Conflict Between Direct Experience and Research-Based Evidence Is a Key Challenge to Evidence-Based Respiratory Medicine on British Racing Yards.
Abstract: Inflammatory airway disease (IAD) is a commonly diagnosed but variably defined syndrome of equine lower airway inflammation. The most recent American College of Veterinary Internal Medicine (ACVIM) consensus statement, informed by research evidence, recommends a case definition based on clinical signs (poor performance or occasional coughing of at least 3 weeks duration), increased endoscopically-visible tracheal mucus, and bronchoalveolar lavage cytology, and proposes that the condition should be termed 'mild-moderate equine asthma' (mEA). In British Thoroughbred racehorses, research to date has focused on airway inflammation defined by increased tracheal mucus and inflammatory tracheal wash sample cytology. It has been unclear whether or to what extent the ACVIM consensus statement has influenced the practice of British racing veterinarians. The aim of this qualitative study was to characterize and understand rationales for current practices relating to diagnosing and managing airway inflammation in British racehorses. Audio-recorded focus group discussions were conducted with 25 participants from four veterinary practices in England. Practices were purposively selected to represent those responsible for different types of racehorse, in different geographical regions. Thematic analysis of transcripts identified (i) an over-arching theme of within which two further themes (ii) and (iii) were nested. The requirement to serve the racing industry was a key driver of clinical approaches, strongly influenced in particular by the trainer. Participants widely disregarded the consensus case definition of IAD/mEA for British racehorses because of perceived differences in etiology, perceived lack of practicability, particularly of BAL sampling, and perceived lack of understanding of the British racing context by consensus authors. Participants shared a strong professional identity as pragmatic clinicians providing an individualized clinical approach based on direct experience, which was often prioritized as the most valuable evidence with which to inform clinical decision-making. Lack of alignment with international consensus presents a barrier to practicing and furthering evidence-based medicine. Improved dialogue and partnership in research would be valuable and further research tailored for this population, including continuing development of contextually acceptable diagnostic methods, may be required.
Copyright © 2020 Kinnison and Cardwell.
Publication Date: 2020-05-27 PubMed ID: 32537459PubMed Central: PMC7267464DOI: 10.3389/fvets.2020.00266Google Scholar: Lookup
The Equine Research Bank provides access to a large database of publicly available scientific literature. Inclusion in the Research Bank does not imply endorsement of study methods or findings by Mad Barn.
- Journal Article
- Airway Disease
- Asthma
- Bronchoalveolar Lavage
- Clinical Signs
- Clinical Study
- Diagnosis
- Diagnostic Technique
- Disease Diagnosis
- Disease Treatment
- Epidemiology
- Equine Diseases
- Equine Health
- Evidence-Based Medicine
- Horse Racing
- Inflammation
- Respiratory Health
- Thoroughbreds
- Veterinary Care
- Veterinary Medicine
- Veterinary Practice
- Veterinary Research
Summary
This research summary has been generated with artificial intelligence and may contain errors and omissions. Refer to the original study to confirm details provided. Submit correction.
The study investigates current practices and the reasons behind them in terms of diagnosing and managing inflammatory airway disease (now referred to as mild-moderate equine asthma) in British racehorses. Researchers found that many veterinarians ignored the standardized, research-backed definition and treatment on the basis of practicality and personal experience, presenting a challenge to evidence-based medicine.
Study Objective and Methodology
- This qualitative research aims to comprehend and outline the existing practices related to the diagnosis and management of airway inflammation in British racehorses.
- Twenty-five participants from four distinct veterinary practices in England became part of the audio-recorded focus group discussions. The practices were specifically picked to symbolize those catering to various types of racehorses, situated in different geographical regions.
- A thematic analysis of the transcripts was conducted to identify the main themes discussed during these group discussions.
Findings and Themes
- From the thematic analysis, the authors identified an overarching theme: the conflict between direct experience and research-based evidence, under which two more themes: the service to the racing industry and professional identity as pragmatic clinicians were nested.
