FREE SHIPPING over $40
OVER 9000 FIVE-STAR REVIEWS
5% OFF ALL SUBSCRIPTIONS
100% HAPPINESS GUARANTEE
Analyze Diet
0
Home / Equine Research Bank / J Mamm Evol / Investigating the reliability of metapodials as taxonomic In...
Journal of mammalian evolution2022; 29(4); 863-875; doi: 10.1007/s10914-022-09626-4

Investigating the reliability of metapodials as taxonomic Indicators for Beringian horses.

Abstract: The metapodials of extinct horses have long been regarded as one of the most useful skeletal elements to determine taxonomic identity. However, recent research on both extant and extinct horses has revealed the possibility for plasticity in metapodial morphology, leading to notable variability within taxa. This calls into question the reliability of metapodials in species identification, particularly for species identified from fragmentary remains. Here, we use ten measurements of metapodials from 203 specimens of four Pleistocene horse species from eastern Beringia to test whether there are significant differences in metapodial morphology that support the presence of multiple species. We then reconstruct the body masses for every specimen to assess the range in body size within each species and determine whether species differ significantly from one another in mean body mass. We find that that taxonomic groups are based largely on the overall size of the metapodial, and that all metapodial measurements are highly autocorrelated. We also find that mean body mass differs significantly among most, but not all, species. We suggest that metapodial measurements are unreliable taxonomic indicators for Beringian horses given evidence for plasticity in metapodial morphology and their clear reflection of differences in body mass. We recommend future studies use more reliable indicators of taxonomy to identify Beringian horse species, particularly from localities from which fossils of several species have been recovered. Unassigned: The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s10914-022-09626-4.
© The Author(s) 2022.
Get Full Text
Publication Date: 2022-09-21 PubMed ID: 36438779PubMed Central: PMC9684255DOI: 10.1007/s10914-022-09626-4Google Scholar: Lookup
The Equine Research Bank provides access to a large database of publicly available scientific literature. Inclusion in the Research Bank does not imply endorsement of study methods or findings by Mad Barn.
LinkedInCopy
  • Journal Article

Summary

This research summary has been generated with artificial intelligence and may contain errors and omissions. Refer to the original study to confirm details provided. Submit correction.

This research is attempting to verify the reliability of metapodials (long bones in the foot of a horse) as indicators for identifying different extinct horse species in the Beringia region. The study points out that while these skeletal features have been traditionally used for species identification, recent research suggests significant variability within taxa, making such identification difficult and unreliable.

Research Methodology

  • The researchers measured the metapodials of 203 specimens from four different extinct horse species found in the eastern Beringia region.
  • They studied whether significant differences in metapodial morphology supported the presence of multiple species.
  • They reconstructed body masses for all specimens to understand the range in body size within each species and to determine if species significantly differed from one another in average body mass.

Findings

  • The research found that taxonomic groups tend to base their classification largely on the overall size of the metapodial.
  • However, all metapodial measurements were found to be highly interrelated, or autocorrelated.
  • The research also discovered that mean body mass did significantly differ among most, but not all, species.

Recommendations

  • Given the finding of significant morphological variability in metapodials that may be mistaken for species difference, the researchers do not consider them reliable taxonomic indicators for extinct Beringian horses.
  • They recommend future studies to use more reliable indicators for identifying species, especially in instances where fossils from several different species have been recovered from the same locality.

Cite This Article

APA
Landry Z, Roloson MJ, Fraser D. (2022). Investigating the reliability of metapodials as taxonomic Indicators for Beringian horses. J Mamm Evol, 29(4), 863-875. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10914-022-09626-4

Publication

Journal of mammalian evolution
ISSN: 1064-7554
NlmUniqueID: 9312477
Country: United States
Language: English
Volume: 29
Issue: 4
Pages: 863-875

Researcher Affiliations

Landry, Zoe
  • Department of Earth Sciences, University of Ottawa, 25 Templeton Street, Ottawa, ON K1N 6N5 Canada.
  • Beaty Centre for Species Discovery, Canadian Museum of Nature, PO Box 3443, Station D., Ottawa, ON K1P 6P4 Canada.
Roloson, Mathew J
  • Beaty Centre for Species Discovery, Canadian Museum of Nature, PO Box 3443, Station D., Ottawa, ON K1P 6P4 Canada.
  • Department of Earth Sciences, Carleton University, 1125 Colonel By Drive, Ottawa, ON K1S 5B6 Canada.
Fraser, Danielle
  • Beaty Centre for Species Discovery, Canadian Museum of Nature, PO Box 3443, Station D., Ottawa, ON K1P 6P4 Canada.
  • Department of Earth Sciences, Carleton University, 1125 Colonel By Drive, Ottawa, ON K1S 5B6 Canada.
  • Department of Biology, Carleton University, 1125 Colonel By Drive, Ottawa, ON K1S 5B6 Canada.
  • Paleobiology Smithsonian National Museum of Natural History, DC 20560 Washington, USA.

