FREE SHIPPING over $40
OVER 9000 FIVE-STAR REVIEWS
5% OFF ALL SUBSCRIPTIONS
100% HAPPINESS GUARANTEE
Analyze Diet
0
Home / Equine Research Bank / Vet Rec / Application of the horse grimace scale in horses with dental...
The Veterinary record2024; 196(3); e4800; doi: 10.1002/vetr.4800

Application of the horse grimace scale in horses with dental disease: Preliminary findings.

Abstract: Dental disease is a common but often under-recognised condition in horses, possibly due to an inability to recognise clinical signs of oral discomfort. Some dental disorders are reportedly more painful than others, but there is no current metric by which dental pain can be objectively assessed. This study aimed to determine whether a facial expression-based pain scale offered an objective and reliable method for assessing dental pain in horses. It was hypothesised that dental disorders affecting the periodontium would produce high pain scores. Twelve horses with dental disease were evaluated for pain using a numerical rating scale (NRS) and a horse grimace scale (HGS) by blinded observers using still, lateral photographs. Interobserver reliability was poor across all observers when both the NRS (intraclass correlation coefficient [ICC] = 0.36) and the HGS (ICC = 0.27) were used in horses with dental disease. The highest mean scores were given for horses with equine odontoclastic tooth resorption and hypercementosis (EOTRH) and periodontal disease (PD). This study has a small sample size of both horses and questionnaire respondents, and the respondent demographics are not representative of the wider veterinary population Furthermore, no positive or negative controls were used for the pain scoring. The results of this study indicate the unreliability of tools designed for identifying acute pain for assessing chronic pain, such as dental pain. A more dental-specific ethogram is required to accurately identify dental pain in horses. Both the NRS and HGS produced the highest mean scores for EOTRH and PD, supporting existing literature that these conditions are associated with more obvious signs of pain.
© 2024 British Veterinary Association.
Get Full Text
Publication Date: 2024-11-09 PubMed ID: 39520383PubMed Central: PMC11783995DOI: 10.1002/vetr.4800Google Scholar: Lookup
The Equine Research Bank provides access to a large database of publicly available scientific literature. Inclusion in the Research Bank does not imply endorsement of study methods or findings by Mad Barn.
LinkedInCopy
  • Journal Article

Summary

This research summary has been generated with artificial intelligence and may contain errors and omissions. Refer to the original study to confirm details provided. Submit correction.

The research investigates the reliability of facial expression-based pain scales, including the horse grimace scale (HGS), for evaluating dental pain in horses. It suggests that these scales may not be reliable for assessing chronic pain like dental discomfort, calling for more specialized tools.

Study Objectives and Methodology

  • The primary objective of the research was to determine if a facial expression-based pain scale offers a dependable and unbiased method for assessing dental pain in horses. More specifically, it was hypothesized that dental disorders impacting the periodontium would yield high pain scores.
  • The methodology involved evaluating twelve horses suffering from dental disease for pain using a numerical rating scale (NRS) and a horse grimace scale (HGS). The evaluation was conducted by blinded observers using static, lateral photographs.

Results and Findings

  • The study found that interobserver reliability was low across all observers, whether using the NRS or HGS for horses with dental disease.
  • The highest mean scores were given to horses suffering from equine odontoclastic tooth resorption and hypercementosis (EOTRH) and periodontal disease (PD).
  • However, the researchers acknowledged that several limitations may have affected the results, notably the small sample size of both horses and questionnaire respondents and unrepresentative respondent demographics. The study also lacked positive or negative controls for the pain scoring.

Conclusions and Implications

  • The study concluded that tools designed for identifying acute pain, such as the NRS and HGS, may not be reliable for assessing chronic pain like dental pain in horses.
  • The researchers suggested that a more dental-specific ethogram is needed to accurately detect dental pain.
  • Despite the identified limitations, the study found that both the NRS and HGS gave the highest mean scores for EOTRH and PD, supporting existing literature that these conditions are accompanied by more notable signs of pain.
  • These findings indicate a need for further research to develop, refine, and validate more specific and reliable tools for assessing dental pain in horses.

