Analyze Diet
Chromosoma2012; 121(5); 475-488; doi: 10.1007/s00412-012-0379-4

The catalytic and the RNA subunits of human telomerase are required to immortalize equid primary fibroblasts.

Abstract: Many human primary somatic cells can be immortalized by inducing telomerase activity through the exogenous expression of the human telomerase catalytic subunit (hTERT). This approach has been extended to the immortalization of cell lines from several mammals. Here, we show that hTERT expression is not sufficient to immortalize primary fibroblasts from three equid species, namely donkey, Burchelli's zebra and Grevy's zebra. In vitro analysis of a reconstituted telomerase composed by hTERT and an equid RNA component of telomerase (TERC) revealed a low activity of this enzyme compared to human telomerase, suggesting a low compatibility of equid and human telomerase subunits. This conclusion was also strengthened by comparison of human and equid TERC sequences, which revealed nucleotide differences in key regions for TERC and TERT interaction. We then succeeded in immortalizing equid fibroblasts by expressing hTERT and hTERC concomitantly. Expression of both human telomerase subunits led to telomerase activity and telomere elongation, indicating that human telomerase is compatible with the other equid telomerase subunits and proteins involved in telomere metabolism. The immortalization procedure described herein could be extended to primary cells from other mammals. The availability of immortal cells from endangered species could be particularly useful for obtaining new information on the organization and function of their genomes, which is relevant for their preservation.
Publication Date: 2012-07-14 PubMed ID: 22797876PubMed Central: PMC3443485DOI: 10.1007/s00412-012-0379-4Google Scholar: Lookup
The Equine Research Bank provides access to a large database of publicly available scientific literature. Inclusion in the Research Bank does not imply endorsement of study methods or findings by Mad Barn.
  • Journal Article
  • Research Support
  • Non-U.S. Gov't

Summary

This research summary has been generated with artificial intelligence and may contain errors and omissions. Refer to the original study to confirm details provided. Submit correction.

The research reveals that certain human telomerase parts can be combined with equivalent parts from three equid species to create immortal cell lines, providing implications for further genetic studies and species preservation.

Introduction

  • The study focuses on the possibility of immortalizing primary somatic cells from three equid species: donkeys, Burchelli’s zebras, and Grevy’s zebras.
  • Prior research has demonstrated that many human primary somatic cells can be immortalized by inducing telomerase activity, particularly through expressing the human telomerase catalytic subunit (hTERT).

Methodology

  • The researchers attempted to express hTERT in primary fibroblasts from the three equid species identified.
  • For in vitro analysis, they constructed a version of telomerase that included hTERT and an equid RNA component.

Research Findings

  • Initial attempts showed that hTERT expression was not sufficient to immortalize the equid fibroblasts uncovered in this study.
  • The in vitro analysis revealed that the reconstituted telomerase had a lower activity level compared with the native human telomerase, suggesting limited compatibility between human and equid telomerase components.
  • To further investigate the possible causes of this incompatibility, the researchers compared the human and equid variants of TERC, an RNA component of telomerase seen as critical for its interaction and function.
  • The comparison showed key nucleotide differences, providing further reason behind their incompatibility.

Immortalizing Equid Fibroblasts

  • Despite initial setbacks, the team managed to immortalize equid fibroblasts by expressing both hTERT and hTERC at the same time.
  • This concurrent expression triggered telomerase activity and telomere elongation, suggesting that human telomerase is compatible with other equid telomerase components and key proteins that play a role in telomere maintenance.

Implications and Future Directions

  • The successful immortalization of equid fibroblasts opens doors for the immortalization of primary cells from other mammal species as well.
  • The availability of immortal cells from endangered species could be particularly beneficial for obtaining new information related to genome structure and function in these beings, thereby contributing to their conservation.