- Participants commonly rejected the consensus definition (as given by the American College of Veterinary Internal Medicine) for equine mild asthma because they felt it did not take into account the unique factors associated with British racehorses.
- The refusal to follow the consensus case definition was influenced by several factors including perceived differences in causation of the disease, perceived impracticality of bronchoalveolar lavage sampling, and lack of understanding of the British racing context by consensus authors.
- Participants shared the identification as pragmatic clinicians who preferred their direct experience over research-based evidence when making decisions about treatment of the racehorses.
Conclusion and Implications
- The study concluded that the disparity with the international consensus presents an obstacle for practising and promoting evidence-based medicine.
- This research suggests that improved dialogue and partnership are needed in the research domain along with further research specifically tailored for the target population.
- Moreover, it concludes that the continued development of contextually acceptable diagnostic techniques may be necessary to help align the practices of British racing veterinarians with evidence-based medicine.
Cite This Article
APA
Kinnison T, Cardwell JM.
(2020).
Conflict Between Direct Experience and Research-Based Evidence Is a Key Challenge to Evidence-Based Respiratory Medicine on British Racing Yards.
Front Vet Sci, 7, 266.
https://doi.org/10.3389/fvets.2020.00266 Publication
Researcher Affiliations
- Royal Veterinary College (RVC), London, United Kingdom.
- Royal Veterinary College (RVC), London, United Kingdom.
References
This article includes 53 references
- Burrell MH, Wood JL, Whitwell KE, Chanter N, Mackintosh ME, Mumford JA. Respiratory disease in thoroughbred horses in training: the relationships between disease and viruses, bacteria and environment.. Vet Rec 1996 Sep 28;139(13):308-13.
- Wood JL, Newton JR, Chanter N, Mumford JA. Association between respiratory disease and bacterial and viral infections in British racehorses.. J Clin Microbiol 2005 Jan;43(1):120-6.
- Wood JL, Newton JR, Chanter N, Mumford JA. Inflammatory airway disease, nasal discharge and respiratory infections in young British racehorses.. Equine Vet J 2005 May;37(3):236-42.
- Jeffcott LB, Rossdale PD, Freestone J, Frank CJ, Towers-Clark PF. An assessment of wastage in thoroughbred racing from conception to 4 years of age.. Equine Vet J 1982 Jul;14(3):185-98.
- Rossdale PD, Hopes R, Digby NJ, offord K. Epidemiological study of wastage among racehorses 1982 and 1983.. Vet Rec 1985 Jan 19;116(3):66-9.
- Dyson PK, Jackson BF, Pfeiffer DU, Price JS. Days lost from training by two- and three-year-old Thoroughbred horses: a survey of seven UK training yards.. Equine Vet J 2008 Nov;40(7):650-7.
- Cardwell JM, Smith KC, Wood JL, Newton JR. Infectious risk factors and clinical indicators for tracheal mucus in British National Hunt racehorses.. Equine Vet J 2014 Mar;46(2):150-5.
- Millerick-May ML, Karmaus W, Derksen FJ, Berthold B, Holcombe SJ, Robinson NE. Local airborne particulate concentration is associated with visible tracheal mucus in Thoroughbred racehorses.. Equine Vet J 2013 Jan;45(1):85-90.
- Ivester KM, Couëtil LL, Moore GE, Zimmerman NJ, Raskin RE. Environmental exposures and airway inflammation in young thoroughbred horses.. J Vet Intern Med 2014 May-Jun;28(3):918-24.
- Holcombe SJ, Jackson C, Gerber V, Jefcoat A, Berney C, Eberhardt S, Robinson NE. Stabling is associated with airway inflammation in young Arabian horses.. Equine Vet J 2001 May;33(3):244-9.
- Sweeney CR, Humber KA, Roby KA. Cytologic findings of tracheobronchial aspirates from 66 thoroughbred racehorses.. Am J Vet Res 1992 Jul;53(7):1172-5.
