The aggregation of four reconstructed zygotes is the limit to improve the developmental competence of cloned equine embryos.
Abstract: Embryo aggregation has been demonstrated to improve cloning efficiency in mammals. However, since no more than three embryos have been used for aggregation, the effect of using a larger number of cloned zygotes is unknown. Therefore, the goal of the present study was to determine whether increased numbers of cloned aggregated zygotes results in improved in vitro and in vivo embryo development in the equine. Zona-free reconstructed embryos (ZFRE's) were cultured in the well of the well system in four different experimental groups: I. 1x, only one ZFRE per microwell; II. 3x, three per microwell; III. 4x, four per microwell; and IV. 5x, five ZFRE's per microwell. Embryo size was measured on day 7, after which blastocysts from each experimental group were either a) maintained in culture from day 8 until day 16 to follow their growth rates, b) fixed to measure DNA fragmentation using the TUNEL assay, or c) transferred to synchronized mares. A higher blastocyst rate was observed on day 7 in the 4x group than in the 5x group. Non-aggregated embryos were smaller on day 8 compared to those aggregated, but from then on the in vitro growth was not different among experimental groups. Apoptotic cells averaged 10% of total cells of day 8 blastocysts, independently of embryo aggregation. Only pregnancies resulting from the aggregation of up to four embryos per microwell went beyond the fifth month of gestation, and two of these pregnancies, derived from experimental groups 3x and 4x, resulted in live cloned foals. In summary, we showed that the in vitro and in vivo development of cloned zona-free embryos improved until the aggregation of four zygotes and declined when five reconstructed zygotes were aggregated.
Publication Date: 2014-11-14 PubMed ID: 25396418PubMed Central: PMC4232247DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0110998Google Scholar: Lookup
The Equine Research Bank provides access to a large database of publicly available scientific literature. Inclusion in the Research Bank does not imply endorsement of study methods or findings by Mad Barn.
- Journal Article
- Research Support
- Non-U.S. Gov't
Summary
This research summary has been generated with artificial intelligence and may contain errors and omissions. Refer to the original study to confirm details provided. Submit correction.
The research article focuses on the study of how the number of aggregated zygotes, reconstructed for cloning, affects the developmental competence of embryos in horses. The study’s findings suggest that combining up to four zygotes improves both in vitro and in vivo embryo development, with a decrease in development when five or more zygotes are used.
Research Objective and Methodology
- Researchers sought to understand whether increasing the number of cloned zygotes aggregated for embryo development would improve the development of equine (horse) embryos both in vitro (outside the organism) and in vivo (within the organism).
- The embryos used were “zona-free reconstructed embryos” (ZFREs) – embryos that have been segmented or reassembled after removing the protective layer (the zona pellucida) and were divided into four experimental groups.
- Each of these groups represented varying numbers of ZFREs per well: group I included one ZFRE per well, group II included three, group III included four, and group IV included five.
- Researchers measured the size of these embryos seven days into development. Then, the resulting blastocysts (early stage embryos) were either tracked for additional growth, examined for DNA fragmentation using the TUNEL assay, or transferred into synchronized mares for in vivo observation.
Key Findings
- Researchers observed a higher rate of blastocyst formation on day seven in the group with four ZFREs per well as compared to the group with five ZFREs per well.
- Non-aggregated embryos (those that were not combined from multiple zygotes) were smaller on day eight compared to the aggregated ones, implying that aggregation contributes to early growth. However, from day eight onwards, the growth rate was similar across all groups.
- Apoptotic cells, or cells undergoing a programmed death, made up approximately 10% of all cells by day eight, with no discernible impact from embryo aggregation, suggesting that aggregation did not influence cell survivability.
- Only pregnancies resulting from the aggregation of up to four embryos per well advanced beyond the fifth month of gestation. Two pregnancies developed into live foals, both from groups with three and four zygotes per well aggregation.
- To summarise, the study demonstrated that the optimal number of zygotes for aggregation to improve equine embryo development, both in vitro and in vivo, is four. Development declined when five reconstructed zygotes were aggregated.
Cite This Article
APA
Gambini A, De Stefano A, Bevacqua RJ, Karlanian F, Salamone DF.
(2014).