Cite This Article

APA
Vidale P, Magnani E, Nergadze SG, Santagostino M, Cristofari G, Smirnova A, Mondello C, Giulotto E. (2012). The catalytic and the RNA subunits of human telomerase are required to immortalize equid primary fibroblasts. Chromosoma, 121(5), 475-488. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00412-012-0379-4

Publication

ISSN: 1432-0886
NlmUniqueID: 2985138R
Country: Austria
Language: English
Volume: 121
Issue: 5
Pages: 475-488

Researcher Affiliations

Vidale, Pamela
  • Dipartimento di Biologia e Biotecnologie Lazzaro Spallanzani, Università degli Studi di Pavia, Via Ferrata 1, 27100, Pavia, Italy.
Magnani, Elisa
    Nergadze, Solomon G
      Santagostino, Marco
        Cristofari, Gael
          Smirnova, Alexandra
            Mondello, Chiara
              Giulotto, Elena

                MeSH Terms

                • Animals
                • Base Sequence
                • Catalytic Domain
                • Cells, Cultured
                • Equidae
                • Fibroblasts / cytology
                • Fibroblasts / metabolism
                • Horses
                • Humans
                • Mice
                • Molecular Sequence Data
                • Protein Subunits / chemistry
                • Protein Subunits / genetics
                • Protein Subunits / metabolism
                • RNA / chemistry
                • RNA / genetics
                • RNA / metabolism
                • Telomerase / chemistry
                • Telomerase / genetics
                • Telomerase / metabolism
                • Telomere / genetics
                • Telomere / metabolism
                • Transfection