Cite This Article

APA
Sidwell AE, Duz M, Hill B, Freeman S, Hole SL. (2024). Application of the horse grimace scale in horses with dental disease: Preliminary findings. Vet Rec, 196(3), e4800. https://doi.org/10.1002/vetr.4800

Publication

The Veterinary record
ISSN: 2042-7670
NlmUniqueID: 0031164
Country: England
Language: English
Volume: 196
Issue: 3
Pages: e4800

Researcher Affiliations

Sidwell, Amelia E
  • School of Veterinary Medicine and Science, University of Nottingham, Sutton Bonington, UK.
  • Pool House Equine Hospital, Fradley, UK.
Duz, Marco
  • School of Veterinary Medicine and Science, University of Nottingham, Sutton Bonington, UK.
Hill, Bradley
  • School of Veterinary Medicine and Science, University of Nottingham, Sutton Bonington, UK.
Freeman, Sarah
  • School of Veterinary Medicine and Science, University of Nottingham, Sutton Bonington, UK.
Hole, Sam L
  • Pool House Equine Hospital, Fradley, UK.

MeSH Terms

  • Animals
  • Horses
  • Horse Diseases / diagnosis
  • Pain Measurement / veterinary
  • Pain Measurement / methods
  • Reproducibility of Results
  • Female
  • Male
  • Facial Expression
  • Stomatognathic Diseases / veterinary
  • Stomatognathic Diseases / diagnosis
  • Observer Variation
  • Tooth Diseases / veterinary
  • Tooth Diseases / diagnosis

Conflict of Interest Statement

The authors declare they have no conflicts of interest.

