FREE SHIPPING over $40
OVER 9000 FIVE-STAR REVIEWS
5% OFF ALL SUBSCRIPTIONS
100% HAPPINESS GUARANTEE
Analyze Diet
0
Home / Equine Research Bank / Front Vet Sci / Using the Judgment Bias Task to Identify Behavioral Indicato...
Frontiers in veterinary science2021; 8; 676888; doi: 10.3389/fvets.2021.676888

Using the Judgment Bias Task to Identify Behavioral Indicators of Affective State: Do Eye Wrinkles in Horses Reflect Mood?

Abstract: Identifying and validating behavioral indicators of mood are important for the assessment of animal welfare. Here, we investigated whether horses' eye wrinkle expression in a presumably neutral situation is a measure of mood as assessed in a cognitive judgment bias task (JBT). To this end, we scored pictures of the left and right eyes of 16 stallions for different aspects of eye wrinkle expression and tested the same individuals on a spatial JBT with active trial initiation. Eye wrinkle expressions were assessed by a qualitative assessment, i.e., the overall assessment of how "worried" horses look, the number of wrinkles, and the angle measured at the intersection of lines drawn through the eyeball and the topmost wrinkle. Correlations between the three eye wrinkle measures and the optimism index as a measure of horses' decisions in the JBT were not statistically significant, but with increasing optimism index, horses tended to be scored as looking less worried (qualitative assessment). We discuss our findings from different perspectives and make suggestions for future research, e.g., by calling for experimental induction of mood and thus greater variation within and/or between individuals and by investigating the interplay between shorter-lasting emotional and longer-lasting mood states to further explore the potential use of the JBT to validate eye wrinkles and other facial or body expressions as indicators of mood.
Copyright © 2021 Hintze and Schanz.
Get Full Text
Publication Date: 2021-07-08 PubMed ID: 34307525PubMed Central: PMC8295722DOI: 10.3389/fvets.2021.676888Google Scholar: Lookup
The Equine Research Bank provides access to a large database of publicly available scientific literature. Inclusion in the Research Bank does not imply endorsement of study methods or findings by Mad Barn.
LinkedInCopy
  • Journal Article

Summary

This research summary has been generated with artificial intelligence and may contain errors and omissions. Refer to the original study to confirm details provided. Submit correction.

The research article focuses on whether horses’ eye wrinkles expression in a neutral condition can serve as an indicator of its mood, as evaluated through a cognitive judgement bias task (JBT). The authors found that while there was no significant correlation between the two, horses with a higher optimism index tended to look less worried.

Experimental Process

  • The experiment involved the analysis of photos of left and right eyes of 16 stallions, assessing various aspects of eye wrinkle expression.
  • This process was followed up with cognitive judgement bias tasks (JBTs) involving the same horses.
  • The eye wrinkle expressions were evaluated based on a qualitative measure of how “worried” the horses appeared, the number of wrinkles, and the angular values at the intersection of lines passing through the eyeball and the uppermost wrinkle.
  • The link between the three measurements of eye wrinkle expressions and the optimism index was examined. The optimism index was used as a measure of horses’ behaviours in the JBT.

Results

  • Statistical analysis revealed no significant correlations between the three eye wrinkle measures and the optimism index.
  • However, the results reveal a tendency for horses with an increasing optimism index to be scored as looking less “worried”.

Suggestions for Future Research

  • Authors discussed the results from various perspectives and have proposed suggestions for future investigations.
  • One key recommendation is to experimentally induce mood variations, which would increase variations within and/or among individual horses.
  • The authors also suggest investigating the relationship between transient emotional states and longer-lasting mood states. The aim of this would be to better understand the potential use of the JBT as a validation tool for facial indicators of mood, such as eye wrinkles.

Cite This Article

APA
Hintze S, Schanz L. (2021). Using the Judgment Bias Task to Identify Behavioral Indicators of Affective State: Do Eye Wrinkles in Horses Reflect Mood? Front Vet Sci, 8, 676888. https://doi.org/10.3389/fvets.2021.676888

Publication

Frontiers in veterinary science
ISSN: 2297-1769
NlmUniqueID: 101666658
Country: Switzerland
Language: English
Volume: 8
Pages: 676888
PII: 676888

Researcher Affiliations

Hintze, Sara
  • Division of Livestock Sciences, Department of Sustainable Agricultural Systems, University of Natural Resources and Life Sciences, Vienna, Austria.
Schanz, Lisa
  • Division of Livestock Sciences, Department of Sustainable Agricultural Systems, University of Natural Resources and Life Sciences, Vienna, Austria.

Conflict of Interest Statement

The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest. The reviewer MS declared a past co-authorship with one of the authors SH to the handling editor.