                References

                This article includes 46 references
                1. Azzalin CM, Mucciolo E, Bertoni L, Giulotto E. Fluorescence in situ hybridization with a synthetic (T2AG3)n polynucleotide detects several intrachromosomal telomere-like repeats on human chromosomes.. Cytogenet Cell Genet 1997;78(2):112-5.
                  doi: 10.1159/000134640pubmed: 9371401google scholar: lookup
                2. Azzalin CM, Reichenbach P, Khoriauli L, Giulotto E, Lingner J. Telomeric repeat containing RNA and RNA surveillance factors at mammalian chromosome ends.. Science 2007 Nov 2;318(5851):798-801.
                  doi: 10.1126/science.1147182pubmed: 17916692google scholar: lookup
                3. Beattie TL, Zhou W, Robinson MO, Harrington L. Reconstitution of human telomerase activity in vitro.. Curr Biol 1998 Jan 29;8(3):177-80.
                  doi: 10.1016/S0960-9822(98)70067-3pubmed: 9443919google scholar: lookup
                4. Belgiovine C, Chiodi I, Mondello C. Telomerase: cellular immortalization and neoplastic transformation. Multiple functions of a multifaceted complex.. Cytogenet Genome Res 2008;122(3-4):255-62.
                  doi: 10.1159/000167811pubmed: 19188694google scholar: lookup
                5. Bertoni L, Attolini C, Tessera L, Mucciolo E, Giulotto E. Telomeric and nontelomeric (TTAGGG)n sequences in gene amplification and chromosome stability.. Genomics 1994 Nov 1;24(1):53-62.
                  doi: 10.1006/geno.1994.1581pubmed: 7896289google scholar: lookup
                6. Boklan J, Nanjangud G, MacKenzie KL, May C, Sadelain M, Moore MA. Limited proliferation and telomere dysfunction following telomerase inhibition in immortal murine fibroblasts.. Cancer Res 2002 Apr 1;62(7):2104-14.
                  pubmed: 11929832
                7. Buser R, Montesano R, Garcia I, Dupraz P, Pepper MS. Bovine microvascular endothelial cells immortalized with human telomerase.. J Cell Biochem 2006 May 15;98(2):267-86.
                  doi: 10.1002/jcb.20715pubmed: 16408275google scholar: lookup
                8. Chen JL, Greider CW. Determinants in mammalian telomerase RNA that mediate enzyme processivity and cross-species incompatibility.. EMBO J 2003 Jan 15;22(2):304-14.
                  doi: 10.1093/emboj/cdg024pmc: PMC140099pubmed: 12514136google scholar: lookup
                9. Chen JL, Blasco MA, Greider CW. Secondary structure of vertebrate telomerase RNA.. Cell 2000 Mar 3;100(5):503-14.
                  doi: 10.1016/S0092-8674(00)80687-Xpubmed: 10721988google scholar: lookup
                10. Collins K. Physiological assembly and activity of human telomerase complexes.. Mech Ageing Dev 2008 Jan-Feb;129(1-2):91-8.
                  doi: 10.1016/j.mad.2007.10.008pmc: PMC2323683pubmed: 18054989google scholar: lookup
                11. Cristofari G, Lingner J. Telomere length homeostasis requires that telomerase levels are limiting.. EMBO J 2006 Feb 8;25(3):565-74.
                  doi: 10.1038/sj.emboj.7600952pmc: PMC1383536pubmed: 16424902google scholar: lookup
                12. Cristofari G, Adolf E, Reichenbach P, Sikora K, Terns RM, Terns MP, Lingner J. Human telomerase RNA accumulation in Cajal bodies facilitates telomerase recruitment to telomeres and telomere elongation.. Mol Cell 2007 Sep 21;27(6):882-9.
                  doi: 10.1016/j.molcel.2007.07.020pubmed: 17889662google scholar: lookup
                13. Cruz F, Brennan AC, Gonzalez-Voyer A, Muñoz-Fuentes V, Eaaswarkhanth M, Roques S, Picó FX. Genetics and genomics in wildlife studies: implications for ecology, evolution, and conservation biology.. Bioessays 2012 Mar;34(3):245-6.
                  doi: 10.1002/bies.201100171pubmed: 22223439google scholar: lookup
                14. Cui W, Aslam S, Fletcher J, Wylie D, Clinton M, Clark AJ. Stabilization of telomere length and karyotypic stability are directly correlated with the level of hTERT gene expression in primary fibroblasts.. J Biol Chem 2002 Oct 11;277(41):38531-9.
                  doi: 10.1074/jbc.M205981200pubmed: 12122013google scholar: lookup
                15. Cui W, Wylie D, Aslam S, Dinnyes A, King T, Wilmut I, Clark AJ. Telomerase-immortalized sheep fibroblasts can be reprogrammed by nuclear transfer to undergo early development.. Biol Reprod 2003 Jul;69(1):15-21.
                  doi: 10.1095/biolreprod.102.013250pubmed: 12606403google scholar: lookup
                16. Farnung BO, Giulotto E, Azzalin CM. Promoting transcription of chromosome ends.. Transcription 2010 Nov;1(3):140-143.
