Differentiating human bone from animal bone: a review of histological methods.
- Journal Article
- Review
Summary
The research article represents a comprehensive review on the possibility of differentiating human bone from various animal bones using their histological characteristics, specifically focusing on the appearance of cortical bone.
Objective of the Study
The objective of the study was to compile and analyze extensive literature to address the question of whether it is possible to distinguish human from non-human bone based on the histological appearance of cortical bone.
Wide Range of Animal Species
- The review includes a variety of mammalian species that are commonly found in North American or Eurasian forensic assemblages. These include rat, hare, badger, racoon dog, cat, dog, pig, cow, goat, sheep, deer, horse, water buffalo, bear, non-human primates, and human.
Findings of the Study
The review identifies and analyzes the distinct histological properties of different species’ cortical bone tissue:
- The research finds that differentiation of human from some non-human species is indeed possible. For instance, small mammals such as rats and hares exhibit Haversian bone tissue, a type of tissue unique to these species.
- Similarly, large mammals like bears and non-human primates show plexiform bone tissue, another distinct histological characteristic, thereby allowing differentiation.
- However, for some species like pigs, cows, goats, sheep, horses, and water buffaloes that exhibit both plexiform and Haversian bone tissue, differentiation from humans is not possible when only Haversian bone tissue exists in bone fragments.
- Furthermore, the research points out that the Haversian bone tissue in other primates is also indistinguishable from humans.
Recommendations for Bone Differentiation
- The study further recommends that where differentiation using Haversian bone tissue is undertaken, both the general microstructural appearance and measurements of histological structures should be considered.
- Haversian system diameter and Haversian canal diameter have been identified as the most diagnostic measurements to use for distinction.
- To provide an upper and lower limit for humans, the application of the Haversian system density is recommended.
In conclusion, this comprehensive review highlights the potential and limitations of using histological methods to differentiate human bone from certain animal bones.
Cite This Article
Publication
Researcher Affiliations
- Department of Archaeology, Simon Fraser University, 8888 University Drive, Burnaby, BC, Canada, V5A 1S6.
MeSH Terms
- Age Determination by Skeleton
- Animals
- Bone and Bones / anatomy & histology
- Buffaloes
- Cats
- Cattle
- Deer
- Dogs
- Forensic Anthropology / methods
- Goats
- Horses
- Humans
- Microscopy, Electron, Scanning
- Mustelidae
- Postmortem Changes
- Primates
- Rabbits
- Raccoon Dogs
- Rats
- Sex Characteristics
- Sheep
- Species Specificity
- Swine
Citations
This article has been cited 72 times.- Daniel CR, Taylor SE, McPhee S, Wolfram U, Schwarz T, Sommer S, Kershaw LE. Relationship between CT-Derived Bone Mineral Density and UTE-MR-Derived Porosity Index in Equine Third Metacarpal and Metatarsal Bones. Animals (Basel) 2023 Aug 31;13(17).
- Waltenberger L, Bosch MD, Fritzl M, Gahleitner A, Kurzmann C, Piniel M, Salisbury RB, Strnad L, Skerjanz H, Verdianu D, Snoeck C, Kanz F, Rebay-Salisbury K. More than urns: A multi-method pipeline for analyzing cremation burials. PLoS One 2023;18(8):e0289140.
- He T, Pang Z, Yin Y, Xue H, Pang Y, Song H, Li J, Bai R, Qin A, Kong X. Micron-resolution Imaging of Cortical Bone under 14 T Ultrahigh Magnetic Field. Adv Sci (Weinh) 2023 Aug;10(24):e2300959.
- Littek A, McKenna SJ, Chiam WX, Kranioti EF, Trucco E, García-Donas JG. Automatic Segmentation of Osteonal Microstructure in Human Cortical Bone Using Deep Learning: A Proof of Concept. Biology (Basel) 2023 Apr 19;12(4).
- Koch DW, Johnson JW, Smith QE, Brekhus C, Gadomski BC, Palmer RH, Easley JT, Nelson BB. Biomechanical evaluation of interlocking nail and locking compression plating for stabilization of ovine critical-sized segmental tibia defects. Ann Transl Med 2023 Mar 31;11(6):258.
- Gao H, Huang J, Wei Q, He C. Advances in Animal Models for Studying Bone Fracture Healing. Bioengineering (Basel) 2023 Feb 3;10(2).