References

This article includes 51 references
  1. O'Neill DG, Church DB, McGreevy PD, Thomson PC, Brodbelt DC. Prevalence of disorders recorded in cats attending primary‐care veterinary practices in England.. Vet J 2014;202(2):286–291.
    pubmed: 25178688
  2. Brigham EJ, Duncanson GR. Case study of 100 horses presented to an equine dental technician in the UK.. Equine Vet Educ 2000;12(2):63–67.
  3. Dixon PM, Dacre I. A review of equine dental disorders.. Vet J 2005;169(2):165–187.
    pubmed: 15727909
  4. Dixon PM, Tremaine WH, Pickles K, Kuhns L, Hawe C, McCann J. Equine dental disease. Part 3: A long‐term study of 400 cases: disorders of wear, traumatic damage and idiopathic fractures, tumours and miscellaneous disorders of the cheek teeth.. Equine Vet J 2000;32(1):9–18.
    pubmed: 10661379
  5. Rowley KJ, Townsend NB, Chang YR, Fiske‐Jackson AR. A computed tomographic study of endodontic and apical changes in 81 equine cheek teeth with sagittal fractures.. Equine Vet J 2022;54(3):541–548.
    pubmed: 34060137
  6. Taylor L, Dixon PM. Equine idiopathic cheek teeth fractures. Part 2: A practice‐based survey of 147 affected horses in Britain and Ireland.. Equine Vet J 2007;39(4):322–326.
    pubmed: 17722723
  7. Dixon PM, Kennedy R, Reardon RJM. Equine 'idiopathic' and infundibular caries‐related cheek teeth fractures: a long‐term study of 486 fractured teeth in 300 horses.. Front Vet Sci 2021;8:646870.
    pmc: PMC8192706pubmed: 34124217
  8. von Borstel UK, Glißman C. Alternatives to conventional evaluation of rideability in horse performance tests: suitability of rein tension and behavioural parameters.. PLoS ONE 2014;9(1):e87285.
    pmc: PMC3906164pubmed: 24489890
  9. Dyson S, Berger J, Ellis AD, Mullard J. Development of an ethogram for a pain scoring system in ridden horses and its application to determine the presence of musculoskeletal pain.. J Vet Behav 2018;23:47–57.
  10. Pehkonen J, Karma L, Raekallio M. Behavioral signs associated with equine periapical infection in cheek teeth.. J Equine Vet Sci 2019;77:144–150.
    pubmed: 31133309
  11. Sellon DC, Sanz M, Kopper JJ, Mattei D. Pain severity scores for common equine disorders as provided by horse owners and equine veterinarians.. Equine Vet J 2022;54(6):1094–1102.
    pubmed: 35034381
  12. Hugonnard M, Leblond A, Keroack S, Cadoré J, Troncy E. Attitudes and concerns of French veterinarians towards pain and analgesia in dogs and cats.. Vet Anaesth Analg 2004;31(3):154–163.
    pubmed: 15268686
  13. Morales‐Vallecilla C, Ramírez N, Villar D, Díaz M, Bustamante S, Ferguson D. Survey of pain knowledge and analgesia in dogs and cats by Colombian veterinarians.. Vet Sci 2019;6(1):6.
    pmc: PMC6466334pubmed: 30634671
  14. Torcivia C, McDonnell S. Equine discomfort ethogram.. Animals 2021;11(2):580.
    pmc: PMC7931104pubmed: 33672338
  15. Torcivia C, McDonnell S. In‐person caretaker visits disrupt ongoing discomfort behavior in hospitalized equine orthopedic surgical patients.. Animals 2020;10(2):210.
    pmc: PMC7070845pubmed: 32012670
  16. Cohen S, Beths T. Grimace scores: tools to support the identification of pain in mammals used in research.. Animals 2020;10(10):1726.
    pmc: PMC7598254pubmed: 32977561
  17. Taylor PM, Pascoe PJ, Mama KR. Diagnosing and treating pain in the horse. Where are we today?. Vet Clin North Am Equine Pract 2002;18:1‒19.
    pubmed: 12064173
  18. Cohn JF, Ambadar Z, Ekman P. Observer‐based measurement of facial expression with the facial action coding system.. 2007. p. 203–221.
  19. Orth EK, Navas González FJ, Iglesias Pastrana C, Berger JM, Jeune SSL, Davis EW. Development of a donkey grimace scale to recognize pain in donkeys (Equus asinus) post castration.. Animals 2020;10(8):1411.
    pmc: PMC7459673pubmed: 32823676
  20. Dalla Costa E, Minero M, Lebelt D, Stucke D, Canali E, Leach MC. Development of the horse grimace scale (HGS) as a pain assessment tool in horses undergoing routine castration.. PLoS One 2014;9(3):e92281.
    pmc: PMC3960217pubmed: 24647606
  21. van Loon JPAM, Van Dierendonck MC. Monitoring equine head‐related pain with the equine Utrecht University scale for facial assessment of pain (EQUUS‐FAP).. Vet J 2017;220:88–90.
    pubmed: 28190503
  22. Evangelista MC, Monteiro BP, Steagall PV. Measurement properties of grimace scales for pain assessment in nonhuman mammals: a systematic review.. Pain 2022;163(6):e697–e714.
    pubmed: 34510132
  23. Langford DJ, Bailey AL, Chanda ML, Clarke SE, Drummond TE, Echols S. Coding of facial expressions of pain in the laboratory mouse.. Nat Methods 2010;7(6):447–449.
    pubmed: 20453868
  24. Sotocina SG, Sorge RE, Zaloum A, Tuttle AH, Martin LJ, Wieskopf JS. The rat grimace scale: a partially automated method for quantifying pain in the laboratory rat via facial expressions.. Mol Pain 2011;7:55.
    pmc: PMC3163602pubmed: 21801409
  25. De Grauw JC, van Loon JPAM. Systematic pain assessment in horses.. Vet J 2016;209:14–22.
    pubmed: 26831169
  26. Mogil JS, Pang DSJ, Silva Dutra GG, Chambers CT. The development and use of facial grimace scales for pain measurement in animals.. Neurosci Biobehav Rev 2020;116:480–493.
    pubmed: 32682741