                  doi: 10.4161/trns.1.3.13191pmc: PMC3023574pubmed: 21326888google scholar: lookup
                17. Feng J, Funk WD, Wang SS, Weinrich SL, Avilion AA, Chiu CP, Adams RR, Chang E, Allsopp RC, Yu J. The RNA component of human telomerase.. Science 1995 Sep 1;269(5228):1236-41.
                  doi: 10.1126/science.7544491pubmed: 7544491google scholar: lookup
                18. Gao K, Lu YR, Wei LL, Lu XF, Li SF, Wan L, Li YP, Cheng JQ. Immortalization of mesenchymal stem cells from bone marrow of rhesus monkey by transfection with human telomerase reverse transcriptase gene.. Transplant Proc 2008 Mar;40(2):634-7.
                19. Garcia CK, Wright WE, Shay JW. Human diseases of telomerase dysfunction: insights into tissue aging.. Nucleic Acids Res 2007;35(22):7406-16.
                  doi: 10.1093/nar/gkm644pmc: PMC2190725pubmed: 17913752google scholar: lookup
                20. Harley CB. Telomerase is not an oncogene.. Oncogene 2002 Jan 21;21(4):494-502.
                  doi: 10.1038/sj.onc.1205076pubmed: 11850774google scholar: lookup
                21. Harley CB. Telomerase and cancer therapeutics.. Nat Rev Cancer 2008 Mar;8(3):167-79.
                  doi: 10.1038/nrc2275pubmed: 18256617google scholar: lookup
                22. Harley CB, Futcher AB, Greider CW. Telomeres shorten during ageing of human fibroblasts.. Nature 1990 May 31;345(6274):458-60.
                  doi: 10.1038/345458a0pubmed: 2342578google scholar: lookup
                23. Masutomi K, Yu EY, Khurts S, Ben-Porath I, Currier JL, Metz GB, Brooks MW, Kaneko S, Murakami S, DeCaprio JA, Weinberg RA, Stewart SA, Hahn WC. Telomerase maintains telomere structure in normal human cells.. Cell 2003 Jul 25;114(2):241-53.
                  doi: 10.1016/S0092-8674(03)00550-6pubmed: 12887925google scholar: lookup
                24. Mondello C, Chiesa M, Rebuzzini P, Zongaro S, Verri A, Colombo T, Giulotto E, D'Incalci M, Franceschi C, Nuzzo F. Karyotype instability and anchorage-independent growth in telomerase-immortalized fibroblasts from two centenarian individuals.. Biochem Biophys Res Commun 2003 Sep 5;308(4):914-21.
                  doi: 10.1016/S0006-291X(03)01484-0pubmed: 12927806google scholar: lookup
                25. Nergadze SG, Magnani E, Attolini C, Bertoni L, Adelson DL, Cappelli K, Verini Supplizi A, Giulotto E. Assignment of the Equus caballus interleukin 8 gene (IL8) to chromosome 3q14.2-->q14.3 by in situ hybridization.. Cytogenet Genome Res 2006;112(3-4):341B.
                  doi: 10.1159/000089892pubmed: 16484794google scholar: lookup
                26. Nergadze SG, Farnung BO, Wischnewski H, Khoriauli L, Vitelli V, Chawla R, Giulotto E, Azzalin CM. CpG-island promoters drive transcription of human telomeres.. RNA 2009 Dec;15(12):2186-94.
                  doi: 10.1261/rna.1748309pmc: PMC2779677pubmed: 19850908google scholar: lookup
                27. Oh HY, Jin X, Kim JG, Oh MJ, Pian X, Kim JM, Yoon MS, Son CI, Lee YS, Hong KC, Kim H, Choi YJ, Whang KY. Characteristics of primary and immortalized fibroblast cells derived from the miniature and domestic pigs.. BMC Cell Biol 2007 Jun 1;8:20.
                  doi: 10.1186/1471-2121-8-20pmc: PMC1894962pubmed: 17543094google scholar: lookup
                28. O'Sullivan RJ, Karlseder J. Telomeres: protecting chromosomes against genome instability.. Nat Rev Mol Cell Biol 2010 Mar;11(3):171-81.
                  doi: 10.1038/nrg2761pmc: PMC2842081pubmed: 20125188google scholar: lookup
                29. Palm W, de Lange T. How shelterin protects mammalian telomeres.. Annu Rev Genet 2008;42:301-34.
                30. Piras FM, Nergadze SG, Poletto V, Cerutti F, Ryder OA, Leeb T, Raimondi E, Giulotto E. Phylogeny of horse chromosome 5q in the genus Equus and centromere repositioning.. Cytogenet Genome Res 2009;126(1-2):165-72.
                  doi: 10.1159/000245916pubmed: 20016166google scholar: lookup
                31. Piras FM, Nergadze SG, Magnani E, Bertoni L, Attolini C, Khoriauli L, Raimondi E, Giulotto E. Uncoupling of satellite DNA and centromeric function in the genus Equus.. PLoS Genet 2010 Feb 12;6(2):e1000845.
                32. Rodier F, Campisi J. Four faces of cellular senescence.. J Cell Biol 2011 Feb 21;192(4):547-56.
                  doi: 10.1083/jcb.201009094pmc: PMC3044123pubmed: 21321098google scholar: lookup
                33. Salzano A, Kochiashvili N, Nergadze SG, Khoriauli L, Smirnova A, Ruiz-Herrera A, Mondello C, Giulotto E. Enhanced gene amplification in human cells knocked down for DNA-PKcs.. DNA Repair (Amst) 2009 Jan 1;8(1):19-28.