- Duits A, Salvatori D, Schouten J, van Urk P, Gaalen SV, Ottink K, Öner C, Kruyt M. Preclinical model for lumbar interbody fusion in small ruminants: Rationale and guideline. J Orthop Translat 2023 Jan;38:167-174.
- Karydi C, García-Donas JG, Tsiminikaki K, Bonicelli A, Moraitis K, Kranioti EF. Estimation of Age-at-Death Using Cortical Bone Histomorphometry of the Rib and Femur: A Validation Study on a British Population. Biology (Basel) 2022 Nov 4;11(11).
- Dias IE, Viegas CA, Requicha JF, Saavedra MJ, Azevedo JM, Carvalho PP, Dias IR. Mesenchymal Stem Cell Studies in the Goat Model for Biomedical Research-A Review of the Scientific Literature. Biology (Basel) 2022 Aug 27;11(9).
- Johansson ML, Shah FA, Eeg-Olofsson M, Monksfield P, Thomsen P, Palmquist A. Long-term osseointegration of laser-ablated hearing implants in sheep cranial bone. Front Surg 2022;9:885964.
- Ferri G, Corradini B, Gianfreda D, Ferrari F, Silingardi E. Two caseworks for one gene: successful species identification from compromised bone materials with the 12S rRNA. Int J Legal Med 2022 Sep;136(5):1255-1260.
- Garvin HM, Dunn R, Sholts SB, Litten MS, Mohamed M, Kuttickat N, Skantz N. Forensic Tools for Species Identification of Skeletal Remains: Metrics, Statistics, and OsteoID. Biology (Basel) 2021 Dec 25;11(1).
- Bacci N, Augustine TN, Hunt HGP, Nixon KJ, Hoffman J, Bam L, de Beer F, Randolph-Quinney P. Harnessing Thor's Hammer: Experimentally induced lightning trauma to human bone by high impulse current. Forensic Sci Int Synerg 2021;3:100206.
- Blanc-Sylvestre N, Bouchard P, Chaussain C, Bardet C. Pre-Clinical Models in Implant Dentistry: Past, Present, Future. Biomedicines 2021 Oct 26;9(11).
- Gigante M, Nava A, Paine RR, Fiore I, Alhaique F, Esposito CM, Sperduti A, Bonetto J, Cinquantaquattro TE, d'Agostino B, Bondioli L. Who was buried with Nestor's Cup? Macroscopic and microscopic analyses of the cremated remains from Tomb 168 (second half of the 8th century BCE, Pithekoussai, Ischia Island, Italy). PLoS One 2021;16(10):e0257368.
- Gemini L, Al-Bourgol S, Machinet G, Bakkali A, Faucon M, Kling R. Ablation of Bone Tissue by Femtosecond Laser: A Path to High-Resolution Bone Surgery. Materials (Basel) 2021 May 7;14(9).
- Hajihoseini N, Rezvani G, Etemad-Moghadam S. Comparison of routine and microwave-assisted decalcification of bone with or without teeth: A histologic study. Dent Res J (Isfahan) 2020 Nov-Dec;17(6):452-458.
- Palombo MR, Zedda M. The intriguing giant deer from the Bate cave (Crete): could paleohistological evidence question its taxonomy and nomenclature?. Integr Zool 2022 Jan;17(1):54-77.
- Montoya-Sanhueza G, Bennett NC, Oosthuizen MK, Dengler-Crish CM, Chinsamy A. Bone remodeling in the longest living rodent, the naked mole-rat: Interelement variation and the effects of reproduction. J Anat 2021 Jul;239(1):81-100.
- Amaroli A, Colombo E, Zekiy A, Aicardi S, Benedicenti S, De Angelis N. Interaction between Laser Light and Osteoblasts: Photobiomodulation as a Trend in the Management of Socket Bone Preservation-A Review. Biology (Basel) 2020 Nov 23;9(11).
- Song D, Shujaat S, Zhao R, Huang Y, Shaheen E, Van Dessel J, Orhan K, Vande Velde G, Coropciuc R, Pauwels R, Politis C, Jacobs R. In vivo quantification of mandibular bone remodeling and vascular changes in a Wistar rat model: A novel HR-MRI and micro-CT fusion technique. Imaging Sci Dent 2020 Sep;50(3):199-208.