- Moore BR, Krakowka S, Robertson JT, Cummins JM. Cytologic evaluation of bronchoalveolar lavage fluid obtained from standardbred racehorses with inflammatory airway disease.. Am J Vet Res 1995 May;56(5):562-7.
- Ward CL, Wood JL, Houghton SB, Mumford JA, Chanter N. Actinobacillus and Pasteurella species isolated from horses with lower airway disease.. Vet Rec 1998 Sep 5;143(10):277-9.
- Chapman PS, Green C, Main JP, Taylor PM, Cunningham FM, Cook AJ, Marr CM. Retrospective study of the relationships between age, inflammation and the isolation of bacteria from the lower respiratory tract of thoroughbred horses.. Vet Rec 2000 Jan 22;146(4):91-5.
- Christley RM, Hodgson DR, Rose RJ, Hodgson JL, Wood JL, Reid SW. Coughing in thoroughbred racehorses: risk factors and tracheal endoscopic and cytological findings.. Vet Rec 2001 Jan 27;148(4):99-104.
- Kusano K, Ishikawa Y, Seki K, Kusunose R. Characteristic of inflammatory airway disease in Japanese thoroughbred racehorses.. J Equine Sci 2008;19(2):25-9.
- Ramzan PH, Parkin TD, Shepherd MC. Lower respiratory tract disease in Thoroughbred racehorses: analysis of endoscopic data from a UK training yard.. Equine Vet J 2008 Jan;40(1):7-13.
- Cardwell JM, Wood JL, Smith KC, Newton JR. Descriptive results from a longitudinal study of airway inflammation in British National Hunt racehorses.. Equine Vet J 2011 Nov;43(6):750-5.
- Couëtil LL, Rosenthal FS, DeNicola DB, Chilcoat CD. Clinical signs, evaluation of bronchoalveolar lavage fluid, and assessment of pulmonary function in horses with inflammatory respiratory disease.. Am J Vet Res 2001 Apr;62(4):538-46.
- Depecker M, Richard EA, Pitel PH, Fortier G, Leleu C, Couroucé-Malblanc A. Bronchoalveolar lavage fluid in Standardbred racehorses: influence of unilateral/bilateral profiles and cut-off values on lower airway disease diagnosis.. Vet J 2014 Jan;199(1):150-6.
- Leclere M, Lavoie-Lamoureux A, Lavoie JP. Acute phase proteins in racehorses with inflammatory airway disease.. J Vet Intern Med 2015 May-Jun;29(3):940-5.
- Richard EA, Depecker M, Defontis M, Leleu C, Fortier G, Pitel PH, Couroucé-Malblanc A. Cytokine concentrations in bronchoalveolar lavage fluid from horses with neutrophilic inflammatory airway disease.. J Vet Intern Med 2014 Nov-Dec;28(6):1838-44.
- Couëtil LL, Cardwell JM, Gerber V, Lavoie JP, Léguillette R, Richard EA. Inflammatory Airway Disease of Horses--Revised Consensus Statement.. J Vet Intern Med 2016 Mar-Apr;30(2):503-15.
- Burrell MH. Endoscopic and virological observations on respiratory disease in a group of young Thoroughbred horses in training.. Equine Vet J 1985 Mar;17(2):99-103.
- Christley RM, Hodgson DR, Rose RJ, Wood JL, Reids SW, Whitear KG, Hodgson JL. A case-control study of respiratory disease in Thoroughbred racehorses in Sydney, Australia.. Equine Vet J 2001 May;33(3):256-64.
- Holcombe SJ, Robinson NE, Derksen FJ, Bertold B, Genovese R, Miller R, de Feiter Rupp H, Carr EA, Eberhart SW, Boruta D, Kaneene JB. Effect of tracheal mucus and tracheal cytology on racing performance in Thoroughbred racehorses.. Equine Vet J 2006 Jul;38(4):300-4.