                  doi: 10.1016/j.dnarep.2008.08.015pubmed: 18832050google scholar: lookup
                34. Schoeftner S, Blasco MA. Developmentally regulated transcription of mammalian telomeres by DNA-dependent RNA polymerase II.. Nat Cell Biol 2008 Feb;10(2):228-36.
                  doi: 10.1038/ncb1685pubmed: 18157120google scholar: lookup
                35. Seabury CM, Bhattarai EK, Taylor JF, Viswanathan GG, Cooper SM, Davis DS, Dowd SE, Lockwood ML, Seabury PM. Genome-wide polymorphism and comparative analyses in the white-tailed deer (Odocoileus virginianus): a model for conservation genomics.. PLoS One 2011 Jan 19;6(1):e15811.
                36. Serakinci N, Guldberg P, Burns JS, Abdallah B, Schrødder H, Jensen T, Kassem M. Adult human mesenchymal stem cell as a target for neoplastic transformation.. Oncogene 2004 Jun 24;23(29):5095-8.
                  doi: 10.1038/sj.onc.1207651pubmed: 15107831google scholar: lookup
                37. Techangamsuwan S, Kreutzer R, Kreutzer M, Imbschweiler I, Rohn K, Wewetzer K, Baumgärtner W. Transfection of adult canine Schwann cells and olfactory ensheathing cells at early and late passage with human TERT differentially affects growth factor responsiveness and in vitro growth.. J Neurosci Methods 2009 Jan 30;176(2):112-20.
                38. Wade CM, Giulotto E, Sigurdsson S, Zoli M, Gnerre S, Imsland F, Lear TL, Adelson DL, Bailey E, Bellone RR, Blöcker H, Distl O, Edgar RC, Garber M, Leeb T, Mauceli E, MacLeod JN, Penedo MC, Raison JM, Sharpe T, Vogel J, Andersson L, Antczak DF, Biagi T, Binns MM, Chowdhary BP, Coleman SJ, Della Valle G, Fryc S, Guérin G, Hasegawa T, Hill EW, Jurka J, Kiialainen A, Lindgren G, Liu J, Magnani E, Mickelson JR, Murray J, Nergadze SG, Onofrio R, Pedroni S, Piras MF, Raudsepp T, Rocchi M, Røed KH, Ryder OA, Searle S, Skow L, Swinburne JE, Syvänen AC, Tozaki T, Valberg SJ, Vaudin M, White JR, Zody MC, Lander ES, Lindblad-Toh K. Genome sequence, comparative analysis, and population genetics of the domestic horse.. Science 2009 Nov 6;326(5954):865-7.
                  doi: 10.1126/science.1178158pmc: PMC3785132pubmed: 19892987google scholar: lookup
                39. Wang J, Hannon GJ, Beach DH. Risky immortalization by telomerase.. Nature 2000 Jun 15;405(6788):755-6.
                  doi: 10.1038/35013171pubmed: 10866187google scholar: lookup
                40. Wang J, Feng H, Huang XQ, Xiang H, Mao YW, Liu JP, Yan Q, Liu WB, Liu Y, Deng M, Gong L, Sun S, Luo C, Liu SJ, Zhang XJ, Liu Y, Li DW. Human telomerase reverse transcriptase immortalizes bovine lens epithelial cells and suppresses differentiation through regulation of the ERK signaling pathway.. J Biol Chem 2005 Jun 17;280(24):22776-87.
                  doi: 10.1074/jbc.M500032200pubmed: 15849192google scholar: lookup
                41. Weinrich SL, Pruzan R, Ma L, Ouellette M, Tesmer VM, Holt SE, Bodnar AG, Lichtsteiner S, Kim NW, Trager JB, Taylor RD, Carlos R, Andrews WH, Wright WE, Shay JW, Harley CB, Morin GB. Reconstitution of human telomerase with the template RNA component hTR and the catalytic protein subunit hTRT.. Nat Genet 1997 Dec;17(4):498-502.
                  doi: 10.1038/ng1297-498pubmed: 9398860google scholar: lookup
                42. Wolinsky H. Wildlife forensics. Genomics has become a powerful tool to inform conservation measures.. EMBO Rep 2012 Apr 2;13(4):308-12.
                  doi: 10.1038/embor.2012.35pmc: PMC3321165pubmed: 22422002google scholar: lookup
                43. Xiang H, Wang J, Mao YW, Li DW. hTERT can function with rabbit telomerase RNA: regulation of gene expression and attenuation of apoptosis.. Biochem Biophys Res Commun 2000 Nov 30;278(3):503-10.
                  doi: 10.1006/bbrc.2000.3834pubmed: 11095941google scholar: lookup
                44. Xin H, Liu D, Songyang Z. The telosome/shelterin complex and its functions.. Genome Biol 2008;9(9):232.
                  doi: 10.1186/gb-2008-9-9-232pmc: PMC2592706pubmed: 18828880google scholar: lookup
                45. Yi X, Tesmer VM, Savre-Train I, Shay JW, Wright WE. Both transcriptional and posttranscriptional mechanisms regulate human telomerase template RNA levels.. Mol Cell Biol 1999 Jun;19(6):3989-97.
                  pmc: PMC104358pubmed: 10330139doi: 10.1128/MCB.19.6.3989google scholar: lookup
                46. Zongaro S, de Stanchina E, Colombo T, D'Incalci M, Giulotto E, Mondello C. Stepwise neoplastic transformation of a telomerase immortalized fibroblast cell line.. Cancer Res 2005 Dec 15;65(24):11411-8.
                  doi: 10.1158/0008-5472.CAN-05-1140pubmed: 16357149google scholar: lookup