- Taguchi T, Lopez MJ. An overview of de novo bone generation in animal models. J Orthop Res 2021 Jan;39(1):7-21.
- Stokes S, Márquez-Grant N, Greenwood C. Establishing a minimum PMI for bone sun bleaching in a UK environment with a controlled desert-simulated comparison. Int J Legal Med 2020 Nov;134(6):2297-2306.
- Nguyen JT, Barak MM. Secondary osteon structural heterogeneity between the cranial and caudal cortices of the proximal humerus in white-tailed deer. J Exp Biol 2020 Jun 11;223(Pt 11).
- Trolle Jensen TZ, Mackie M, Taurozzi AJ, Lanigan LT, Gundelach C, Olsen J, Sørensen SA, Collins MJ, Sørensen M, Schroeder H. The biomolecular characterization of a finger ring contextually dated to the emergence of the Early Neolithic from Syltholm, Denmark. R Soc Open Sci 2020 Jan;7(1):191172.
- Yamashita J, McCauley LK. Effects of Intermittent Administration of Parathyroid Hormone and Parathyroid Hormone-Related Protein on Fracture Healing: A Narrative Review of Animal and Human Studies. JBMR Plus 2019 Dec;3(12):e10250.
- Szalma J, Lovász BV, Vajta L, Soós B, Lempel E, Möhlhenrich SC. The influence of the chosen in vitro bone simulation model on intraosseous temperatures and drilling times. Sci Rep 2019 Aug 14;9(1):11817.
- Cummaudo M, Cappella A, Giacomini F, Raffone C, Màrquez-Grant N, Cattaneo C. Histomorphometric analysis of osteocyte lacunae in human and pig: exploring its potential for species discrimination. Int J Legal Med 2019 May;133(3):711-718.
- Bradfield J. Identifying animal taxa used to manufacture bone tools during the Middle Stone Age at Sibudu, South Africa: Results of a CT-rendered histological analysis. PLoS One 2018;13(11):e0208319.
- Matusin DP, Fontes-Pereira AJ, Rosa PTCR, Barboza T, de Souza SAL, von Krüger MA, Pereira WCA. EXPLORING CORTICAL BONE DENSITY THROUGH THE ULTRASOUND INTEGRATED REFLECTION COEFFICIENT. Acta Ortop Bras 2018;26(4):255-259.
- Föger-Samwald U, Knecht C, Stimpfl T, Szekeres T, Kerschan-Schindl K, Mikosch P, Pietschmann P, Sipos W. Bone Effects of Binge Alcohol Drinking Using Prepubescent Pigs as a Model. Alcohol Clin Exp Res 2018 Nov;42(11):2123-2135.
- Thitaram C, Matchimakul P, Pongkan W, Tangphokhanon W, Maktrirat R, Khonmee J, Sathanawongs A, Kongtueng P, Nganvongpanit K. Histology of 24 organs from Asian elephant calves (Elephas maximus). PeerJ 2018;6:e4947.
- Cummaudo M, Cappella A, Biraghi M, Raffone C, Màrquez-Grant N, Cattaneo C. Histomorphological analysis of the variability of the human skeleton: forensic implications. Int J Legal Med 2018 Sep;132(5):1493-1503.
- Johnson V, Beckett S, Márquez-Grant N. Differentiating human versus non-human bone by exploring the nutrient foramen: implications for forensic anthropology. Int J Legal Med 2017 Nov;131(6):1757-1763.
- Hsu DJ, Lee CW, Tsai WC, Chien YC. Essential and toxic metals in animal bone broths. Food Nutr Res 2017;61(1):1347478.
- Cohen H, Kugel C, May H, Medlej B, Stein D, Slon V, Brosh T, Hershkovitz I. The effect of impact tool geometry and soft material covering on long bone fracture patterns in children. Int J Legal Med 2017 Jul;131(4):1011-1021.
- Montoya-Sanhueza G, Chinsamy A. Long bone histology of the subterranean rodent Bathyergus suillus (Bathyergidae): ontogenetic pattern of cortical bone thickening. J Anat 2017 Feb;230(2):203-233.
- Barrera JW, Le Cabec A, Barak MM. The orthotropic elastic properties of fibrolamellar bone tissue in juvenile white-tailed deer femora. J Anat 2016 Oct;229(4):568-76.