- Widmer A, Doherr MG, Tessier C, Koch C, Ramseyer A, Straub R, Gerber V. Association of increased tracheal mucus accumulation with poor willingness to perform in show-jumpers and dressage horses.. Vet J 2009 Dec;182(3):430-5.
- Fraipont A, Van Erck E, Ramery E, Richard E, Denoix JM, Lekeux P, Art T. Subclinical diseases underlying poor performance in endurance horses: diagnostic methods and predictive tests.. Vet Rec 2011 Aug 6;169(6):154.
- Braun V, Clarke V. Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qual Res Psychol (2006) 3:77–101.
- Rcvs Knowledge.nWhat is EBVM? (2019) Available Online at: https://knowledge.rcvs.org.uk/evidence-based-veterinary-medicine/what-is-ebvm/ (accessed October 7, 2019).
- May SA. Veterinary ethics, professionalism and society. In: Wathes CM, Corr SA, May SA, McCulloch SP, Whiting MC, editors. Veterinary and Animal Ethics. Oxford: Blackwell Publishing Ltd; (2012). p. 44–58.
- Campbell ML. The role of veterinarians in equestrian sport: a comparative review of ethical issues surrounding human and equine sports medicine.. Vet J 2013 Sep;197(3):535-40.
- Evans DL, Kiddell L, Smith CL. Pulmonary function measurements immediately after exercise are correlated with neutrophil percentage in tracheal aspirates in horses with poor racing performance.. Res Vet Sci 2011 Jun;90(3):510-5.
- Wichtel M, Gomez D, Burton S, Wichtel J, Hoffman A. Relationships between equine airway reactivity measured by flowmetric plethysmography and specific indicators of airway inflammation in horses with suspected inflammatory airway disease.. Equine Vet J 2016 Jul;48(4):466-71.
- Richard EA, Fortier GD, Pitel PH, Dupuis MC, Valette JP, Art T, Denoix JM, Lekeux PM, Erck EV. Sub-clinical diseases affecting performance in Standardbred trotters: diagnostic methods and predictive parameters.. Vet J 2010 Jun;184(3):282-9.
- Coyne LA, Pinchbeck GL, Williams NJ, Smith RF, Dawson S, Pearson RB, Latham SM. Understanding antimicrobial use and prescribing behaviours by pig veterinary surgeons and farmers: a qualitative study.. Vet Rec 2014 Dec 13;175(23):593.
- Speksnijder DC, Wagenaar JA. Reducing antimicrobial use in farm animals: how to support behavioral change of veterinarians and farmers.. Anim Front 2018 Apr;8(2):4-9.
- King C, Smith M, Currie K, Dickson A, Smith F, Davis M, Flowers P. Exploring the behavioural drivers of veterinary surgeon antibiotic prescribing: a qualitative study of companion animal veterinary surgeons in the UK.. BMC Vet Res 2018 Nov 7;14(1):332.
- Smith M, King C, Davis M, Dickson A, Park J, Smith F, Currie K, Flowers P. Pet owner and vet interactions: exploring the drivers of AMR.. Antimicrob Resist Infect Control 2018;7:46.
- Lucas PJ, Cabral C, Hay AD, Horwood J. A systematic review of parent and clinician views and perceptions that influence prescribing decisions in relation to acute childhood infections in primary care.. Scand J Prim Health Care 2015 Mar;33(1):11-20.
- Elwyn G, Gwyn R, Edwards A, Grol R. Is 'shared decision-making' feasible in consultations for upper respiratory tract infections? Assessing the influence of antibiotic expectations using discourse analysis.. Health Expect 1999 May;2(2):105-117.
- Newton JR, Daly JM, Spencer L, Mumford JA. Description of the outbreak of equine influenza (H3N8) in the United Kingdom in 2003, during which recently vaccinated horses in Newmarket developed respiratory disease.. Vet Rec 2006 Feb 11;158(6):185-92.
