Effects of telemetry collars on two free-roaming feral equid species.
Abstract: There are two species of free-roaming feral equids in North America: horses (Equus caballus) and donkeys or "burros" (E. asinus). Both species were introduced as domestic animals to North America in the early 1500s and currently inhabit rangelands across the western United States, Canada, and all continents except Antarctica. Despite their global distribution, little is known about their fine scale spatial ecology. Contemporary research tools to assess space use include global positioning system (GPS) tracking collars, but older models were problematic due to stiff collar belting causing poor fit. We tested modern designs of GPS collars on n = 105 horses and n = 60 burros for 4 years in five populations (3 horse, 2 burro) across the western United States, to assess whether collars posed welfare risks to horses or burros. We found no difference in survival of collared versus uncollared mares and jennies, and no difference in survival of their foals. In 4036 of 4307 observations for horses (93.7%) and 2115 of 2258 observations for burros (93.6%), collars were observed symmetrical, maintaining proper fit on the neck. Fur effects from collars (sweaty neck, indented fur, broken fur) were seen in 3% of horse observations and 25% of burro observations. Superficial effects (chafes and marks on skin surface) were seen in 2% of horse observations and 11% of burro observations; no severe effects from collars were seen. Body condition was not affected by collars; mean body condition of collared horses was 4.70 ± 0.54 (mean ± s.d) and 4.71 ± 0.65 for collared burros. Behavior results indicated minimal effects; collared horses stood slightly more than uncollared, and collared burros stood and foraged more in one population, but not in the other. For 6.3% of observations of horses and 6.4% of observations of burros, we found an effect of time wearing a collar on the cumulative sum of fur effects which increased over time (burros: rs = 0.87, P = <0.0001; horses: rs = 0.31, P = 0.002). Burros also showed an increase over time in the number of superficial effects, but horses did not. Collars occasionally moved into the wrong position, shifting forward over the ears; we observed this on 19 horses and 1 burro. Of those, most collars went over the ears in summer (n = 12). All collars were equipped with a remote release mechanism as well as a timed-release mechanism for redundancy, thus removed when observed in wrong position to avoid rubbing or discomfort. Our finding of no consequential physical effects in 98% of horse observations, and 89% of burro observations suggests the consequences of collars on free-roaming equid welfare and survival is biologically insignificant, although collars should be monitored regularly and continue to be equipped with a remote release mechanism to remove a collar if needed. With frequent welfare-driven, visual monitoring, collaring of free-roaming equids can be a safe and useful tool to increase our understanding of their spatial ecology, demography, habitat use, behavior, and interactions with other wildlife.
Copyright: This is an open access article, free of all copyright, and may be freely reproduced, distributed, transmitted, modified, built upon, or otherwise used by anyone for any lawful purpose. The work is made available under the Creative Commons CC0 public domain dedication.
Publication Date: 2024-05-30 PubMed ID: 38814957PubMed Central: PMC11139308DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0303312Google Scholar: Lookup
The Equine Research Bank provides access to a large database of publicly available scientific literature. Inclusion in the Research Bank does not imply endorsement of study methods or findings by Mad Barn.
- Journal Article
Summary
This research summary has been generated with artificial intelligence and may contain errors and omissions. Refer to the original study to confirm details provided. Submit correction.
The paper outlines a scientific study that tested modern GPS collars on free-roaming feral horses and donkeys to monitor ecological activity. They found the use of these collars did not significantly impact the well-being or survival of these animals.
Study Context and Methodology
- The research involved testing on two species of indigenous North American equids: horses (Equus caballus) and donkeys, also known as “burros” (E. asinus).
- The need for the study arose as there is limited knowledge on these animals’ spatial ecology, despite a widespread global presence.
- The research team used modern GPS tracking collars to collect data, comparing their impact on 105 horses and 60 donkeys over a span of four years.
- The study focused on assessing whether these collars posed any threat to the wellbeing of the animals.
Results and Findings
- The researchers observed negligible differences in survival rates between collared and uncollared mares, jennies, and their foals.
- They also found no distinct consequence in the body condition for both collared donkeys and horses.
- Effects such as sweaty neck, indented fur, or broken fur were observed in just 3% of horse and 25% of burro observations. Superficial effects were found in even smaller percentages.
- Changes in behavior due to the collars were minimal. Collared horses stood up slightly more, and in one population, collared donkeys stood and foraged more – but this was not seen in another donkey population.
- For a minority of instances (6.3% of horse observations and 6.4% of burro observations), the cumulative sum of fur effects increased over time due to collar wearing.