- Gaddini GW, Turner RT, Grant KA, Iwaniec UT. Alcohol: A Simple Nutrient with Complex Actions on Bone in the Adult Skeleton. Alcohol Clin Exp Res 2016 Apr;40(4):657-71.
- Gocha TP, Agnew AM. Spatial variation in osteon population density at the human femoral midshaft: histomorphometric adaptations to habitual load environment. J Anat 2016 May;228(5):733-45.
- Caccia G, Magli F, Tagi VM, Porta DG, Cummaudo M, Márquez-Grant N, Cattaneo C. Histological determination of the human origin from dry bone: a cautionary note for subadults. Int J Legal Med 2016 Jan;130(1):299-307.
- Kolb C, Scheyer TM, Veitschegger K, Forasiepi AM, Amson E, Van der Geer AA, Van den Hoek Ostende LW, Hayashi S, Sánchez-Villagra MR. Mammalian bone palaeohistology: a survey and new data with emphasis on island forms. PeerJ 2015;3:e1358.
- Shipov A, Segev G, Meltzer H, Milrad M, Brenner O, Atkins A, Shahar R. The effect of naturally occurring chronic kidney disease on the micro-structural and mechanical properties of bone. PLoS One 2014;9(10):e110057.
- Li CL, Liu XL, Cai WX, Lu WW, Zwahlen RA, Zheng LW. Effect of ovariectomy on stimulating intracortical remodeling in rats. Biomed Res Int 2014;2014:421431.
- Imaizumi K, Taniguchi K, Ogawa Y. DNA survival and physical and histological properties of heat-induced alterations in burnt bones. Int J Legal Med 2014 May;128(3):439-46.
- Mayya A, Banerjee A, Rajesh R. Mammalian cortical bone in tension is non-Haversian. Sci Rep 2013;3:2533.
- Brits D, Steyn M, L'Abbé EN. A histomorphological analysis of human and non-human femora. Int J Legal Med 2014 Mar;128(2):369-77.
- Nguyen LH, Annabi N, Nikkhah M, Bae H, Binan L, Park S, Kang Y, Yang Y, Khademhosseini A. Vascularized bone tissue engineering: approaches for potential improvement. Tissue Eng Part B Rev 2012 Oct;18(5):363-82.
- Bagi CM, Berryman E, Moalli MR. Comparative bone anatomy of commonly used laboratory animals: implications for drug discovery. Comp Med 2011 Feb;61(1):76-85.
- Tobe SS, Linacre A. DNA typing in wildlife crime: recent developments in species identification. Forensic Sci Med Pathol 2010 Sep;6(3):195-206.
- McNamara LM, Majeska RJ, Weinbaum S, Friedrich V, Schaffler MB. Attachment of osteocyte cell processes to the bone matrix. Anat Rec (Hoboken) 2009 Mar;292(3):355-63.
- Reinwald S, Burr D. Review of nonprimate, large animal models for osteoporosis research. J Bone Miner Res 2008 Sep;23(9):1353-68.
- Suderman RP, Hurtig MB, Grynpas MD, Kuzyk PRT, Changoor A. Patient-Specific 3D-Printed Drill Guides for an Ovine Osteochondral Allograft Transplantation Model. J Orthop Res 2025 Dec;43(12):2114-2124.
- Xiong B, Liu T, Zhao Y, Gao L, Li X, Zhang C. Effect of Solute Molecular Weights on Mass Transfer within the Rat Lacunar-Canalicular System under Gravity. Tissue Eng Regen Med 2025 Oct;22(7):929-939.
- Azizi S, Goodarzi N, Ghaderi S. Morphometric, histometric and elemental profile of the metacarpal and metatarsal bones in adult Sanjabi sheep. Vet Res Forum 2025;16(5):293-300.
- Kothuri SK, MacMahon D, Lanka P, O'Flynn C, Henn P, Andersson-Engels S, Gautam R, Konugolu Venkata Sekar S. Broadband time domain diffuse optical characterization of human cadaver bone from 500 to 1100 nm. Sci Rep 2025 Jul 17;15(1):25931.
- Daskareh M, Carl M, Suprana A, Wang J, Xie S, Lo J, Jerban S, Chang E, Ma Y, Du J. Fast Volumetric Imaging of Bone Using a Three-Dimensional Short TR Adiabatic Inversion Recovery Ultrashort Echo Time (STAIR-UTE) Sequence. NMR Biomed 2025 Sep;38(9):e70102.