The aggregation of four reconstructed zygotes is the limit to improve the developmental competence of cloned equine embryos.
PLoS One, 9(11), e110998.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0110998 Publication
Researcher Affiliations
- Laboratory of Animal Biotechnology, Faculty of Agriculture, University of Buenos Aires, Buenos Aires, Argentina; National Institute of Scientific and Technological Research, Buenos Aires, Argentina.
- Laboratory of Animal Biotechnology, Faculty of Agriculture, University of Buenos Aires, Buenos Aires, Argentina.
- Laboratory of Animal Biotechnology, Faculty of Agriculture, University of Buenos Aires, Buenos Aires, Argentina; National Institute of Scientific and Technological Research, Buenos Aires, Argentina.
- Laboratory of Animal Biotechnology, Faculty of Agriculture, University of Buenos Aires, Buenos Aires, Argentina.
- Laboratory of Animal Biotechnology, Faculty of Agriculture, University of Buenos Aires, Buenos Aires, Argentina; National Institute of Scientific and Technological Research, Buenos Aires, Argentina.
MeSH Terms
- Animals
- Blastocyst / cytology
- Cloning, Organism / methods
- DNA Fragmentation
- Embryo Culture Techniques
- Embryo, Mammalian / embryology
- Embryonic Development
- Horses / embryology
- In Situ Nick-End Labeling
- Zygote / growth & development
Conflict of Interest Statement
The authors received funding from SIDUS Company. This does not alter the authors' adherence to all the PLOS ONE policies on sharing data and materials.
References
This article includes 61 references
- Woods GL, White KL, Vanderwall DK, Li GP, Aston KI, Bunch TD, Meerdo LN, Pate BJ. A mule cloned from fetal cells by nuclear transfer.. Science 2003 Aug 22;301(5636):1063.
- Galli C, Lagutina I, Crotti G, Colleoni S, Turini P, Ponderato N, Duchi R, Lazzari G. Pregnancy: a cloned horse born to its dam twin.. Nature 2003 Aug 7;424(6949):635.
- Lagutina I, Lazzari G, Duchi R, Colleoni S, Ponderato N, Turini P, Crotti G, Galli C. Somatic cell nuclear transfer in horses: effect of oocyte morphology, embryo reconstruction method and donor cell type.. Reproduction 2005 Oct;130(4):559-67.
- Hinrichs K, Choi YH, Love CC, Chung YG, Varner DD. Production of horse foals via direct injection of roscovitine-treated donor cells and activation by injection of sperm extract.. Reproduction 2006 Jun;131(6):1063-72.
- Hinrichs K, Choi YH, Varner DD, Hartman DL. Production of cloned horse foals using roscovitine-treated donor cells and activation with sperm extract and/or ionomycin.. Reproduction 2007 Aug;134(2):319-25.
- Lagutina I, Lazzari G, Duchi R, Turini P, Tessaro I, Brunetti D, Colleoni S, Crotti G, Galli C. Comparative aspects of somatic cell nuclear transfer with conventional and zona-free method in cattle, horse, pig and sheep.. Theriogenology 2007 Jan 1;67(1):90-8.
- Choi YH, Hartman DL, Fissore RA, Bedford-Guaus SJ, Hinrichs K. Effect of sperm extract injection volume, injection of PLCzeta cRNA, and tissue cell line on efficiency of equine nuclear transfer.. Cloning Stem Cells 2009 Jun;11(2):301-8.
- Gambini A, Jarazo J, Olivera R, Salamone DF. Equine cloning: in vitro and in vivo development of aggregated embryos.. Biol Reprod 2012 Jul;87(1):15, 1-9.
- Choi YH, Norris JD, Velez IC, Jacobson CC, Hartman DL, Hinrichs K. A viable foal obtained by equine somatic cell nuclear transfer using oocytes recovered from immature follicles of live mares.. Theriogenology 2013 Mar 15;79(5):791-6.e1.
- Boiani M, Eckardt S, Leu NA, Schöler HR, McLaughlin KJ. Pluripotency deficit in clones overcome by clone-clone aggregation: epigenetic complementation?. EMBO J 2003 Oct 1;22(19):5304-12.