Conflict of Interest Statement

Competing interestsAuthor DF is the Director for the Beaty Centre for Species Discovery and receives a salary from the Canadian Museum of Nature. Author DF is an Associate Editor for the Journal of Mammalian Evolution. The authors have no other competing interests to declare.

References

This article includes 124 references
  1. Alberdi MT, Arroyo-Cabrales J, Marín-Leyva AH, Polaco OJ. Study of Cedral horses and their place in the Mexican Quaternary. Rev Mex Cienc Geol 31:221–237.
  2. Alberdi MT, Prado JL, Ortiz-Jaureguizar E. Patterns of body size changes in fossil and living Equini (Perissodactyla). Biol J Linn Soc 1995;54:349–370.
    doi: 10.1016/0024-4066(95)90015-2google scholar: lookup
  3. Alexander RM. Symmorphosis and safety factors. In: Weibel ER, Taylor CR, Bolis L, editors. Principles of Animal Design: The Optimization and Symmorphosis Debate. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 1998. pp. 28–35.
  4. Alroy J. Taxonomic influence and body mass distributions in North American fossil mammals. J Mammal 84(2):431–443.
    doi: 10.1644/1545-1542(2003)084<0431:tiabmd>2.0.co;2google scholar: lookup
  5. Ashton KG, Tracy MC, Queiroz A. Is Bergmann's Rule Valid for Mammals?. Am Nat 2000 Oct;156(4):390-415.
    doi: 10.1086/303400pubmed: 29592141google scholar: lookup
  6. Barrón-Ortiz CI, Jass CN, Barrón-Corvera R, Austen J, Theodor JM. Enamel hypoplasia and dental wear of North American late Pleistocene horses and bison: an assessment of nutritionally based extinction models. Paleobiology 2019;45(3):484–515.
    doi: 10.1017/pab.2019.17google scholar: lookup
  7. Barrón-Ortiz CI, Rodrigues AT, Theodor JM, Kooyman BP, Yang DY, Speller CF. Cheek tooth morphology and ancient mitochondrial DNA of late Pleistocene horses from the western interior of North America: Implications for the taxonomy of North American Late Pleistocene Equus.. PLoS One 2017;12(8):e0183045.
    doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0183045pmc: PMC5560644pubmed: 28817644google scholar: lookup
  8. Baskin JA, Mosqueda AE. Analysis of horse (Equus) metapodials from the Late Pleistocene of the lower Nueces Valley, south Texas. Tex J Sci 2002;54(1):17–26.
  9. Bergmann C. Über die verhaltnisse der warmeokonomie der thiere zu ihrer grosse (translation: On the conditions of the thermal economy of animals to their size). Germany: Göttingen; 1847.
  10. Bernor RL, Scott RS, Fortelius M, Kappelman J, Sen S. Equidae (Perissodactyla). In: Fortelius M, Kappelman J, Sen S, Bernor RL, editors. The Geology and Paleontology of the Miocene Sinap Formation, Turkey. New York: Columbia University Press; 2003. pp. 220–281.
  11. Bertram JE, Biewener AA. Differential scaling of the long bones in the terrestrial carnivora and other mammals.. J Morphol 1990 May;204(2):157-69.
    doi: 10.1002/jmor.1052040205pubmed: 2348461google scholar: lookup
  12. Biewener AA. Mammalian terrestrial locomotion and size. BioScience 1989;39:776–783.
    doi: 10.2307/1311183google scholar: lookup
  13. Biewener AA. Muscle-tendon stresses and elastic energy storage during locomotion in the horse.. Comp Biochem Physiol B Biochem Mol Biol 1998 May;120(1):73-87.
    doi: 10.1016/S0305-0491(98)00024-8pubmed: 9787779google scholar: lookup
  14. Biewener AA. Biomechanical consequences of scaling.. J Exp Biol 2005 May;208(Pt 9):1665-76.
    doi: 10.1242/jeb.01520pubmed: 15855398google scholar: lookup
  15. Biewener AA, Patek S. Animal Locomotion. 2. New York: Oxford University Press; 2018.
  16. Bocherens H. Isotopic biogeochemistry and the paleoecology of the mammoth steppe fauna. Deinsea 2003;9:57–76.
  17. Brooks SA, Makvandi-Nejad S, Chu E, Allen JJ, Streeter C, Gu E, McCleery B, Murphy BA, Bellone R, Sutter NB. Morphological variation in the horse: defining complex traits of body size and shape.. Anim Genet 2010 Dec;41 Suppl 2:159-65.
    doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2052.2010.02127.xpubmed: 21070291google scholar: lookup
  18. Christiansen P. Scaling mammalian long bones: small and large mammals compared. J Zool 1999;247:333–348.
