Analyze Diet
Animals : an open access journal from MDPI2026; 16(21); 3493; doi: 10.3390/ani16213493

Inter-Reader and Inter-Modality Agreement for Radiographic and Magnetic Resonance Imaging Subchondral Bone Assessment in the Equine Proximal Phalanx Is Location- and Pattern-Dependent.

Abstract: Standing low-field magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is widely used for subchondral bone (SCB) assessment of the equine proximal phalanx, but radiography remains the most common first-line imaging modality, and no direct comparison between the two is available for SCB sclerosis and resorption. Fifty-four fetlocks from 52 horses referred for standing MRI were retrospectively assessed at the medial glenoid, sagittal groove and lateral glenoid, using an ordinal scale for sclerosis and a four-type nominal classification for resorption. Seven readers of varied clinical backgrounds performed independent radiographic readings; two board-certified radiologists then established a consensus reading, blinded to MRI. Agreement was quantified with Gwet's agreement coefficients (inter-reader), weighted and unweighted Cohen's κ (reader-MRI) and symmetric metrics (consensus-MRI). Inter-reader agreement for sclerosis was location-dependent (Gwet's agreement coefficient = 0.27-0.73, lowest medially) and substantial-to-almost-perfect for resorption (Gwet's agreement coefficient ≥ 0.72). The radiographic consensus aligned closely with MRI at the sagittal groove but underestimated marked sclerosis medially and over-called it laterally; fracture-type resorption was reliably detected at the sagittal groove but misclassified medially. Radiography can be relied upon for sagittal groove lesions, but complementary MRI is warranted medially when resorption or clinical suspicion of fracture is present, and to confirm radiographic positive calls laterally.
Publication Date: 2026-11-04 PubMed ID: 43027224PubMed Central: PMC13762259DOI: 10.3390/ani16213493Google Scholar: Lookup
The Equine Research Bank provides access to a large database of publicly available scientific literature. Inclusion in the Research Bank does not imply endorsement of study methods or findings by Mad Barn.
  • Journal Article

Summary

This research summary has been generated with artificial intelligence and may contain errors and omissions. Refer to the original study to confirm details provided. Submit correction.

Overview

  • This study compares the agreement between radiography and standing low-field magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) for evaluating subchondral bone (SCB) changes in the equine proximal phalanx, focusing on differences related to location and lesion pattern.
  • It reveals that agreement varies by anatomical site and type of lesion, with radiography being more reliable at some locations but less so at others, indicating when MRI is necessary as a complementary tool.

Background and Purpose

  • Subchondral bone (SCB) changes such as sclerosis (hardening) and resorption (bone loss) in the proximal phalanx of horses are important for diagnosing joint conditions.
  • Standing low-field MRI is extensively used to assess SCB but radiography remains the most commonly used initial imaging technique due to availability and cost.
  • Prior to this study, no direct head-to-head comparison between radiography and MRI had been reported specifically for assessing SCB sclerosis and resorption in the equine proximal phalanx.
  • The goal was to determine agreement and reliability between modalities and among different readers in evaluating SCB changes at specific anatomical sites.

Methods

  • Sample: 54 fetlocks from 52 horses referred for standing MRI were retrospectively included.
  • Assessment Locations: Medial glenoid, sagittal groove, and lateral glenoid regions of the proximal phalanx.
  • Lesion Types:
    • Sclerosis was graded using an ordinal scale to indicate severity.
    • Resorption was classified into four types using a nominal classification system.
  • Reading Process:
    • Seven readers from different clinical backgrounds independently evaluated the radiographs to assess bone changes.
    • Two board-certified radiologists then performed a consensus reading of the radiographs, blinded to the MRI results.
  • Agreement Metrics:
    • Inter-reader agreement was measured using Gwet’s agreement coefficients, which account for chance agreement and are particularly robust in scenarios with skewed data.
    • Reader-to-MRI agreement was assessed using weighted and unweighted Cohen’s kappa statistics to evaluate consistency between radiograph readers and MRI interpretations.
    • Consensus radiograph-to-MRI comparisons were evaluated with symmetric agreement metrics to analyze the overall concordance.

Results

  • Inter-reader agreement for sclerosis varied by location:
    • Agreement ranged from fair to substantial depending on the site, with the lowest agreement found in the medial glenoid (Gwet’s coefficient between 0.27 and 0.73).
  • Inter-reader agreement for resorption was consistently higher:
    • Substantial to almost perfect agreement was reported (Gwet’s coefficient ≥ 0.72) across sites.
  • Comparing radiographic consensus with MRI findings showed location-dependent results:
    • At the sagittal groove, radiography and MRI were closely aligned in detecting sclerosis and resorption.
    • Medially, radiography tended to underestimate marked sclerosis and misclassify fracture-type resorption.
    • Laterally, radiography overcalled sclerosis relative to MRI findings.
    • Fracture-type resorption was reliably detected at the sagittal groove but less so in the medial region.