- Cummaudo M, Bruni S, D'Apuzzo A, Mazzarelli D, Caccia G, Palamenghi A, Salsarola D, Biehler-Gomez L, Cattaneo C. Three-step forensic approach for the differentiation of human and pig fingernail-like fragments: macroscopic examination, raman spectroscopy and histogenetic analyses. Int J Legal Med 2025 Nov;139(6):2939-2950.
- Ortiz-Arrabal O, Rodriguez MA, Chato-Astrain J, Martín-Piedra MÁ, Garzón I, Carriel V, Fernández-Valadés R, España-López A, Alaminos M, Rodriguez IA. A comprehensive analysis of two types of xenogeneic bone particles for use in maxillofacial bone regeneration therapies. PLoS One 2025;20(5):e0323754.
- Rhodes C, Price R, Willetts C, Swall J, Combs LG, Seashols-Williams S. Improved DNA recovery and STR profile development from weathered Bos taurus bones using demineralized bone slices. J Forensic Sci 2025 May;70(3):954-963.
- Carlsson J, Karlsson O, Isaksson H, Gustafsson A. Phase-field simulation of crack growth in cortical bone microstructure: parameter identification and comparison against experiments. Biomech Model Mechanobiol 2025 Apr;24(2):599-613.
- Pili N, Lowe TJ, Margetts L, Pickup K, Sellers WI, Nicholls EL, Withers PJ, Manning PL. Harnessing 3D microarchitecture of pterosaur bone using multi-scale X-ray CT for aerospace material design. Sci Rep 2025 Feb 17;15(1):5719.
- Aharoni S, Rittel D, Shemtov-Yona K. Factual observations of dynamic bone crushing. Sci Rep 2024 Oct 27;14(1):25597.
- Martonos CO, Gudea AI, Little WB, Stan FG, Lațiu C, Bolfa P, Dezdrobitu CC. The Gross Anatomical and Histological Features of the Humerus in African Green Monkeys (Chlorocebus sabaeus) from Saint Kitts and Nevis, West Indies. Life (Basel) 2024 Oct 12;14(10).
- Stan E, Muresan CO, Daescu E, Dumache R, Ciocan V, Ungureanu S, Costachescu D, Enache A. A Review of Histological Techniques for Differentiating Human Bone from Animal Bone. Methods Protoc 2024 Jun 30;7(4).
- Tuncludemir Z, Cinar IC, Avcı Kupeli Z, Unlu E, Yalcin S. In vivo comparison of customized zirconia barriers in guided bone regeneration: An experimental study. Heliyon 2024 Jun 15;10(11):e32070.
- Krap T, Leenstra A, Oostra RJ, Duijst W. Technical note: Temperature estimation accuracy based on colourimetry of embalmed human and fresh non-human burned bone. Int J Legal Med 2024 Sep;138(5):2107-2111.
- Suderman RP, Hurtig MB, Grynpas MD, Kuzyk PRT, Changoor A. Effect of Press-Fit Size on Insertion Mechanics and Cartilage Viability in Human and Ovine Osteochondral Grafts. Cartilage 2024 Apr 23;:19476035241247297.
- Adanty K, Brice A, Li Y, Vakiel P, Rabey KN, Adeeb S, Ouellet S, Romanyk DL, Dennison CR. A Preliminary Step Towards a Physical Surrogate of the Human Calvarium to Model Fracture. Ann Biomed Eng 2023 Dec;51(12):2883-2896.
- de Silva L, Longoni A, Staubli F, Nurmohamed S, Duits A, Rosenberg AJWP, Gawlitta D. Bone Regeneration in a Large Animal Model Featuring a Modular Off-the-Shelf Soft Callus Mimetic. Adv Healthc Mater 2023 Nov;12(29):e2301717.
- Glengarry J, Archer M. Marine mimicry is afoot. Forensic Sci Med Pathol 2024 Jun;20(2):652-656.
- Stein M, Elefteriou F, Busse B, Fiedler IA, Kwon RY, Farrell E, Ahmad M, Ignatius A, Grover L, Geris L, Tuckermann J. Why Animal Experiments Are Still Indispensable in Bone Research: A Statement by the European Calcified Tissue Society. J Bone Miner Res 2023 Aug;38(8):1045-1061.