    doi: 10.1111/j.1469-7998.1999.tb00996.xgoogle scholar: lookup
  19. Clayton HM. HORSE SPECIES SYMPOSIUM: Biomechanics of the exercising horse.. J Anim Sci 2016 Oct;94(10):4076-4086.
    doi: 10.2527/jas.2015-9990pubmed: 27898852google scholar: lookup
  20. Cope ED. A preliminary report on the vertebrate paleontology of the Llano Estacado. Fourth Annual Report of the Geological Survey of Texas 1893;1892:11–136.
    doi: 10.5962/bhl.title.61555google scholar: lookup
  21. Cromsigt JP, Olff H. Resource partitioning among savanna grazers mediated by local heterogeneity: an experimental approach.. Ecology 2006 Jun;87(6):1532-41.
    doi: 10.1890/0012-9658(2006)87[1532:RPASGM]2.0.CO;2pubmed: 16869429google scholar: lookup
  22. Currey JD. Bones: Structure and Mechanics. 2. Princeton: Princeton University Press; 2002.
  23. Davis M. What North America's skeleton crew of megafauna tells us about community disassembly.. Proc Biol Sci 2017 Jan 11;284(1846).
    doi: 10.1098/rspb.2016.2116pmc: PMC5247494pubmed: 28077767google scholar: lookup
  24. Drucker DG. The isotopic ecology of the Mammoth Steppe. Annu Rev Earth Planet Sci 2022;50:395–418.
    doi: 10.1146/annurev-earth-100821-081832google scholar: lookup
  25. Eisenmann V. Comparative osteology of modern and fossil horses, half-asses, and asses. In: Meadows RH, Uerpmann H-P, editors. Equids in the Ancient World. Dr: Ludwig Reichert Verlag, Wiesbaden; 1986. pp. 67–116.
  26. Eisenmann V, Howe J, Pichardo M. Old World hemiones and New World slender species (Mammalia, Equidae). Palaeovertebrata 36:159–233.
    doi: 10.18563/pv.36.1-4.159-233google scholar: lookup
  27. Etienne C, Filippo A, Cornette R, Houssaye A. Effect of mass and habitat on the shape of limb long bones: A morpho-functional investigation on Bovidae (Mammalia: Cetartiodactyla).. J Anat 2021 Apr;238(4):886-904.
    doi: 10.1111/joa.13359pmc: PMC7930763pubmed: 33210307google scholar: lookup
  28. Evans AR, Jones D, Boyer AG, Brown JH, Costa DP, Ernest SK, Fitzgerald EM, Fortelius M, Gittleman JL, Hamilton MJ, Harding LE, Lintulaakso K, Lyons SK, Okie JG, Saarinen JJ, Sibly RM, Smith FA, Stephens PR, Theodor JM, Uhen MD. The maximum rate of mammal evolution.. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 2012 Mar 13;109(11):4187-90.
    doi: 10.1073/pnas.1120774109pmc: PMC3306709pubmed: 22308461google scholar: lookup
  29. Fox-Dobbs K, Leonard JA, Koch PL. Pleistocene megafauna from eastern Beringia: paleoecological and paleoenvironmental interpretations of stable carbon and nitrogen isotope and radiocarbon records. Palaeogeogr Palaeoclimatol Palaeoecol 2008;261:30–46.
    doi: 10.1016/j.palaeo.2007.12.011google scholar: lookup
  30. Freckleton RP, Harvey PH, Pagel M. Bergmann's rule and body size in mammals.. Am Nat 2003 May;161(5):821-5.
    doi: 10.1086/374346pubmed: 12858287google scholar: lookup
  31. Froese DG, Zazula GD, Westgate JA, Preece SJ, Sanborn PT, Reyes AV, Pearce NJG. The Klondike goldfields and Pleistocene environment of Beringia. GSA Today 2009;19(8):4–10.
    doi: 10.1130/GSATG54A.1google scholar: lookup
  32. Gardner JL, Peters A, Kearney MR, Joseph L, Heinsohn R. Declining body size: a third universal response to warming?. Trends Ecol Evol 2011 Jun;26(6):285-91.
    doi: 10.1016/j.tree.2011.03.005pubmed: 21470708google scholar: lookup
  33. Gidley JW. A new species of Pleistocene horse from the Staked Plains of Texas. Bull Am Mus Nat Hist 13:111–116.
  34. Gidley JW. Tooth characters and revision of the North American species of the genus Equus. Bull Am Mus Nat 1901;14:91–142.
  35. Goldstein DM, Engiles JB, Rezabek GB, Ruff CB. Locomotion on the edge: Structural properties of the third metacarpal in Thoroughbred and Quarter Horse racehorses and feral Assateague Island ponies.. Anat Rec (Hoboken) 2021 Apr;304(4):771-786.
    doi: 10.1002/ar.24485pubmed: 32805766google scholar: lookup
  36. Gombin J, Vaidyanathan R, Agafonkin V. concaveman: a very fast 2D concave hull algorithm. .