References

This article includes 45 references
  1. Descovich KA, Wathan J, Leach MC, Buchanan-Smith HM, Flecknell P, Farningham D, Vick SJ. Facial expression: An under-utilised tool for the assessment of welfare in mammals.. ALTEX 2017;34(3):409-429.
    doi: 10.14573/altex.1607161pubmed: 28214916google scholar: lookup
  2. Girard B, Bellone C. Revealing animal emotions.. Science 2020 Apr 3;368(6486):33-34.
    doi: 10.1126/science.abb2796pubmed: 32241939google scholar: lookup
  3. Ekman P, Friesen WV. Facial Action Coding System: A Technique for the Measurement of Facial Movement. Palo Alto: Consulting Psychologists Press; (1978).
  4. Parr LA, Waller BM, Vick SJ, Bard KA. Classifying chimpanzee facial expressions using muscle action.. Emotion 2007 Feb;7(1):172-81.
    doi: 10.1037/1528-3542.7.1.172pmc: PMC2826116pubmed: 17352572google scholar: lookup
  5. Waller BM, Lembeck M, Kuchenbuch P, Burrows AM, Liebal K. GibbonFACS: a muscle-based facial movement coding system for hylobatids. Int J Primatol (2012) 33:809–21.
    doi: 10.1007/s10764-012-9611-6google scholar: lookup
  6. Wathan J, Burrows AM, Waller BM, McComb K. EquiFACS: The Equine Facial Action Coding System.. PLoS One 2015;10(8):e0131738.
    doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0131738pmc: PMC4526551pubmed: 26244573google scholar: lookup
  7. Bremhorst A, Sutter NA, Würbel H, Mills DS, Riemer S. Differences in facial expressions during positive anticipation and frustration in dogs awaiting a reward.. Sci Rep 2019 Dec 17;9(1):19312.
    doi: 10.1038/s41598-019-55714-6pmc: PMC6917793pubmed: 31848389google scholar: lookup
  8. Waller BM, Peirce K, Caeiro CC, Scheider L, Burrows AM, McCune S, Kaminski J. Paedomorphic facial expressions give dogs a selective advantage.. PLoS One 2013;8(12):e82686.
    doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0082686pmc: PMC3873274pubmed: 24386109google scholar: lookup
  9. Bennett V, Gourkow N, Mills DS. Facial correlates of emotional behaviour in the domestic cat (Felis catus).. Behav Processes 2017 Aug;141(Pt 3):342-350.
    doi: 10.1016/j.beproc.2017.03.011pubmed: 28341145google scholar: lookup
  10. Caeiro CC, Burrows AM, Waller BM. Development and application of CatFACS : Are human cat adopters influenced by cat facial expressions?. Appl Anim Behav Sci (2017) 189:66–78.
    doi: 10.1016/j.applanim.2017.01.005google scholar: lookup
  11. Dalla Costa E, Minero M, Lebelt D, Stucke D, Canali E, Leach MC. Development of the Horse Grimace Scale (HGS) as a pain assessment tool in horses undergoing routine castration.. PLoS One 2014;9(3):e92281.
    doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0092281pmc: PMC3960217pubmed: 24647606google scholar: lookup
  12. Gleerup KB, Andersen PH, Munksgaard L, Forkman B. Pain evaluation in dairy cattle. Appl Anim Behav Sci (2015) 171:25–32.
    doi: 10.1016/j.applanim.2015.08.023google scholar: lookup
  13. Keating SC, Thomas AA, Flecknell PA, Leach MC. Evaluation of EMLA cream for preventing pain during tattooing of rabbits: changes in physiological, behavioural and facial expression responses.. PLoS One 2012;7(9):e44437.
    doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0044437pmc: PMC3436883pubmed: 22970216google scholar: lookup
  14. Langford DJ, Bailey AL, Chanda ML, Clarke SE, Drummond TE, Echols S, Glick S, Ingrao J, Klassen-Ross T, Lacroix-Fralish ML, Matsumiya L, Sorge RE, Sotocinal SG, Tabaka JM, Wong D, van den Maagdenberg AM, Ferrari MD, Craig KD, Mogil JS. Coding of facial expressions of pain in the laboratory mouse.. Nat Methods 2010 Jun;7(6):447-9.
    doi: 10.1038/nmeth.1455pubmed: 20453868google scholar: lookup
  15. Finlayson K, Lampe JF, Hintze S, Würbel H, Melotti L. Facial Indicators of Positive Emotions in Rats.. PLoS One 2016;11(11):e0166446.
    doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0166446pmc: PMC5130214pubmed: 27902721google scholar: lookup
  16. Lansade L, Nowak R, Lainé AL, Leterrier C, Bonneau C, Parias C, Bertin A. Facial expression and oxytocin as possible markers of positive emotions in horses.. Sci Rep 2018 Oct 2;8(1):14680.
    doi: 10.1038/s41598-018-32993-zpmc: PMC6168541pubmed: 30279565google scholar: lookup
  17. Boissy A, Aubert A, Greiveldinger L, Delval E, Veissier I. Cognitive sciences to relate ear postures to emotions in sheep. Anim Welf (2011) 20:47–56.
  18. Proctor HS, Carder G. Can ear postures reliably measure the positive emotional state of cows?. Appl Anim Behav Sci (2014) 161:20–7.
    doi: 10.1016/j.applanim.2014.09.015google scholar: lookup
  19. Gómez Y, Bieler R, Hankele AK, Zähner M, Savary P, Hillmann E. Evaluation of visible eye white and maximum eye temperature as non- invasive indicators of stress in dairy cows. Appl Anim Behav Sci (2018) 198:1–8.
    doi: 10.1016/j.applanim.2017.10.001google scholar: lookup
  20. Sandem A-I, Braastad BO. Effects of cow–calf separation on visible eye white and behaviour in dairy cows - A brief report. Appl Anim Behav Sci (2005) 95:233–9.
    doi: 10.1016/j.applanim.2005.04.011google scholar: lookup
  21. Coneglian MM, Borges TD, Weber SH, Bertagnon GH, Michelotto VP. Use of the horse grimace scale to identify and quantify pain due to dental disorders in horses. Appl Anim Behav Sci (2020) 225:104970.
    doi: 10.1016/j.applanim.2020.104970google scholar: lookup