Conclusions and Clinical Implications

  • Reliability of radiographic assessment for SCB changes depends on both the anatomical location and lesion pattern.
  • Radiography performs well for assessing lesions in the sagittal groove, making it a dependable first-line imaging modality in that region.
  • When there is clinical suspicion of fracture or resorption medially, MRI should be used as a complementary imaging technique due to radiography’s limitations in that area.
  • Additionally, MRI is advised to confirm suspicious positive radiographic findings in the lateral glenoid region, where radiography may overestimate sclerosis.
  • Overall, the study supports a tailored imaging approach that combines radiography and MRI guided by lesion location and suspicion to improve diagnostic accuracy in equine distal limb conditions.

Cite This Article

APA
Vandersmissen M, Charles A, Evrard L, Fraschetto C, Audigié F, Busoni V. (2026). Inter-Reader and Inter-Modality Agreement for Radiographic and Magnetic Resonance Imaging Subchondral Bone Assessment in the Equine Proximal Phalanx Is Location- and Pattern-Dependent. Animals (Basel), 16(21), 3493. https://doi.org/10.3390/ani16213493

Publication

ISSN: 2076-2615
NlmUniqueID: 101635614
Country: Switzerland
Language: English
Volume: 16
Issue: 21
PII: 3493

Researcher Affiliations

Vandersmissen, Maxime
  • Diagnostic Imaging Unit, Department of Equine Clinical Sciences, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, University of Liège, 4000 Liège, Belgium.
Charles, Alexandre
  • Diagnostic Imaging Unit, Department of Equine Clinical Sciences, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, University of Liège, 4000 Liège, Belgium.
Evrard, Laurence
  • Diagnostic Imaging Unit, Department of Equine Clinical Sciences, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, University of Liège, 4000 Liège, Belgium.
Fraschetto, Claudia
  • Clinique Vétérinaire de Grosbois, 94470 Boissy Saint Léger, France.
Audigié, Fabrice
  • ACAP3, Ecole Nationale Vétérinaire d'Alfort, 14430 Goustranville, France.
Busoni, Valeria
  • Diagnostic Imaging Unit, Department of Equine Clinical Sciences, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, University of Liège, 4000 Liège, Belgium.

Conflict of Interest Statement

The authors declare no conflicts of interest.