  37. Goswami A, Smaers JB, Soligo C, Polly PD. The macroevolutionary consequences of phenotypic integration: from development to deep time.. Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci 2014 Aug 19;369(1649):20130254.
    doi: 10.1098/rstb.2013.0254pmc: PMC4084539pubmed: 25002699google scholar: lookup
  38. Gould SJ. The Structure of Evolutionary Theory. Harvard, MA: Harvard University Press; 2002.
  39. Graffelman J. calibrate: calibration of scatterplot and biplot axes. .
  40. Guthrie RD. Mammals of the mammoth steppe as paleoenvironmental indicators. In: Hopkins DM (ed) Palaeoecology of Beringia. Academic Press, New York, pp 307–326.
    doi: 10.1016/b978-0-12-355860-2.50030-2google scholar: lookup
  41. Guthrie RD. Origin and causes of the mammoth steppe: a story of cloud cover, woolly mammoth tooth pits, buckles, and inside-out Beringia. Quat Sci Rev 2001;20(1–3):549–574.
    doi: 10.1016/S0277-3791(00)00099-8google scholar: lookup
  42. Guthrie RD. Rapid body size decline in Alaskan Pleistocene horses before extinction.. Nature 2003 Nov 13;426(6963):169-71.
    doi: 10.1038/nature02098pubmed: 14614503google scholar: lookup
  43. Hallgrímsson B, Willmore K, Hall BK. Canalization, developmental stability, and morphological integration in primate limbs.. Am J Phys Anthropol 2002;Suppl 35:131-58.
    doi: 10.1002/ajpa.10182pmc: PMC5217179pubmed: 12653311google scholar: lookup
  44. Hanot P, Herrel A, Guintard C, Cornette R. The impact of artificial selection on morphological integration in the appendicular skeleton of domestic horses.. J Anat 2018 Apr;232(4):657-673.
    doi: 10.1111/joa.12772pmc: PMC5835793pubmed: 29315551google scholar: lookup
  45. Harington CR. Pleistocene mammals from Lost Chicken Creek, Alaska. Can J Earth Sci 1980;17:168–198.
    doi: 10.1139/e80-015google scholar: lookup
  46. Harington CR. Vertebrates of the Last Interglaciation in Canada: A review, with new data. Géogr Phys Quatern 1990;44(3):375–387.
    doi: 10.7202/032837argoogle scholar: lookup
  47. Harington CR. Pleistocene vertebrates of the Yukon Territory. Quat Sci Rev 2011;30:2341–2354.
    doi: 10.1016/j.quascirev.2011.05.020google scholar: lookup
  48. Harington CR, Clulow FV. Pleistocene mammals from Gold Run Creek, Yukon Territory. Can J Earth Sci 1973;10:697–759.
    doi: 10.1139/e73-069google scholar: lookup
  49. Hay OP. Contributions to the knowledge of the mammals of the Pleistocene of North America. Proc US Natl Mus 1915;48:515–575.
    doi: 10.5479/si.00963801.48-2086.515google scholar: lookup
  50. Hay OP. Description of a new species of extinct horse, Equus lambei, from the Pleistocene of Yukon Territory. Proc US Natl Mus 1917;53:435–443.
    doi: 10.5479/si.00963801.53-2212.435google scholar: lookup
  51. Heintzman PD, Zazula GD, MacPhee R, Scott E, Cahill JA, McHorse BK, Kapp JD, Stiller M, Wooller MJ, Orlando L, Southon J, Froese DG, Shapiro B. A new genus of horse from Pleistocene North America.. Elife 2017 Nov 28;6.
    pmc: PMC5705217pubmed: 29182148doi: 10.7554/elife.29944google scholar: lookup
  52. Hibbert D. History of the steppe-tundra concept. In: Hopkins DM (ed) Paleoecology of Beringia. Academic Press, New York, pp 153–156.
    doi: 10.1016/b978-0-12-355860-2.50017-xgoogle scholar: lookup
  53. Hildebrand M. Analysis of Vertebrate Structure. 2. New York: Wiley; 1982.
  54. Hildebrand M. The mechanics of horse legs. Am Sci 1987;75:594–601.
  55. Hughes OL, Harington CR, Janssens JA, Matthews JV, Morlan RE, Rutter NW, Schweger CE. Upper Pleistocene stratigraphy, paleoecology, and archaeology of the northern Yukon interior, eastern Beringia 1. Bonnet Plume Basin. Arctic 1981;34(4):329–365.
    doi: 10.14430/arctic2538google scholar: lookup
  56. Janis CM, Bernor RL. The evolution of equid monodactyly: a review including a new hypothesis. Front Ecol Evol 2019;7:1–19.
    doi: 10.3389/fevo.2019.00119google scholar: lookup
  57. Janis CM, Wilhelm PB. Were there mammalian pursuit predators in the Tertiary? Dances with wolf avatars. J Mammal Evol 1993;1:103–125.
    doi: 10.1007/BF01041590google scholar: lookup