  22. McLennan KM, Rebelo CJB, Corke MJ, Holmes MA, Leach MC, Constantino-Casas F. Development of a facial expression scale using footrot and mastitis as models of pain in sheep. Appl Anim Behav Sci (2016) 176:19–26.
    doi: 10.1016/j.applanim.2016.01.007google scholar: lookup
  23. Feldman Barrett L. Was darwin wrong about emotional expressions?. Curr Dir Psychol Sci (2011) 20:400–6.
    doi: 10.1177/0963721411429125google scholar: lookup
  24. Arellano D, Perales FJ, Varona J. Mood and its mapping onto facial expressions. In: Proc. 8th Int. Conf. AMDO 2014 (Palma de Mallorca: ), (2014). p. 31–40.
  25. Renneberg B, Heyn K, Gebhard R, Bachmann S. Facial expression of emotions in borderline personality disorder and depression.. J Behav Ther Exp Psychiatry 2005 Sep;36(3):183-96.
    doi: 10.1016/j.jbtep.2005.05.002pubmed: 15950175google scholar: lookup
  26. Jaeger J, Borod JC, Peselow E. Facial expression of positive and negative emotions in patients with unipolar depression.. J Affect Disord 1986 Jul-Aug;11(1):43-50.
    doi: 10.1016/0165-0327(86)90058-3pubmed: 2944927google scholar: lookup
  27. Schwartz GE, Fair PL, Salt P, Mandel MR, Klerman GL. Facial muscle patterning to affective imagery in depressed and nondepressed subjects.. Science 1976 Apr 30;192(4238):489-91.
    doi: 10.1126/science.1257786pubmed: 1257786google scholar: lookup
  28. Hintze S, Smith S, Patt A, Bachmann I, Würbel H. Are Eyes a Mirror of the Soul? What Eye Wrinkles Reveal about a Horse's Emotional State.. PLoS One 2016;11(10):e0164017.
    doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0164017pmc: PMC5061373pubmed: 27732647google scholar: lookup
  29. Schanz L, Krueger K, Hintze S. Sex and Age Don't Matter, but Breed Type Does-Factors Influencing Eye Wrinkle Expression in Horses.. Front Vet Sci 2019;6:154.
    doi: 10.3389/fvets.2019.00154pmc: PMC6549476pubmed: 31192235google scholar: lookup
  30. Bullock AB. The Expression and Regulation of Sadness in Complicated Grief. New York, NY: Columbia University; (2012).
  31. Ellgring H. Non-verbal Communication in Depression. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; (1989).
  32. Pampouchidou A, Marias K, Tsiknakis M, Yang F, Meriaudeau F. Designing a framework for assisting depression severity assessment from facial image analysis. In: 2015 IEEE International Conference on Signal Image Processing Applications (ICSIPA). Kuala Lumpur: IEEE; (2015). p. 578–83.
  33. Mendl M, Burman OHP, Parker RMA, Paul ES. Cognitive bias as an indicator of animal emotion and welfare: emerging evidence and underlying mechanisms. Appl Anim Behav Sci (2009) 118:161–81.
    doi: 10.1016/j.applanim.2009.02.023google scholar: lookup
  34. Roelofs S, Boleij H, Nordquist RE, van der Staay FJ. Making Decisions under Ambiguity: Judgment Bias Tasks for Assessing Emotional State in Animals.. Front Behav Neurosci 2016;10:119.
    doi: 10.3389/fnbeh.2016.00119pmc: PMC4899464pubmed: 27375454google scholar: lookup
  35. Neville V, Nakagawa S, Zidar J, Paul ES, Lagisz M, Bateson M, Løvlie H, Mendl M. Pharmacological manipulations of judgement bias: A systematic review and meta-analysis.. Neurosci Biobehav Rev 2020 Jan;108:269-286.
    doi: 10.1016/j.neubiorev.2019.11.008pmc: PMC6966323pubmed: 31747552google scholar: lookup
  36. Lagisz M, Zidar J, Nakagawa S, Neville V, Sorato E, Paul ES, Bateson M, Mendl M, Løvlie H. Optimism, pessimism and judgement bias in animals: A systematic review and meta-analysis.. Neurosci Biobehav Rev 2020 Nov;118:3-17.
    doi: 10.1016/j.neubiorev.2020.07.012pubmed: 32682742google scholar: lookup
  37. Hintze S, Melotti L, Colosio S, Bailoo JD, Boada-Saña M, Würbel H, Murphy E. A cross-species judgement bias task: integrating active trial initiation into a spatial Go/No-go task.. Sci Rep 2018 Mar 23;8(1):5104.
    doi: 10.1038/s41598-018-23459-3pmc: PMC5865189pubmed: 29572529google scholar: lookup
  38. R Core Team. R: A Language and Environment for Statistical Computing. Vienna: R Core Team; (2020).
  39. R Studio Team. RStudio: Integrated Development Environment for R. Boston, MA: R Core Team; (2021).
  40. Wickham H. ggplot2: Elegant Graphics for Data Analysis. New York, NY: Springer Nature; (2016).
  41. Pinheiro J, Bates D, DebRoy S, Sarkar D, R Core Team T. nlme: Linear and Nonlinear Mixed Effects Models_. R package version 3.1-137 (2018). Available online at: https://CRAN.R-project.org/package=nlme (accessed January 3, 2021).
  42. Rygula R, Pluta H, Popik P. Laughing rats are optimistic.. PLoS One 2012;7(12):e51959.
    doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0051959pmc: PMC3530570pubmed: 23300582google scholar: lookup
  43. Bremhorst A, Mills DS, Stolzlechner L, Würbel H, Riemer S. 'Puppy Dog Eyes' Are Associated With Eye Movements, Not Communication.. Front Psychol 2021;12:568935.
    doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2021.568935pmc: PMC7925631pubmed: 33679505google scholar: lookup
  44. Kaminski J, Hynds J, Morris P, Waller BM. Human attention affects facial expressions in domestic dogs.. Sci Rep 2017 Oct 19;7(1):12914.
    doi: 10.1038/s41598-017-12781-xpmc: PMC5648750pubmed: 29051517google scholar: lookup
  45. Clarkson JM, Leach MC, Flecknell PA, Rowe C. Negative mood affects the expression of negative but not positive emotions in mice.. Proc Biol Sci 2020 Aug 26;287(1933):20201636.
    doi: 10.1098/rspb.2020.1636pmc: PMC7482280pubmed: 32842924google scholar: lookup