- Balbach ST, Esteves TC, Brink T, Gentile L, McLaughlin KJ, Adjaye JA, Boiani M. Governing cell lineage formation in cloned mouse embryos.. Dev Biol 2010 Jul 1;343(1-2):71-83.
- Zhou W, Xiang T, Walker S, Abruzzese RV, Hwang E, Farrar V, Findeisen B, Sadeghieh S, Arenivas F, Chen SH, Polejaeva I. Aggregation of bovine cloned embryos at the four-cell stage stimulated gene expression and in vitro embryo development.. Mol Reprod Dev 2008 Aug;75(8):1281-9.
- Ribeiro ES, Gerger RP, Ohlweiler LU, Ortigari I Jr, Mezzalira JC, Forell F, Bertolini LR, Rodrigues JL, Ambrósio CE, Miglino MA, Mezzalira A, Bertolini M. Developmental potential of bovine hand-made clone embryos reconstructed by aggregation or fusion with distinct cytoplasmic volumes.. Cloning Stem Cells 2009 Sep;11(3):377-86.
- Akagi S, Yamaguchi D, Matsukawa K, Mizutani E, Hosoe M, Adachi N, Kubo M, Takahashi S. Developmental ability of somatic cell nuclear transferred embryos aggregated at the 8-cell stage or 16- to 32-cell stage in cattle.. J Reprod Dev 2011 Sep;57(4):500-6.
- Terashita Y, Sugimura S, Kudo Y, Amano R, Hiradate Y, Sato E. Improving the quality of miniature pig somatic cell nuclear transfer blastocysts: aggregation of SCNT embryos at the four-cell stage.. Reprod Domest Anim 2011 Apr;46(2):189-96.
- Hillman N, Sherman MI, Graham C. The effect of spatial arrangement on cell determination during mouse development.. J Embryol Exp Morphol 1972 Oct;28(2):263-78.
- Boediono A, Suzuki T, Li LY, Godke RA. Offspring born from chimeras reconstructed from parthenogenetic and in vitro fertilized bovine embryos.. Mol Reprod Dev 1999 Jun;53(2):159-70.
- Lee SG, Park CH, Choi DH, Kim HS, Ka HH, Lee CK. In vitro development and cell allocation of porcine blastocysts derived by aggregation of in vitro fertilized embryos.. Mol Reprod Dev 2007 Nov;74(11):1436-45.
- Yang F, Hao R, Kessler B, Brem G, Wolf E, Zakhartchenko V. Rabbit somatic cell cloning: effects of donor cell type, histone acetylation status and chimeric embryo complementation.. Reproduction 2007 Jan;133(1):219-30.
- Ohtsuka M, Miura H, Gurumurthy CB, Kimura M, Inoko H, Yoshimura S, Sato M. Fluorescent transgenic mice suitable for multi-color aggregation chimera studies.. Cell Tissue Res 2012 Nov;350(2):251-60.
- He W, Kong Q, Shi Y, Xie B, Jiao M, Huang T, Guo S, Hu K, Liu Z. Generation and developmental characteristics of porcine tetraploid embryos and tetraploid/diploid chimeric embryos.. Genomics Proteomics Bioinformatics 2013 Oct;11(5):327-33.
- Hiriart MI, Bevacqua RJ, Canel NG, Fernández-Martín R, Salamone DF. Production of chimeric embryos by aggregation of bovine egfp eight-cell stage blastomeres with two-cell fused and asynchronic embryos.. Theriogenology 2013 Sep 1;80(4):357-64.
- Nakano K, Watanabe M, Matsunari H, Matsuda T, Honda K, Maehara M, Kanai T, Hayashida G, Kobayashi M, Kuramoto M, Arai Y, Umeyama K, Fujishiro SH, Mizukami Y, Nagaya M, Hanazono Y, Nagashima H. Generating porcine chimeras using inner cell mass cells and parthenogenetic preimplantation embryos.. PLoS One 2013;8(4):e61900.
- Shan ZY, Wu YS, Shen XH, Li X, Xue Y, Zheng Z, Wang ZD, Liu CJ, Sun RZ, Li ZY, Shen JL, Liu ZH, Lei L. Aggregation of pre-implantation embryos improves establishment of parthenogenetic stem cells and expression of imprinted genes.. Dev Growth Differ 2012 May;54(4):481-8.