Conclusions and Implications
- No severe effects from collars were found, but a handful of incidents where collars moved over the ears were observed. All these collars were equipped with a remote release mechanism, allowing for removal to avoid discomfort.
- They concluded that collars on animals had minimal health impact, affecting neither horses (98%) nor donkeys (89%) significantly.
- The research suggests the use of collars on free-roaming equids is biologically insignificant with regular monitoring, and with a remote release mechanism to remove a collar if needed.
- The results imply that GPS collar tracking can be a safe and useful method for understanding the spatial ecology, demography, habitat use, behavior, and relations with other wildlife of such animal groups.
Cite This Article
APA
Schoenecker KA, King SRB, Hennig JD, Cole MJ, Scasta JD, Beck JL.
(2024).
Effects of telemetry collars on two free-roaming feral equid species.
PLoS One, 19(5), e0303312.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0303312 Publication
Researcher Affiliations
- U.S. Geological Survey, Fort Collins Science Center, Fort Collins, CO, United States of America.
- Colorado State University, Fort Collins, CO, United States of America.
- University of Wyoming, Laramie, WY, United States of America.
- University of Arizona, Tucson, AZ, United States of America.
- Colorado State University, Fort Collins, CO, United States of America.
- University of Wyoming, Laramie, WY, United States of America.
- University of Wyoming, Laramie, WY, United States of America.
MeSH Terms
- Animals
- Telemetry
- Equidae / physiology
- Geographic Information Systems
- Horses
- Female
- Male
Conflict of Interest Statement
The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
References
This article includes 87 references
- Schmidt RH, Bruner JG. A professional attitude toward humaneness.. Wildlife Society Bulletin 1981; 9:289–291.
- Sikes RS. Guidelines of the American Society of Mammalogists for the use of wild mammals in research and education.. Journal of Mammalogy 2016; 97:663–688.
- Cox RJ, Nol P, Ellis CK, Palmer MV. Research with agricultural animals and wildlife.. ILAR Journal 2019;60:66–73.
- Scasta JD. Mortality and operational attributes relative to feral horse and burro capture techniques based on publicly available data from 2010–2019.. Journal of Equine Veterinary Science 2020;86:102893.
- Frey SN, Scasta JD, Beck JL, Singletary L. U.S. public opinion of reproductive control options for free-roaming horses on western public lands.. Human–Wildlife Interactions 2022;16:217–232.
- Schubert M, Jónsson H, Chang D, Der Sarkissian C, Ermini L, Ginolhac A. Prehistoric genomes reveal the genetic foundation and cost of horse domestication.. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 2014;111:E5661–E5669.
- Todd ET, Tonasso-Calvière L, Chauvey L, Schiavinato S, Fages A, Seguin-Orlando A. The genomic history and global expansion of domestic donkeys.. Science 2022;377:1172–1180.
- Scasta JD. Why are humans so emotional about feral horses? A spatiotemporal review of the psycho-ecological evidence with global implications.. Geoforum 2019;103:171–175.
- Taylor WT, Librado P, Hunska Tašunke Icu M, Shield Chief Gover C, Arterberry J, Luta Wiƞ A, Nujipi A, Omniya T, Gonzalez M, Means B, High Crane S. Early dispersal of domestic horses into the Great Plains and northern Rockies.. Science 2023. Mar 31;379(6639):1316–23.
- Taylor WT, Belardi JB, Barberena R, Coltrain JB, Marina FC, Borrero LA, Conver JL, Hodgins G, Admiraal M, Craig OE, Lucquin A. Interdisciplinary evidence for early domestic horse exploitation in southern Patagonia.. Science Advances 2023. Dec 8;9(49):eadk5201.
- LeSchack L. Issue statement feral horses and burros in North America, The Wildlife Society.. United States of America. 2016. CID: 20.500.12592/vmxg3b.
- Conant EK, Juras R, Cothran EG. A microsatellite analysis of five Colonial Spanish horse populations of the southeastern United States.. Animal Genetics 2012;43:53–62.
- Schoenecker KA, King SRB, Messmer TA. The wildlife profession’s duty in achieving science‐based sustainable management of free‐roaming equids.. The Journal of Wildlife Management 2021;85:1057–1061.
- Scasta JD, Hennig JD, Beck JL. Framing contemporary U.S. wild horse and burro management processes in a dynamic ecological, sociological, and political environment.. Human–Wildlife Interactions 2018;12:31–45.
- Rubin ES, Boyce WM, Stermer CJ, Torres SG. Bighorn sheep habitat use and selection near an urban environment.. Biological Conservation 2002;104:251–263.