References

This article includes 31 references
  1. Ammann L, Ohlerth S, Fürst AE, Jackson MA. Differences of Morphological Attributes between 62 Proximal and Distal Subchondral Cystic Lesions of the Proximal Phalanx as Determined by Radiography and Computed Tomography. Am. J. Vet. Res. 2022;83:1–9.
    doi: 10.2460/ajvr.22.04.0071pubmed: 36315450google scholar: lookup
  2. Vandersmissen M, Evrard L, Charles A, Audigié F, Busoni V. Diagnostic Imaging Findings in Lame Warmblood Horses with Bone Injuries of the Medial Proximal Phalanx Glenoid Cavity. Vet. Radiol. Ultrasound 2025;66:e13449.
    doi: 10.1111/vru.13449pubmed: 39377553google scholar: lookup
  3. Faulkner JE, Joostens Z, Broeckx BJG, Hauspie S, Mariën T, Vanderperren K. Low-field Magnetic Resonance Imaging of Sagittal Groove Disease of the Proximal Phalanx in Non-racing Sport Horses. Equine Vet. J. 2025;57:140–152.
    doi: 10.1111/evj.14088pubmed: 38566459google scholar: lookup
  4. Lesca H, Fairburn A, Sherlock C, Mair T. The Use of Advanced vs. Conventional Imaging Modalities for the Diagnosis of Subchondral Bone Injuries. Equine Vet. Educ. 2022;34:443–448.
    doi: 10.1111/eve.13619google scholar: lookup
  5. Dyson S, Nagy A, Murray R. Clinical and Diagnostic Imaging Findings in Horses with Subchondral Bone Trauma of the Sagittal Groove of the Proximal Phalanx: Subchondral Bone Trauma of the Proximal Phalanx. Vet. Radiol. Ultrasound 2011;52:596–604.
  6. Stewart HL, Kawcak CE. The Importance of Subchondral Bone in the Pathophysiology of Osteoarthritis. Front. Vet. Sci. 2018;5:178.
    doi: 10.3389/fvets.2018.00178pmc: PMC6122109pubmed: 30211173google scholar: lookup
  7. Smith MA, Dyson SJ, Murray RC. The Appearance of the Equine Metacarpophalangeal Region on High-Field vs. Standing Low-Field Magnetic Resonance Imaging: High- and Low-Field MRI of the Equine Fetlock. Vet. Radiol. Ultrasound 2011;52:61–70.
  8. Ramzan PHL, Powell SE. Clinical and Imaging Features of Suspected Prodromal Fracture of the Proximal Phalanx in Three Thoroughbred Racehorses: Clinical and Imaging Features of Suspected Prodromal Fracture. Equine Vet. J. 2010;42:164–169.
    doi: 10.2746/042516409X478695pubmed: 20156254google scholar: lookup
  9. Gold SJ, Werpy NM, Gutierrez-Nibeyro SD. Injuries of the Sagittal Groove of the Proximal Phalanx in Warmblood Horses Detected with Low-Field Magnetic Resonance Imaging: 19 Cases (2007–2016): Injuries of the Equine Proximal Phalanx. Vet. Radiol. Ultrasound 2017;58:344–353.
    doi: 10.1111/vru.12488pubmed: 28281306google scholar: lookup
  10. O’Brien T, Baker TA, Brounts SH, Sample SJ, Markel MD, Scollay MC, Marquis P, Muir P. Detection of Articular Pathology of the Distal Aspect of the Third Metacarpal Bone in Thoroughbred Racehorses: Comparison of Radiography, Computed Tomography and Magnetic Resonance Imaging. Vet. Surg. 2011;40:942–951.
  11. Olive J, D’Anjou M-A, Girard C, Laverty S, Theoret CL. Imaging and Histological Features of Central Subchondral Osteophytes in Racehorses with Metacarpophalangeal Joint Osteoarthritis. Equine Vet. J. 2009;41:859–864.
    doi: 10.2746/042516409X448481pubmed: 20383982google scholar: lookup
  12. Butler JA, Colles CM, Dyson SJ, Kold SE, Poulos PW. Clinical Radiology of the Horse. 4th ed. Wiley Blackwell; Chichester, UK: 2017. General Principles; pp. 1–39.
  13. Brünisholz HP, Hagen R, Fürst AE, Kuemmerle JM. Radiographic and Computed Tomographic Configuration of Incomplete Proximal Fractures of the Proximal Phalanx in Horses Not Used for Racing: CT Configuration of Incomplete P1 Fractures. Vet. Surg. 2015;44:809–815.
    doi: 10.1111/vsu.12364pubmed: 26197984google scholar: lookup
  14. Nagy A, Dyson S. Combined Standing Low-Field Magnetic Resonance Imaging and Fan-Beam Computed Tomographic Diagnosis of Fetlock Region Pain in 27 Sports Horses. Equine Vet. J. 2025;57:1313–1327.
    doi: 10.1111/evj.14504pmc: PMC12326934pubmed: 40123444google scholar: lookup
  15. Butler JA, Colles CM, Dyson SJ, Kold SE, Poulos PW. Clinical Radiology of the Horse. 4th ed. Wiley Blackwell; Chichester, UK: 2017. Metacarpophalangeal and Metatarsophalangeal (Fetlock) Joints; pp. 175–176.
  16. Geijer M, Båth M, Wessman C. Some Common Statistical Methods for Assessing Rater Agreement in Radiological Studies. Acta Radiol 2025;66:675–683.
    doi: 10.1177/02841851251319666pmc: PMC12163189pubmed: 39988909google scholar: lookup
  17. Landis JR, Koch GG. The Measurement of Observer Agreement for Categorical Data. Biometrics 1977;33:159–174.