- Eckardt S, McLaughlin KJ. Interpretation of reprogramming to predict the success of somatic cell cloning.. Anim Reprod Sci 2004 Jul;82-83:97-108.
- Hardy K. Cell death in the mammalian blastocyst.. Mol Hum Reprod 1997 Oct;3(10):919-25.
- Hardy K, Stark J, Winston RM. Maintenance of the inner cell mass in human blastocysts from fragmented embryos.. Biol Reprod 2003 Apr;68(4):1165-9.
- Hao Y, Lai L, Mao J, Im GS, Bonk A, Prather RS. Apoptosis and in vitro development of preimplantation porcine embryos derived in vitro or by nuclear transfer.. Biol Reprod 2003 Aug;69(2):501-7.
- Maddox-Hyttell P, Gjørret JO, Vajta G, Alexopoulos NI, Lewis I, Trounson A, Viuff D, Laurincik J, Müller M, Tveden-Nyborg P, Thomsen PD. Morphological assessment of preimplantation embryo quality in cattle.. Reprod Suppl 2003;61:103-16.
- Melka MG, Rings F, Hölker M, Tholen E, Havlicek V, Besenfelder U, Schellander K, Tesfaye D. Expression of apoptosis regulatory genes and incidence of apoptosis in different morphological quality groups of in vitro-produced bovine pre-implantation embryos.. Reprod Domest Anim 2010 Oct;45(5):915-21.
- Moussa M, Tremoleda JL, Duchamp G, Bruyas JF, Colenbrander B, Bevers MM, Daels PF. Evaluation of viability and apoptosis in horse embryos stored under different conditions at 5 degrees C.. Theriogenology 2004 Apr 1;61(5):921-32.
- Pomar FJ, Teerds KJ, Kidson A, Colenbrander B, Tharasanit T, Aguilar B, Roelen BA. Differences in the incidence of apoptosis between in vivo and in vitro produced blastocysts of farm animal species: a comparative study.. Theriogenology 2005 May;63(8):2254-68.
- Tecirlioglu RT, Cooney MA, Lewis IM, Korfiatis NA, Hodgson R, Ruddock NT, Vajta G, Downie S, Trounson AO, Holland MK, French AJ. Comparison of two approaches to nuclear transfer in the bovine: hand-made cloning with modifications and the conventional nuclear transfer technique.. Reprod Fertil Dev 2005;17(5):573-85.
- Misica-Turner PM, Oback FC, Eichenlaub M, Wells DN, Oback B. Aggregating embryonic but not somatic nuclear transfer embryos increases cloning efficiency in cattle.. Biol Reprod 2007 Feb;76(2):268-78.
- Oback B. Climbing Mount Efficiency--small steps, not giant leaps towards higher cloning success in farm animals.. Reprod Domest Anim 2008 Jul;43 Suppl 2:407-16.
- Siriboon C, Tu CF, Kere M, Liu MS, Chang HJ, Ho LL, Tai ME, Fang WD, Lo NW, Tseng JK, Ju JC. Production of viable cloned miniature pigs by aggregation of handmade cloned embryos at the 4-cell stage.. Reprod Fertil Dev 2014 Mar;26(3):395-406.
- Kurosaka S, Eckardt S, Ealy AD, McLaughlin KJ. Regulation of blastocyst stage gene expression and outgrowth interferon tau activity of somatic cell clone aggregates.. Cloning Stem Cells 2007 Winter;9(4):630-41.
- Vajta G, Peura TT, Holm P, Páldi A, Greve T, Trounson AO, Callesen H. New method for culture of zona-included or zona-free embryos: the Well of the Well (WOW) system.. Mol Reprod Dev 2000 Mar;55(3):256-64.
- Taka M, Iwayama H, Fukui Y. Effect of the well of the well (WOW) system on in vitro culture for porcine embryos after intracytoplasmic sperm injection.. J Reprod Dev 2005 Aug;51(4):533-7.
- Hoelker M, Rings F, Lund Q, Ghanem N, Phatsara C, Griese J, Schellander K, Tesfaye D. Effect of the microenvironment and embryo density on developmental characteristics and gene expression profile of bovine preimplantative embryos cultured in vitro.. Reproduction 2009 Mar;137(3):415-25.