- Monteith KL, Bleich VC, Stephenson TR, Pierce BM, Conner MM, Klaver RW. Timing of seasonal migration in mule deer: effects of climate, plant phenology, and life-history characteristics.. Ecosphere 2011;2:art47.
- Richard JH, Côté SD. Space use analyses suggest avoidance of a ski area by mountain goats.. Journal of Wildlife Management 2016;80:387–395.
- LaCava MEF, Gagne RB, Love Stowell SM, Gustafson KD, Buerkle CA, Knox L. Pronghorn population genomics show connectivity in the core of their range.. Journal of Mammalogy 2020;101:1061–1071.
- National Research Council (NRC). Using science to improve the BLM wild horse and burro program, A way forward.. The National Academies Press Washington, DC, USA; 2013.
- Schoenecker KA, Esmaeili S, King SRB. Seasonal resource selection and movement ecology of free-ranging horses in the western United States.. Journal of Wildlife Management 2023;87:e22341.
- Boyce PN. Feral horse ecology in the Rocky Mountain foothills of Alberta, Canada.. Ph.D. Dissertation, University of Saskatchewan. 2022.
- Esmaeili S, Jesmer BR, Albeke SE, Aikens EO, Schoenecker KA, King SRB. Body size and digestive system shape resource selection by ungulates: a cross-taxa test of the forage maturation hypothesis.. Ecology Letters 2021;24:2178–2191.
- Hennig JD, Beck JL, Scasta JD. Spatial ecology observations from feral horses equipped with global positioning system transmitters.. Human–Wildlife Interactions 2018;12:75–84.
- King SRB, Schoenecker KA. Comparison of methods to examine diet of feral horses from non-invasively collected fecal samples.. Rangeland Ecology and Management 2019;72:661–666.
- Esmaeili S, King SRB, Schoenecker KA. Browsers or grazers? New insights into feral burro diet using a non-invasive sampling and plant DNA metabarcoding approach.. Animals 2013;13: 2683.
- King SRB, Schoenecker KA, Cole MJ. Effect of adult male sterilization on the behavior and social associations of a feral polygynous ungulate: the horse.. Applied Animal Behaviour Science 2022;249:105598.
- King SRB, Cole MJ, Barton C, Schoenecker KA. Proximate factors affecting mortality and maternal abandonment of free-roaming feral horse foals.. Journal of Veterinary Behavior 2022;66:1–10.
- Hennig JD, Beck JL, Duchardt CJ, Scasta JD. Variation in sage-grouse habitat quality metrics across a gradient of feral horse use.. Journal of Arid Environments 2021;192:104550.
- Coates PS, O’Neil ST, Muñoz DA, Dwight IA, Tull JC. Sage‐grouse population dynamics are adversely affected by overabundant feral horses.. Journal of Wildlife Management 2021;85:1132–1149.
- Gooch AMJ, Petersen SL, Collins GH, Smith TS, McMillan BR, Eggett DL. The impact of feral horses on pronghorn behavior at water sources.. Journal of Arid Environments 2017;138:38–43.
- Berry KH, Yee JL, Lyren LM. Feral buros and other influences on desert tortoise presence in the western Sonoran Desert.. Herpetologica 2020;76: 403–413.
- Girard TL, Bork EW, Nielsen SE, Alexander MJ. Seasonal variation in habitat selection by free-ranging feral horses within Alberta’s forest reserve.. Rangeland Ecology and Management 2013;66:428–437.
- Leverkus SER, Fuhlendorf SD, Geertsema M, Allred BW, Gregory M, Bevington AR. Resource selection of free-ranging horses influenced by fire in northern Canada.. Human–Wildlife Interactions 2018;12:85–101.
- National Research Council (NRC). Wild horse populations: field studies in genetics and fertility: Report to the Bureau of Land Management, U.S. Department of the Interior.. National Academies of Science Washington, DC, USA; 1991.
- Hennig JD, Scasta JD, Beck JL, Schoenecker KA, King SRB. Systematic review of equids and telemetry collars: Implications for deployment and reporting.. Wildlife Research 2020;47:381–390.
- Frair JL, Nielsen SE, Merrill EH, Lele SR, Boyce MS, Munro RHM. Removing GPS collar bias in habitat selection studies.. Journal of Applied Ecology 2004;41:201–212.
- Habib TJ, Moore DA, Merrill EH. Detection and stratification approaches for aerial surveys of deer in prairie parklands.. Wildlife Research 2012;39:593–602.