  58. Jiménez-Hidalgo E, Díaz-Sibaja R. Was Equus cedralensis a non-stilt legged horse? Taxonomical implications for the Mexican Pleistocene horses. Ameghiniana 2020;57(3):284–288.
    doi: 10.5710/AMGH.06.01.2020.3262google scholar: lookup
  59. Kartzinel TR, Chen PA, Coverdale TC, Erickson DL, Kress WJ, Kuzmina ML, Rubenstein DI, Wang W, Pringle RM. DNA metabarcoding illuminates dietary niche partitioning by African large herbivores.. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 2015 Jun 30;112(26):8019-24.
    doi: 10.1073/pnas.1503283112pmc: PMC4491742pubmed: 26034267google scholar: lookup
  60. Kassambara A. ggpubr: ‘ggplot2’ based publication ready plots. .
  61. Kassambara A, Mundt F. factoextra: extract and visualize the results of multivariate data analyses. .
  62. Kelly A, Miller JH, Wooller MJ, Seaton CT, Druckenmiller P, DeSantis L. Dietary paleoecology of bison and horses on the Mammoth Steppe of eastern Beringia based on dental microwear and mesowear analyses. Palaeogeogr Palaeoclimatol Palaeoecol 2021;572:110394.
    doi: 10.1016/j.palaeo.2021.110394google scholar: lookup
  63. Kleynhans EJ, Jolles AE, Bos MRE, Olff H. Resource partitioning along multiple niche dimensions in differently sized African savanna grazers. Oikos 2011;120:591–600.
    doi: 10.1111/j.1600-0706.2010.18712.xgoogle scholar: lookup
  64. Köhler M. Skeleton and habitat of recent and fossil ruminants. Münch Geowizz Abh A 1993;25:1–88.
  65. Leidy J. Bones and teeth of horses from California and Oregon. Proc Acad Nat Sci 1865;17(2):1–94.
  66. Li Y, Deng T, Hua H, Sun B, Zhang Y. Locomotor adaptations of 7.4 Ma Hipparionine fossils from the middle reaches of the Yellow River and their palaeoecological significance. Hist Biol 2021;33(7):927–940.
    doi: 10.1080/08912963.2019.1669592google scholar: lookup
  67. Linnaeus C. Systema Naturae, per Regna Tria Naturae: Secundum Classes, Ordines, Genera, Species cum Characteribus, Differentiis, Synonymis, Locis. Vol. 1 (10th edition). Laurentii Salvii, Holmiae.
  68. Lovegrove BG, Mowoe MO. The evolution of mammal body sizes: responses to Cenozoic climate change in North American mammals.. J Evol Biol 2013 Jun;26(6):1317-29.
    doi: 10.1111/jeb.12138pubmed: 23675820google scholar: lookup
  69. MacFadden BJ. Fossil horses: Systematics, Paleobiology, and Evolution of the Family Equidae. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press; 1994.
  70. Mandlate LC, Arsenault R, Rodrigues FHG. Grass greenness and grass height promote the resource partitioning among reintroduced Burchell’s zebra and blue wildebeest in southern Mozambique. Austral Ecol 2019;44:648–657.
    doi: 10.1111/aec.12708google scholar: lookup
  71. Marín-Leyva AH, Alberdi MT, García-Zepeda ML, Ponce-Saavedra J, Schaaf P, Arroyo-Cabrales J, Bastir M. Geometric morphometrics in post-cranial bone elements of Late Pleistocene horses in Mexico: taxonomic and ecomorphological implications. Rev Mex Cienc Geol 2019;36(2):195–206.
    doi: 10.22201/cgeo.20072902e.2019.2.1044google scholar: lookup
  72. Marroig G, Cheverud JM. A comparison of phenotypic variation and covariation patterns and the role of phylogeny, ecology, and ontogeny during cranial evolution of new world monkeys.. Evolution 2001 Dec;55(12):2576-600.
    doi: 10.1111/j.0014-3820.2001.tb00770.xpubmed: 11831671google scholar: lookup
  73. Martin JM, Mead JI, Barboza PS. Bison body size and climate change.. Ecol Evol 2018 May;8(9):4564-4574.
    doi: 10.1002/ece3.4019pmc: PMC5938452pubmed: 29760897google scholar: lookup
  74. McHorse BK, Biewener AA, Pierce SE. Mechanics of evolutionary digit reduction in fossil horses (Equidae).. Proc Biol Sci 2017 Aug 30;284(1861).
    doi: 10.1098/rspb.2017.1174pmc: PMC5577487pubmed: 28835559google scholar: lookup
  75. Mendoza M, Janis CM, Palmqvist P. Estimating the body mass of extinct ungulates: a study on the use of multiple regression. J Zool 2005;270:90–101.
    doi: 10.1111/j.1469-7998.2006.00094.xgoogle scholar: lookup
  76. Mendoza M, Palmqvist P. Characterizing adaptive morphological patterns related to habitat use and body mass in Bovidae (Mammalia: Artiodactyla). Acta Zool Sin 2006;52:971–987.