- Sananmuang T, Phutikanit N, Nguyen C, Manee-In S, Techakumphu M, Tharasanit T. In vitro culture of feline embryos increases stress-induced heat shock protein 70 and apoptotic related genes.. J Reprod Dev 2013;59(2):180-8.
- Gopichandran N, Leese HJ. The effect of paracrine/autocrine interactions on the in vitro culture of bovine preimplantation embryos.. Reproduction 2006 Feb;131(2):269-77.
- Sancho M, Di-Gregorio A, George N, Pozzi S, Sánchez JM, Pernaute B, Rodríguez TA. Competitive interactions eliminate unfit embryonic stem cells at the onset of differentiation.. Dev Cell 2013 Jul 15;26(1):19-30.
- Balbach ST, Esteves TC, Houghton FD, Siatkowski M, Pfeiffer MJ, Tsurumi C, Kanzler B, Fuellen G, Boiani M. Nuclear reprogramming: kinetics of cell cycle and metabolic progression as determinants of success.. PLoS One 2012;7(4):e35322.
- Li J, Li R, Villemoes K, Liu Y, Purup S. Developmental potential and kinetics of pig embryos with different cytoplasmic volume. Zygote 15: 1–11.
- Lewis NE, Rossant J. Mechanism of size regulation in mouse embryo aggregates.. J Embryol Exp Morphol 1982 Dec;72:169-81.
- Rands GF. Size regulation in the mouse embryo. I. The development of quadruple aggregates.. J Embryol Exp Morphol 1986 Jun;94:139-48.
- Bertolini M, Beam SW, Shim H, Bertolini LR, Moyer AL, Famula TR, Anderson GB. Growth, development, and gene expression by in vivo- and in vitro-produced day 7 and 16 bovine embryos.. Mol Reprod Dev 2002 Nov;63(3):318-28.
- Vajta G, Hyttel P, Trounson AO. Post-hatching development of in vitro produced bovine embryos on agar and collagen gels. Anim Reprod Sci 60-61: 208.
- Brandão DO, Maddox-Hyttel P, Løvendahl P, Rumpf R, Stringfellow D, Callesen H. Post hatching development: a novel system for extended in vitro culture of bovine embryos.. Biol Reprod 2004 Dec;71(6):2048-55.
- Vejlsted M, Du Y, Vajta G, Maddox-Hyttel P. Post-hatching development of the porcine and bovine embryo--defining criteria for expected development in vivo and in vitro.. Theriogenology 2006 Jan 7;65(1):153-65.
- Alexopoulos NI, French AJ. The prevalence of embryonic remnants following the recovery of post-hatching bovine embryos produced in vitro or by somatic cell nuclear transfer.. Anim Reprod Sci 2009 Aug;114(1-3):43-53.
- Machado GM, Ferreira AR, Guardieiro MM, Bastos MR, Carvalho JO, Lucci CM, Diesel TO, Sartori R, Rumpf R, Franco MM, Dode MA. Morphology, sex ratio and gene expression of day 14 in vivo and in vitro bovine embryos.. Reprod Fertil Dev 2013;25(4):600-8.
- Machado GM, Ferreira AR, Pivato I, Fidelis A, Spricigo JF, Paulini F, Lucci CM, Franco MM, Dode MA. Post-hatching development of in vitro bovine embryos from day 7 to 14 in vivo versus in vitro.. Mol Reprod Dev 2013 Nov;80(11):936-47.
- Allen WR, Stewart F. Equine placentation.. Reprod Fertil Dev 2001;13(7-8):623-34.
- Tremoleda JL, Stout TA, Lagutina I, Lazzari G, Bevers MM, Colenbrander B, Galli C. Effects of in vitro production on horse embryo morphology, cytoskeletal characteristics, and blastocyst capsule formation.. Biol Reprod 2003 Dec;69(6):1895-906.
- Fischer B, Mootz U, Denker HW, Lambertz M, Beier HM. The dynamic structure of rabbit blastocyst coverings. III. Transformation of coverings under non-physiological developmental conditions.. Anat Embryol (Berl) 1991;183(1):17-27.