Citations

This article has been cited 4 times.
  1. Long M, Dürnberger C, Jenner F, Kelemen Z, Auer U, Grimm H. Quality of Life within Horse Welfare Assessment Tools: Informing Decisions for Chronically Ill and Geriatric Horses. Animals (Basel) 2022 Jul 17;12(14).
    doi: 10.3390/ani12141822pubmed: 35883370google scholar: lookup
  2. Loftus L, Newman A, Leach M, Asher L. Exploring the induction and measurement of positive affective state in equines through a personality-centred lens. Sci Rep 2025 May 27;15(1):18550.
    doi: 10.1038/s41598-025-98034-8pubmed: 40425817google scholar: lookup
  3. Haussler KK, le Jeune SS, MacKechnie-Guire R, Latif SN, Clayton HM. The Challenge of Defining Laterality in Horses: Is It Laterality or Just Asymmetry?. Animals (Basel) 2025 Jan 21;15(3).
    doi: 10.3390/ani15030288pubmed: 39943060google scholar: lookup
  4. Hall C, Kay R. Living the good life? A systematic review of behavioural signs of affective state in the domestic horse (Equus caballus) and factors relating to quality of life. Part I: Fulfilment of species-specific needs. Anim Welf 2024;33:e40.
    doi: 10.1017/awf.2024.38pubmed: 39464387google scholar: lookup
Subscribe to our newsletter
Join 99,359 horse owners like you who receive our email updates on horse health and nutrition.