- Singer FJ, Zeigenfuss LC. Influence of trophy hunting and horn size on mating behavior and survivorship of mountain sheep.. Journal of Mammalogy 2002;83:682–698.
- Schoenecker KA, Nielsen SE, Zeigenfuss LC, Pague CA. Selection of vegetation types and density of bison in an arid ecosystem.. Journal of Wildlife Management 2015;79:1117–1128.
- Ballard WB, Spraker TH, Taylor KP. Causes of neonatal moose calf mortality in south central Alaska.. Journal of Wildlife Management 1981;45:335–342.
- Bank MS, Franklin WL, Sarno RJ. Assessing the effect of radiocollars on juvenile guanaco survival.. Oecologia 2000;124:232–234.
- Augustine DJ, Derner JD. Assessing herbivore foraging behavior with GPS collars in a semiarid grassland.. Sensors 2013;13:3711–3723.
- Krausman PR, Bleich VC, Cain JW III, Stephenson TR, DeYoung DW, McGrath PW. From the field: neck lesions in ungulates from collars incorporating satellite technology.. Wildlife Society Bulletin 2004;32:987–991.
- Brooks C, Bonyongo C, Harris S. Effects of global positioning system collar weight on zebra behavior and location error.. Journal of Wildlife Management 2008;72:527–534.
- Bleich VC, Stephenson TR, Pierce BM, Warner MJ. Body condition of radio-collared mule deer while injured and following recovery.. Southwestern Naturalist 2007;52:164–167.
- Côté SD, Festa-Bianchet M, Fournier F. Life-history effects of chemical immobilization and radiocollars on mountain goats.. Journal of Wildlife Management 1998;62:745–752.
- Severud WJ, Giudice GD, Obermoller TR, Enright TA, Wright RG, Forester JD. Using GPS collars to determine parturition and cause‐specific mortality of moose calves.. Wildlife Society Bulletin 2015;39:616–625.
- Stabach JA, Cunningham SA, Connette G, Mota JL, Reed D, Byron M. Short-term effects of GPS collars on the activity, behavior, and adrenal response of scimitar-horned oryx (Oryx dammah).. PLoS ONE 2020;15:e0221843.
- Rasiulis AL, Festa‐Bianchet M, Couturier S, Côté SD. The effect of radio‐collar weight on survival of migratory caribou.. Journal of Wildlife Management 2014;78:953–956.
- Collins GH, Petersen SL, Carr CA, Pielstick L. Testing VHF/GPS collar design and safety in the study of free-roaming horses.. PLoS One 2014;9:e103189.
- United States Geological Survey (USGS), the National Map. 3DEP products and services: The National Map, 3D Elevation Program Web page.. 2016.
- PRISM Climate Group, Oregon State University. 2021. http://prism.oregonstate.edu
- Bureau of Land Management (BLM). Wild Horse and Burro Program data.. 2023.
- Kottek M, Grieser J, Beck C, Rudolf B, Rubel F. World map of the Köppen-Geiger climate classification updated.. Meteorologische Zeitschrift 2006;15:259–263.
- Van Devender TR, McClaran MP. The desert grassland.. University of Arizona Press; 1995.
- Harris JG. A vascular flora of the San Rafael swell, Utah.. The Great Basin Naturalist 1983;43:79–87.
- Bureau of Land Management (BLM). Instructional Memorandum 2015–151; Comprehensive animal welfare program for wild horse and burro gathers.. Washington, D.C., USA. 2015.
- Schoenecker KA, King SRB, Collins GH. Evaluation of the impacts of radio-marking devices on feral horses and burros in a captive setting.. Human–Wildlife Interactions 2020;14:73–86.
- Evans PA, Jack N. Aging horses by their teeth.. Utah State University Cooperative Extension Report AG/Equine/2007-06pr 2007.
- Henneke D, Potter G, Kreider J, Yeates B. Relationship between condition score, physical measurements and body fat percentage in mares.. Equine Veterinary Journal 1983;15:371–372.
- Schoenecker K.A., King S.R., Hennig J.C., Cole M.C., Scasta J.D., Beck J.L.. Data describing effects of telemetry collars on horses and burros between 2016 and 2020.. U.S. Geological Survey data release .
- Altmann J. Observational study of behavior: sampling methods.. Behaviour 1974;49:227–266.
- R Special Interest Group on Databases (R-SIG-DB), Wickham H, Müller K. DBI: R Database Interface.. R package version 1.1.3 2022.
- Müller K, Wickham H, James DA, Falcon S. RSQLite: SQLite Interface for R.. R package version 2.3.1 2023.