- Levy RR, Cordonier H, Czyba JC, Guerin JF. Apoptosis in preimplantation mammalian embryo and genetics.. Ital J Anat Embryol 2001;106(2 Suppl 2):101-8.
- Johnson AK, Clark-Price SC, Choi YH, Hartman DL, Hinrichs K. Physical and clinicopathologic findings in foals derived by use of somatic cell nuclear transfer: 14 cases (2004-2008).. J Am Vet Med Assoc 2010 May 1;236(9):983-90.
- Pedersen HG, Schmidt M, Sangild PT, Strøbech L, Vajta G, Callesen H, Greve T. Clinical experience with embryos produced by handmade cloning: work in progress.. Mol Cell Endocrinol 2005 Apr 29;234(1-2):137-43.
- Petters RM, Mettus RV. Survival rate to term of chimeric morulae produced by aggregation of five to nine embryos in the mouse, Mus musculus.. Theriogenology 1984 Aug;22(2):167-74.
Citations
This article has been cited 9 times.- Salamone D, Maserati M. Horse Somatic Cell Nuclear Transfer Using Zona Pellucida-Enclosed and Zona-Free Oocytes. Methods Mol Biol 2023;2647:269-281.
- Vajta G, Parmegiani L, Machaty Z, Chen WB, Yakovenko S. Back to the future: optimised microwell culture of individual human preimplantation stage embryos. J Assist Reprod Genet 2021 Oct;38(10):2563-2574.
- Gambini A, Duque Rodríguez M, Rodríguez MB, Briski O, Flores Bragulat AP, Demergassi N, Losinno L, Salamone DF. Horse ooplasm supports in vitro preimplantation development of zebra ICSI and SCNT embryos without compromising YAP1 and SOX2 expression pattern. PLoS One 2020;15(9):e0238948.
- Jeong PS, Yoon SB, Lee MH, Son HC, Lee HY, Lee S, Koo BS, Jeong KJ, Lee JH, Jin YB, Song BS, Kim JS, Kim SU, Koo DB, Sim BW. Embryo aggregation regulates in vitro stress conditions to promote developmental competence in pigs. PeerJ 2019;7:e8143.
- Xu L, Mesalam A, Lee KL, Song SH, Khan I, Chowdhury MMR, Lv W, Kong IK. Improves the In Vitro Developmental Competence and Reprogramming Efficiency of Cloned Bovine Embryos by Additional Complimentary Cytoplasm. Cell Reprogram 2019 Feb;21(1):51-60.
- Olivera R, Moro LN, Jordan R, Pallarols N, Guglielminetti A, Luzzani C, Miriuka SG, Vichera G. Bone marrow mesenchymal stem cells as nuclear donors improve viability and health of cloned horses. Stem Cells Cloning 2018;11:13-22.
- Olivera R, Moro LN, Jordan R, Luzzani C, Miriuka S, Radrizzani M, Donadeu FX, Vichera G. In Vitro and In Vivo Development of Horse Cloned Embryos Generated with iPSCs, Mesenchymal Stromal Cells and Fetal or Adult Fibroblasts as Nuclear Donors. PLoS One 2016;11(10):e0164049.
- Buemo CP, Gambini A, Moro LN, Hiriart MI, Fernández-Martín R, Collas P, Salamone DF. Embryo Aggregation in Pig Improves Cloning Efficiency and Embryo Quality. PLoS One 2016;11(2):e0146390.
- Nesiyama TNG, Sangalli JR, De Bem THC, Recchia K, Martins SMMK, de Andrade AFC, Ferst JG, Almeida GHDR, Marques MG, Dória RGS, Carregaro AB, Feliciano MAR, Miglino MA, Bressan FF, Perecin F, da Silveira JC, Smith LC, Bordignon V, Meirelles FV. Swine clones: potential application for animal production and animal models. Anim Reprod 2025;22(1):e20240037.
Use Nutrition Calculator
Check if your horse's diet meets their nutrition requirements with our easy-to-use tool Check your horse's diet with our easy-to-use tool
Talk to a Nutritionist
Discuss your horse's feeding plan with our experts over a free phone consultation Discuss your horse's diet over a phone consultation
Submit Diet Evaluation
Get a customized feeding plan for your horse formulated by our equine nutritionists Get a custom feeding plan formulated by our nutritionists