  77. Moorcroft W. Travels in the provinces of Hindustand and the Panjab; in Ladakh and Kashmir; in Peshawar, Kabul, Kundaz, and Bokhara; from 1819 to 1825. London, United Kingdom: John Murray; 1841. p. 312.
  78. Nogués-Bravo D, Rodríguez J, Hortal J, Batra P, Araújo MB. Climate change, humans, and the extinction of the woolly mammoth.. PLoS Biol 2008 Apr 1;6(4):e79.
    doi: 10.1371/journal.pbio.0060079pmc: PMC2276529pubmed: 18384234google scholar: lookup
  79. Olsen EC, Miller RL. A mathematical model applied to a study of the evolution of species. Evolution 1951;5:325–338.
    doi: 10.2307/2405677google scholar: lookup
  80. Owen R. Description of the fossil remains of a mammal (Hyracotherium leporinum) and of a bird (Lithornis vulturinus) from the London Clay. Trans Geol Soc London 1841;6:203–208.
    doi: 10.1144/transgslb.6.1.20google scholar: lookup
  81. Pedersen TL. ggforce: accelerating ‘ggplot2.’. .
  82. Pineda-Munoz S, Jukar AM, Tóth AB, Fraser D, Du A, Barr WA, Amatangelo KL, Balk MA, Behrensmeyer AK, Blois J, Davis M, Eronen JT, Gotelli NJ, Looy C, Miller JH, Shupinski AB, Soul LC, Villaseñor A, Wing S, Lyons SK. Body mass-related changes in mammal community assembly patterns during the late Quaternary of North America. Ecography 2021;44(1):56–66.
    doi: 10.1111/ecog.05027google scholar: lookup
  83. Piras P, Maiorino L, Raia P, Marcolini F, Salvi D, Vignoli L, Kotsakis T. Functional and phylogenetic constrains in Rhinocerotinae craniodental morphology. Evol Ecol Res 2010;12:897–928.
  84. Pires MM, Koch PL, Fariña RA, de Aguiar MA, dos Reis SF, Guimarães PR Jr. Pleistocene megafaunal interaction networks became more vulnerable after human arrival.. Proc Biol Sci 2015 Sep 7;282(1814).
    doi: 10.1098/rspb.2015.1367pmc: PMC4571700pubmed: 26336175google scholar: lookup
  85. Plummer TW, Bishop LC. Hominid paleoecology at Olduvai Gorge, Tanzania as indicated by antelope remains. J Hum Evol 1994;27:47–75.
    doi: 10.1006/jhev.1994.1035google scholar: lookup
  86. Polly D. Limbs in mammalian evolution. In: Hall BK (ed) Fins into Limbs: Evolution, Development, and Transformation. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, pp 245–268.
    doi: 10.7208/9780226313405google scholar: lookup
  87. Porter L. Jack Wade Creek: an in situ Alaskan Late Pleistocene vertebrate assemblage. Arctic 1986;39(4):297–299.
    doi: 10.14430/arctic2090google scholar: lookup
  88. Priego-Vargas J, Bravo-Cuevas VM, Jiménez-Hidalgo E. Revisión taxonómica de los équidos del Pleistoceno de México con base en la morfología dental. Rev Bras Paleontol 2017;20(2):239–268.
    doi: 10.4072/rbp.2017.2.07google scholar: lookup
  89. R Core Team. R: A language and environment for statistical computing. R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria. 2021.
  90. Raghavan M, Themudo GE, Smith CI, Zazula GD, Campos PF. Musk ox (Ovibos moschatus) of the mammoth steppe: tracing palaeodietary and palaeoenvironmental changes over the last 50,000 years using carbon and nitrogen isotopic analysis. Quat Sci Rev 2014;102:192–201.
    doi: 10.1016/j.quascirev.2014.08.001google scholar: lookup
  91. Rasmussen SO, Bigler M, Blockley SP, Blunier T, Buchardt SL, Clausen HB, Cvijanovic I, Dahl-Jensen D, Johnsen SJ, Fischer H, Gkinis V, Guillevic M, Hoek WZ, Lowe JJ, Pedro JB, Popp T, Seierstad IK, Steffensen JP, Svensson AM, Vallelonga P, Vinther BM, Walker MJC, Wheatley JJ, Winstrup M. A stratigraphic framework for abrupt climatic changes during the Last Glacial period base don three synchronized Greenland ice-core records: refining and extending the INTIMATE event stratigraphy. Quat Sci Rev 2014;106:14–28.
    doi: 10.1016/j.quascirev.2014.09.007google scholar: lookup
  92. Ripley B, Venables B, Bates DM, Hornik K, Gebhardt A, Firth D. MASS: support functions and datasets for venables and Ripley’s MASS. .
  93. Rodríguez MÁ, Olalla-Tárraga MÁ, Hawkins BA. Bergmann’s rule and the geography of mammal body size in the Western Hemisphere. Glob Ecol Biogeogr 2008;17(2):274–283.
    doi: 10.1111/j.1466-8238.2007.00363.xgoogle scholar: lookup