  27. Sperry MM, Yu YH, Welch RL, Granquist EJ, Winkelstein BA. Grading facial expression is a sensitive means to detect grimace differences in orofacial pain in a rat model.. Sci Rep 2018;8(1):13894.
    pmc: PMC6141616pubmed: 30224708
  28. Watanabe R, Doodnaught GM, Evangelista MC, Monteiro BP, Ruel HLM, Steagall PV. Inter‐rater reliability of the feline grimace scale in cats undergoing dental extractions.. Front Vet Sci 2020;7:302.
    pmc: PMC7272704pubmed: 32548134
  29. Rojo R, Prados‐Frutos JC, López‐Valverde A. Pain assessment using the facial action coding system. A systematic review.. Med Clin Engl Ed 2015;145(8):350–355.
    pubmed: 25433779
  30. Coneglian MM, Duarte Borges T, Weber SH, Godoi Bertagnon H, Michelotto PV. Use of the horse grimace scale to identify and quantify pain due to dental disorders in horses.. Appl Anim Behav Sci 2020;225:104970.
  31. Coneglian MM, Weber SH, Michelotto Junior PV. Influence of oral health on the facial expressions and on the acupuncture examination in equines.. Arq Bras Med Vet Zootec 2023;75(3):415–424.
  32. Limone LE. Update on equine odontoclastic tooth resorption and hypercementosis.. Vet Clin North Am Equine Pract 2020;36(3):671–689.
    pubmed: 33067098
  33. Kennedy RS, Dixon PM. The aetiopathogenesis of equine periodontal disease—a fresh perspective.. Equine Vet Educ 2018;30(3):161–168.
  34. Dalla Costa E, Bracci D, Dai F, Lebelt D, Minero M. Do different emotional states affect the horse grimace scale score? A pilot study.. J Equine Vet Sci 2017;54:114–117.
  35. Van Loon JPAM, Van Dierendonck MC. Monitoring acute equine visceral pain with the Equine Utrecht University Scale for Composite Pain Assessment (EQUUS‐COMPASS) and the Equine Utrecht University Scale for Facial Assessment of Pain (EQUUS‐FAP): a scale‐construction study.. Vet J 2015;206(3):356–364.
    pubmed: 26526526
  36. Van Loon JPAM, Macri L. Objective assessment of chronic pain in horses using the horse chronic pain scale (HCPS): a scale‐construction study.. Animals 2021;11(6):1826.
    pmc: PMC8234780pubmed: 34207290
  37. Dalla Costa E, Stucke D, Dai F, Minero M, Leach M, Lebelt D. Using the horse grimace scale (HGS) to assess pain associated with acute laminitis in horses (Equus caballus).. Animals 2016;6(8):47.
    pmc: PMC4997272pubmed: 27527224
  38. Luke SG. Evaluating significance in linear mixed‐effects models in R.. Behav Res Methods 2017;49(4):1494–1502.
    pubmed: 27620283
  39. Koo TK, Li MY. A guideline for selecting and reporting intraclass correlation coefficients for reliability research.. J Chiropr Med 2016;15(2):155–163.
    pmc: PMC4913118pubmed: 27330520
  40. Sutton GA, Paltiel O, Soffer M, Turner D. Validation of two behaviour‐based pain scales for horses with acute colic.. Vet J 2013;197(3):646–650.
    pubmed: 23993390
  41. McKeown R. Validation of the horse grimace scale: exploring the effects of training and previous experience.. .
  42. Dai F, Leach M, MacRae AM, Minero M, Dalla Costa E. Does thirty‐minute standardised training improve the inter‐observer reliability of the horse grimace scale (HGS)? A case study.. Animals 2020;10(5):781.
    pmc: PMC7277819pubmed: 32365927
  43. Anderson KA, Morrice‐West AV, Wong ASM, Walmsley EA, Fisher AD, Whitton RC. Poor association between facial expression and mild lameness in thoroughbred trot‐up examinations.. Animals 2023;13(11):1727.
    pmc: PMC10251806pubmed: 37889660
  44. Gregory NS, Harris AL, Robinson CR, Dougherty PM, Fuchs PN, Sluka KA. An overview of animal models of pain: disease models and outcome measures.. J Pain 2013;14(11):1255–1269.
    pmc: PMC3818391pubmed: 24035349
  45. Thomsen PT, Anneberg I, Herskin MS. Differences in attitudes of farmers and veterinarians towards pain in dairy cows.. Vet J 2012;194(1):94–97.
    pubmed: 22516921
  46. Beswick A, Dewey C, Johnson R, Dowsett‐Cooper J, Niel L. Survey of Ontario veterinarians’ knowledge and attitudes on pain in dogs and cats in 2012.. Can Vet J 2016;57:1274‒1280.
    pmc: PMC5109631pubmed: 27928175
  47. Dohoo SE, Dohoo IR. Factors influencing the postoperative use of analgesics in dogs and cats by Canadian veterinarians.. Can Vet J 1996;37:552‒556.
    pmc: PMC1576376pubmed: 8877041
  48. Lorello O, Foster DL, Levine DG, Boyle A, Engiles J, Orsini JA. Clinical treatment and prognosis of equine odontoclastic tooth resorption and hypercementosis.. Equine Vet J 2016;48(2):188–194.
    pubmed: 25557855
  49. Rahmani V, Häyrinen L, Kareinen I, Ruohoniemi M. History, clinical findings and outcome of horses with radiographical signs of equine odontoclastic tooth resorption and hypercementosis.. Vet Rec 2019;185(23):730.
    pmc: PMC7008772pubmed: 31601733
  50. Hole SL, Staszyk C. Equine odontoclastic tooth resorption and hypercementosis.. Equine Vet Educ 2018;30(7):386–391.
    pubmed: 29067719
  51. Dixon PM, Tremaine WH, Pickles K, Kuhns L, Hawe C, McCann J. Equine dental disease. Part 2: a long‐term study of 400 cases: disorders of development and eruption and variations in position of the cheek teeth.. Equine Vet J 1999;31(6):519–528.
    pubmed: 10596936
Subscribe to our newsletter
Join 99,344 horse owners like you who receive our email updates on horse health and nutrition.