    doi: 10.2307/2529310pubmed: 843571google scholar: lookup
  18. Dyson SJ, Murray R. Osseous Trauma in the Fetlock Region of Mature Sports Horses. Proceedings of the 52nd Annual Convention of the American Association of Equine Practitioners; San Antonio, TX, USA. 2–6 December 2006; pp. 443–456.
  19. Nagy A, Dyson S. Magnetic Resonance Imaging, Computed Tomographic and Radiographic Findings in the Metacarpophalangeal Joints of 31 Warmblood Showjumpers in Full Work and Competing Regularly. Animals 2024;14:1417.
    doi: 10.3390/ani14101417pmc: PMC11117305pubmed: 38791635google scholar: lookup
  20. Schöffl VR, Hoffmann PM, Imhoff A, Küpper T, Schöffl I, Hochholzer T, Hinterwimmer S. Long-Term Radiographic Adaptations to Stress of High-Level and Recreational Rock Climbing in Former Adolescent Athletes: An 11-Year Prospective Longitudinal Study. Orthop. J. Sports Med. 2018;6:2325967118792847.
    doi: 10.1177/2325967118792847pmc: PMC6125860pubmed: 30202767google scholar: lookup
  21. Burton NJ, Toscano MJ, Barr FJ, Owen MR. Reliability of Radiological Assessment of Ulnar Trochlear Notch Sclerosis in Dysplastic Canine Elbows. J. Small Anim. Pract. 2008;49:572–576.
  22. Morgan JW, Santschi EM, Zekas LJ, Scollay-Ward MC, Markel MD, Radtke CL, Sample SJ, Keuler NS, Muir P. Comparison of Radiography and Computed Tomography to Evaluate Metacarpo/Metatarsophalangeal Joint Pathology of Paired Limbs of Thoroughbred Racehorses with Severe Condylar Fracture. Vet. Surg. 2006;35:611–617.
  23. Olive J, D’Anjou M-A, Alexander K, Laverty S, Theoret C. Comparison of Magnetic Resonance Imaging, Computed Tomography, and Radiography for Assessment of Noncartilaginous Changes in Equine Metacarpophalangeal Osteoarthritis. Vet. Radiol. Ultrasound 2010;51:267–279.
  24. Pullen WM, Pierre K, Wong I, Aoki SK, Lynch TS, Mather RC III, Ayeni OR, Byrd JWT, Safran MR. MRI Does Not Improve Inter- or Intrarater Reliability for Hip Arthritis Grading Systems. Am. J. Sports Med. 2023;51:1826–1830.
    doi: 10.1177/03635465231167866pubmed: 37103331google scholar: lookup
  25. D’Anjou M-A, Moreau M, Troncy É, Martel-Pelletier J, Abram F, Raynauld J-P, Pelletier J-P. Osteophytosis, Subchondral Bone Sclerosis, Joint Effusion and Soft Tissue Thickening in Canine Experimental Stifle Osteoarthritis: Comparison Between 1.5 T Magnetic Resonance Imaging and Computed Radiography. Vet. Surg. 2008;37:166–177.
  26. Faulkner JE, Joostens Z, Broeckx BJG, Hauspie S, Mariën T, Vanderperren K. Follow-Up Magnetic Resonance Imaging of Sagittal Groove Disease of the Equine Proximal Phalanx Using a Classification System in 29 Non-Racing Sports Horses. Animals 2023;14:34.
    doi: 10.3390/ani14010034pmc: PMC10778323pubmed: 38200766google scholar: lookup
  27. Byrne CA, Marshall JF, Voute LC. Clinical Magnetic Resonance Image Quality of the Equine Foot Is Significantly Influenced by Acquisition System. Equine Vet. J. 2021;53:469–480.
    doi: 10.1111/evj.13330pubmed: 32767582google scholar: lookup
  28. Cresswell EN, McDonough SP, Palmer SE, Hernandez CJ, Reesink HL. Can Quantitative Computed Tomography Detect Bone Morphological Changes Associated with Catastrophic Proximal Sesamoid Bone Fracture in Thoroughbred Racehorses?. Equine Vet. J. 2019;51:123–130.
    doi: 10.1111/evj.12965pubmed: 29758110google scholar: lookup
  29. Rubio-Martínez LM, Cruz AM, Gordon K, Hurtig MB. Structural Characterization of Subchondral Bone in the Distal Aspect of Third Metacarpal Bones from Thoroughbred Racehorses via Micro–Computed Tomography. Am. J. Vet. Res. 2008;69:1413–1422.
    doi: 10.2460/ajvr.69.11.1413pubmed: 18980423google scholar: lookup
  30. Lin S, Bolas NM, Sargan DR, Restif O, Peter VG, Pokora R, Patrick H, Foote AK, Murray RC. Comparison of Cone-beam and Fan-beam Computed Tomography and Low-field Magnetic Resonance Imaging for Detection of Proximal Phalanx Dorsoproximal Osteochondral Defects. Equine Vet. J. 2024;56:484–493.
    doi: 10.1111/evj.13973pubmed: 37488678google scholar: lookup
  31. Gur D, Bandos AI, Cohen CS, Hakim CM, Hardesty LA, Ganott MA, Perrin RL, Poller WR, Shah R, Sumkin JH. The “Laboratory” Effect: Comparing Radiologists’ Performance and Variability during Prospective Clinical and Laboratory Mammography Interpretations.. Radiology 2008;249:47–53.
    doi: 10.1148/radiol.2491072025pmc: PMC2607194pubmed: 18682584google scholar: lookup

Citations

This article has been cited 0 times.