                Citations

                This article has been cited 10 times.
                1. Piras FM, Cappelletti E, Abdelgadir WA, Salamon G, Vignati S, Santagostino M, Sola L, Nergadze SG, Giulotto E. A Satellite-Free Centromere in Equus przewalskii Chromosome 10. Int J Mol Sci 2023 Feb 18;24(4).
                  doi: 10.3390/ijms24044134pubmed: 36835543google scholar: lookup
                2. Piras FM, Cappelletti E, Santagostino M, Nergadze SG, Giulotto E, Raimondi E. Molecular Dynamics and Evolution of Centromeres in the Genus Equus. Int J Mol Sci 2022 Apr 10;23(8).
                  doi: 10.3390/ijms23084183pubmed: 35457002google scholar: lookup
                3. Promjantuek W, Chaicharoenaudomrung N, Phonchai R, Kunhorm P, Noisa P. Transgenic Immortalization of Human Dermal Fibroblasts Mediated Through the MicroRNA/SIRT1 Pathway. In Vivo 2022 Jan-Feb;36(1):140-152.
                  doi: 10.21873/invivo.12685pubmed: 34972709google scholar: lookup
                4. Jiang QX. Single-Run Catalysis and Kinetic Control of Human Telomerase Holoenzyme. Adv Exp Med Biol 2022;1371:109-129.
                  doi: 10.1007/5584_2021_676pubmed: 34962637google scholar: lookup
                5. Santagostino M, Piras FM, Cappelletti E, Del Giudice S, Semino O, Nergadze SG, Giulotto E. Insertion of Telomeric Repeats in the Human and Horse Genomes: An Evolutionary Perspective. Int J Mol Sci 2020 Apr 18;21(8).
                  doi: 10.3390/ijms21082838pubmed: 32325780google scholar: lookup
                6. Fukuda T, Eitsuka T, Donai K, Kurita M, Saito T, Okamoto H, Kinoshita K, Katayama M, Nitto H, Uchida T, Onuma M, Sone H, Inoue-Murayama M, Kiyono T. Expression of human mutant cyclin dependent kinase 4, Cyclin D and telomerase extends the life span but does not immortalize fibroblasts derived from loggerhead sea turtle (Caretta caretta). Sci Rep 2018 Jun 20;8(1):9229.
                  doi: 10.1038/s41598-018-27271-xpubmed: 29925962google scholar: lookup
                7. Nergadze SG, Piras FM, Gamba R, Corbo M, Cerutti F, McCarter JGW, Cappelletti E, Gozzo F, Harman RM, Antczak DF, Miller D, Scharfe M, Pavesi G, Raimondi E, Sullivan KF, Giulotto E. Birth, evolution, and transmission of satellite-free mammalian centromeric domains. Genome Res 2018 Jun;28(6):789-799.
                  doi: 10.1101/gr.231159.117pubmed: 29712753google scholar: lookup
                8. Santagostino M, Khoriauli L, Gamba R, Bonuglia M, Klipstein O, Piras FM, Vella F, Russo A, Badiale C, Mazzagatti A, Raimondi E, Nergadze SG, Giulotto E. Genome-wide evolutionary and functional analysis of the Equine Repetitive Element 1: an insertion in the myostatin promoter affects gene expression. BMC Genet 2015 Oct 26;16:126.
                  doi: 10.1186/s12863-015-0281-1pubmed: 26503543google scholar: lookup
                9. Cappelletti E, Piras FM, Biundo M, Raimondi E, Nergadze SG, Giulotto E. CENP-A/CENP-B uncoupling in the evolutionary reshuffling of centromeres in equids. Genome Biol 2025 Feb 6;26(1):23.
                  doi: 10.1186/s13059-025-03490-0pubmed: 39915813google scholar: lookup
                10. Tani T. Immortalization of American miniature horse-derived fibroblast by cell cycle regulator with normal karyotype. PeerJ 2024;12:e16832.
                  doi: 10.7717/peerj.16832pubmed: 38288466google scholar: lookup