  94. Saarinen J, Oksanen O, Žliobaitė I, Fortelius M, DeMiguel D, Azanza B, Bocherens H, Luzón C, Solano-García J, Yravedra J, Courtenay LA, Blain H-A, Sánchez-Bandera C, Serrano-Ramos A, Rodriguez-Alba JJ, Viranta S, Barsky D, Tallavaara M, Oms O, Agustí J, Ochando J, Carrión JS, Jiménez-Arenas JM. Pliocene to middle Pleistocene climate history in the Guadix-Baza Basin, and the environmental conditions of early Homo dispersal in Europe. Quat Sci Rev 2021;268:107132.
    doi: 10.1016/j.quascirev.2021.107132google scholar: lookup
  95. Schellhorn R, Pfretzschner H-U. Analyzing ungulate long bones as a tool for habitat reconstruction. Mamm Res 2015;60:195–205.
    doi: 10.1007/s13364-015-0218-0google scholar: lookup
  96. Schmidt-Nielsen K. Scaling: Why is Animal Size so Important?. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 1984.
  97. Schulz E, Kaiser TM. Historical distribution, habitat requirements and feeding ecology of the genus Equus (Perissodactyla). Mamm Rev 2013;43:111–123.
    doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2907.2012.00210.xgoogle scholar: lookup
  98. Schwartz-Narbonne R, Longstaffe FJ, Kardynal KJ, Druckenmiller P, Hobson KA, Jass CN, Metcalfe JZ, Zazula GD. Reframing the mammoth steppe: insights from analysis of isotopic niches. Quat Sci Rev 2019;215:1–21.
    doi: 10.1016/j.quascirev.2019.04.025google scholar: lookup
  99. Schweger CE. Late Pleistocene vegetation of eastern Beringia: pollen analysis of dated alluvium. In: Hopkins DM, editor. Paleoecology of Beringia. New York: Academic; 1982. pp. 95–112.
  100. Scott KM. Allometric trends and locomotor adaptations in the Bovidae. Bull Am Mus Nat Hist 1985;179:197–288.
  101. Scott KM. Poscranial dimensions of ungulates as predictors of body mass. In: Damuth J, MacFadden BJ, editors. Body size in Mammalian Palaeobiology: Estimation and Biological Implications. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 1990. pp. 301–336.
  102. Secord R, Bloch JI, Chester SG, Boyer DM, Wood AR, Wing SL, Kraus MJ, McInerney FA, Krigbaum J. Evolution of the earliest horses driven by climate change in the Paleocene-Eocene Thermal Maximum.. Science 2012 Feb 24;335(6071):959-62.
    pubmed: 22363006doi: 10.1126/science.1213859google scholar: lookup
  103. Semprebon GM, Rivals F, Solounias N, Hulbert RC. Paleodietary reconstruction of fossil horses from the Eocene through Pleistocene of North America. Palaeogeogr Palaeoclimatol Palaeoecol 2016;442:110–127.
    doi: 10.1016/j.palaeo.2015.11.004google scholar: lookup
  104. Sher AV. Mlekopitaiushchie i Stratigrafia Pleistotsena Krainego Severo-Vostoka SSSR i Severnoi Ameriki. Moskva: Nauka; 1971.
  105. Sheridan JA, Bickford D. Shrinking body size as an ecological response to climate change. Nat Clim Change 2011;1:401–406.
    doi: 10.1038/nclimate1259google scholar: lookup
  106. Shotwell JA. Late Tertiary biogeography of horses in the northern Great Basin. J Paleontol 1961;35:203–217.
  107. Simpson GG. Horses: The Story of the Horse Family in the Modern World and Through Sixty Million Years. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press; 1951.
  108. Sun B, Liu Y, Chen S, Deng T. Hippotherium Datum implies Miocene palaeoecological pattern.. Sci Rep 2022 Mar 4;12(1):3605.
    doi: 10.1038/s41598-022-07639-wpmc: PMC8897424pubmed: 35246584google scholar: lookup
  109. Thomason JJ. The functional morphology of the manus in tridactyl equids Merychippus and Mesohippus: paleontological inferences from neontological models. J Vertebr Paleontol 1986;6:143–161.
    doi: 10.1080/02724634.1986.10011607google scholar: lookup
  110. van Asperen EN. Ecomorphological adaptations to climate and substrate in late Middle Pleistocene caballoid horses. Palaeogeogr Palaeoclimatol Palaeoecol 2010;297(3–4):584–596.
    doi: 10.1016/j.palaeo.2010.09.007google scholar: lookup