- R Development Core Team. R: A Language and Environment for Statistical Computing.. R Foundation for Statistical Computing Vienna Austria. 2016.
- Schloerke B, Cook D, Lamarangue J, Briatte F, Marbach M, Thoen E. GGally: Extension to ’ggplot2’.. R package version 2.1.2 2021.
- Naimi B, Hamm N, Groen TA, Skidmore AK, Toxopeus AG. Where is positional uncertainty a problem for species distribution modeling.. Ecography 2014;37:191–203.
- Bates D, Maechler M, Bolker B, Walker S. Fitting linear mixed-effects models using lme4.. Journal of Statistical Software 2015;67:1–48.
- Burnham KP, Anderson DR. Model selection and inference.. Springer, New York, NY .
- Anderson TW, Darling DA. A test of goodness-of-fit.. Journal of the American Statistical Association 1954;49:765–769.
- Kruskal WH, Wallis WA. Use of ranks in one-criterion variance analysis.. Journal of the American Statistical Association 1952;47:583–621.
- Herve M. RVAideMemoire: Testing and plotting procedures for biostatistics.. R package version 0.9-81–3 2022.
- Powell RA, Proulx G. Trapping and marking terrestrial mammals for research: integrating ethics, performance criteria, techniques, and common sense.. ILAR journal 2003;44:259–276.
- White GC, Garrott RA. Analysis of wildlife radio-tracking data.. Academic Press, New York, New York, USA 1990.
- Bleich VC, Bowyer RT, Pauli AM, Nicholson MC, Anthes RW. Mountain sheep Ovis canadensis and helicopter surveys: ramifications for the conservation of large mammals.. Biological Conservation 1994;70:1–7.
- Pastorini J, Prasad T, Leimgruber P, Isler K, Fernando P. Elephant GPS tracking collars: Is there a best?. Gajah 2015, 43:15–25.
- Wilson DE, Cole FR, Nichols JD, Rudran R, Foster MS (Eds). Measuring and monitoring biological diversity: standard methods for mammals.. 1996. Smithsonian Institution Press, Washington, D.C..
- Sikes RS, Gannon WL, and the Animal Care and Use Committee of the American Society of Mammologists. Guidelines of the American Society of Mammologists for the use of wild mammals in research.. Journal of Mammalogy 2011, 92(1): 235–253.
- Carroll CL, Huntington PJ. Body condition scoring and weight estimation of horses.. Equine Veterinary Journal 1988;20:41–45.
- Mottet R, Onan G, Hiney K. Revisiting the Henneke body condition scoring system: 25 years later.. Journal of Equine Veterinary Science 2009;29:417–418.
- Godfrey JD, Bryant DM, Williams MJ. Radio-telemetry increases free-living energy costs in the endangered Takahe Porphyrio mantelli.. Biological Conservation 2003;114:35–38.
- Withey JC, Bloxton TD, Marzluff JM. Effects of tagging and location error in wildlife radiotelemetry studies.. In: Millspaugh JJ, Marzluff JM, editors. Radio tracking and animal populations. Elsevier; 2001. pp. 43–75.
- Jung TS, Kuba K. Performance of GPS collars on free-ranging bison (Bison bison) in north-western Canada.. Wildlife Research 2015;42:315–323.
- Dick BL, Findholt SL, Johnson BK. A self‐adjusting expandable GPS collar for male elk.. Wildlife Society Bulletin 2013;37:887–892.
- Naidoo R, Du Preez P, Stuart-Hill G, Jago M, Wegmann M. Home on the range: factors explaining partial migration of African buffalo in a tropical environment.. PLoS ONE 2012;7:e36527.
- Scasta JD, Hennig JD, Calkins CM. Feral horse cause-specific mortality relative to mustering (gathering) and individual demographic attributes in the USA.. Wildlife Research 2021;48:673–689.
- Gedir JV, Cain JW, Lubow BC, Karish T, Delaney DK, Roemer GW. Estimating abundance and simulating fertility control in a feral burro population.. Journal of Wildlife Management 2021;85:1187–1199.
Citations
This article has been cited 0 times.Use Nutrition Calculator
Check if your horse's diet meets their nutrition requirements with our easy-to-use tool Check your horse's diet with our easy-to-use tool
Talk to a Nutritionist
Discuss your horse's feeding plan with our experts over a free phone consultation Discuss your horse's diet over a phone consultation
Submit Diet Evaluation
Get a customized feeding plan for your horse formulated by our equine nutritionists Get a custom feeding plan formulated by our nutritionists