  111. Vershinina AO, Heintzman PD, Froese DG, Zazula G, Cassatt-Johnstone M, Dalén L, Der Sarkissian C, Dunn SG, Ermini L, Gamba C, Groves P, Kapp JD, Mann DH, Seguin-Orlando A, Southon J, Stiller M, Wooller MJ, Baryshnikov G, Gimranov D, Scott E, Hall E, Hewitson S, Kirillova I, Kosintsev P, Shidlovsky F, Tong HW, Tiunov MP, Vartanyan S, Orlando L, Corbett-Detig R, MacPhee RD, Shapiro B. Ancient horse genomes reveal the timing and extent of dispersals across the Bering Land Bridge.. Mol Ecol 2021 Dec;30(23):6144-6161.
    doi: 10.1111/mec.15977pubmed: 33971056google scholar: lookup
  112. Voeten MM, Prins HH. Resource partitioning between sympatric wild and domestic herbivores in the Tarangire region of Tanzania.. Oecologia 1999 Aug;120(2):287-294.
    pubmed: 28308091doi: 10.1007/s004420050860google scholar: lookup
  113. Wagner GP, Altenberg L. PERSPECTIVE: COMPLEX ADAPTATIONS AND THE EVOLUTION OF EVOLVABILITY.. Evolution 1996 Jun;50(3):967-976.
    doi: 10.2307/2410639pubmed: 28565291google scholar: lookup
  114. Weber FR, Hamilton TD, Hopkins DM, Repenning CA, Haas H. Canyon Creek: a Late Pleistocene vertebrate locality in interior Alaska. Quat Res 1981;16:167–180.
    doi: 10.1016/0033-5894(81)90043-0google scholar: lookup
  115. Weinstock J, Willerslev E, Sher A, Tong W, Ho SY, Rubenstein D, Storer J, Burns J, Martin L, Bravi C, Prieto A, Froese D, Scott E, Xulong L, Cooper A. Evolution, systematics, and phylogeography of pleistocene horses in the new world: a molecular perspective.. PLoS Biol 2005 Aug;3(8):e241.
    doi: 10.1371/journal.pbio.0030241pmc: PMC1159165pubmed: 15974804google scholar: lookup
  116. Wickham H, François R, Henry L, Müller K. dplyr: a grammar of data manipulation. .
  117. Willerslev E, Davison J, Moora M, Zobel M, Coissac E, Edwards ME, Lorenzen ED, Vestergård M, Gussarova G, Haile J, Craine J, Gielly L, Boessenkool S, Epp LS, Pearman PB, Cheddadi R, Murray D, Bråthen KA, Yoccoz N, Binney H, Cruaud C, Wincker P, Goslar T, Alsos IG, Bellemain E, Brysting AK, Elven R, Sønstebø JH, Murton J, Sher A, Rasmussen M, Rønn R, Mourier T, Cooper A, Austin J, Möller P, Froese D, Zazula G, Pompanon F, Rioux D, Niderkorn V, Tikhonov A, Savvinov G, Roberts RG, MacPhee RD, Gilbert MT, Kjær KH, Orlando L, Brochmann C, Taberlet P. Fifty thousand years of Arctic vegetation and megafaunal diet.. Nature 2014 Feb 6;506(7486):47-51.
    doi: 10.1038/nature12921pubmed: 24499916google scholar: lookup
  118. Winans MC. A quantitative study of the North American fossil species of the genus Equus. In: Prothero DR, Schoch RM (eds) The Evolution of Perissodactyls. Oxf Monogr Geol Geophys 15:262–297.
  119. Wolf D, Nelson SV, Schwartz HL, Semprebon GM, Kaiser TM, Bernor RL. Taxonomy and paleoecology of the Pleistocene Equidae from Makuyuni, Northern Tanzania. Palaeodiversity 2010;3:249–269.
  120. Zazula GD, Froese DG, Schweger CE, Mathewes RW, Beaudoin AB, Telka AM, Harington CR, Westgate JA. Palaeobotany: Ice-age steppe vegetation in east Beringia.. Nature 2003 Jun 5;423(6940):603.
    pubmed: 12789326doi: 10.1038/423603agoogle scholar: lookup
  121. Zazula GD, Telka AM, Harington CR, Schweger CE, Mathewes RW. New spruce (Picea spp.) macrofossils from Yukon Territory: implications for late Pleistocene refugia in eastern Beringia. Arctic 2006;59:391–400.
    doi: 10.14430/arctic288google scholar: lookup
  122. Zhu D, Ciais P, Chang J, Krinner G, Peng S, Viovy N, Peñuelas J, Zimov S. The large mean body size of mammalian herbivores explains the productivity paradox during the Last Glacial Maximum.. Nat Ecol Evol 2018 Apr;2(4):640-649.
    doi: 10.1038/s41559-018-0481-ypmc: PMC5868731pubmed: 29483680google scholar: lookup
  123. Zimov SA, Chuprynin VI, Oreshko AP, Chapin FS, Reynolds JF, Chapin MC. Steppe-tundra transition: a herbivore-driven biome shift at the end of the Pleistocene. Am Nat 1995;146(5):765–794.
    doi: 10.1086/285824google scholar: lookup
  124. Zimov SA, Zimov NS, Tikhonov AN, Chapin FS. Mammoth steppe: a high-productivity phenomenon. Quat Sci Rev 2012;57:26–45.
    doi: 10.1016/j.quascirev.2012.10.005google scholar: lookup

Citations

This article has been cited 0 times.
Subscribe to our newsletter
Join 99,109 horse owners like you who receive our email updates on horse health and nutrition.