- Schwechler J, van den Hoven R, Schoster A. Antimicrobial prescribing practices by Swiss, German and Austrian equine practitioners.. Vet Rec 2016 Feb 27;178(9):216.
- Raidal SL. Antimicrobial stewardship in equine practice.. Aust Vet J 2019 Jul;97(7):238-242.
- Hughes LA, Pinchbeck G, Callaby R, Dawson S, Clegg P, Williams N. Antimicrobial prescribing practice in UK equine veterinary practice.. Equine Vet J 2013 Mar;45(2):141-7.
- Hardefeldt LY, Browning GF, Thursky K, Gilkerson JR, Billman-Jacobe H, Stevenson MA, Bailey KE. Antimicrobials used for surgical prophylaxis by equine veterinary practitioners in Australia.. Equine Vet J 2018 Jan;50(1):65-72.
- Johnson LS. From knowledge transfer to knowledge translation: applying research to practice. Occup Ther Now (2005) 7:11–4.
- Fisher R. “A gentleman's handshake”: the role of social capital and trust in transforming information into usable knowledge. J Rural Stud (2013) 31:13–22.
- van Schaik SM, O'Sullivan PS, Eva KW, Irby DM, Regehr G. Does source matter? Nurses' and Physicians' perceptions of interprofessional feedback.. Med Educ 2016 Feb;50(2):181-8.
- Burford B. Group processes in medical education: learning from social identity theory.. Med Educ 2012 Feb;46(2):143-52.
- Malikides N, Hughes KJ, Hodgson DR, Hodgson JL. Comparison of tracheal aspirates and bronchoalveolar lavage in racehorses. 2. Evaluation of the diagnostic significance of neutrophil percentage.. Aust Vet J 2003 Nov;81(11):685-7.
- Salz RO, Ahern BJ, Boston R, Begg LM. Association of tracheal mucus or blood and airway neutrophilia with racing performance in Thoroughbred horses in an Australian racing yard.. Aust Vet J 2016 Apr;94(4):96-100.
- Bryman A. sampling in qualitative research. In: Social Research Methods. Oxford: Oxford University Press; (2016). p. 407–421.
Citations
This article has been cited 12 times.- Cullinane A, Garvey M, Walsh C, Gibbons J, Creighton A. A Scoping Review of Non-Structural Airway Disease as a Cause of Poor Performance in Racehorses. Animals (Basel) 2023 Jan 27;13(3).
- Gunasekara YD, Kinnison T, Kottawatta SA, Kalupahana RS, Silva-Fletcher A. Exploring Barriers to One Health Antimicrobial Stewardship in Sri Lanka: A Qualitative Study among Healthcare Professionals. Antibiotics (Basel) 2022 Jul 19;11(7).
- Holmes TQ, Brown AF. Champing at the Bit for Improvements: A Review of Equine Welfare in Equestrian Sports in the United Kingdom. Animals (Basel) 2022 May 5;12(9).
- Lee GKC, Beeler-Marfisi J, Viel L, Piché É, Kang H, Sears W, Bienzle D. Bronchial brush cytology, endobronchial biopsy, and SALSA immunohistochemistry in severe equine asthma. Vet Pathol 2022 Jan;59(1):100-111.
- Secombe C, Adler A, Hosgood G, Raisis A, Mosing M. Can bronchoconstriction and bronchodilatation in horses be detected using electrical impedance tomography?. J Vet Intern Med 2021 Jul;35(4):2035-2044.
- Couetil L, Cardwell JM, Leguillette R, Mazan M, Richard E, Bienzle D, Bullone M, Gerber V, Ivester K, Lavoie JP, Martin J, Moran G, Niedźwiedź A, Pusterla N, Swiderski C. Equine Asthma: Current Understanding and Future Directions. Front Vet Sci 2020;7:450.
- Bozzola C, Sala G, Stancari G, Ferrucci F, Zucca E. Comparison Between Tracheal Wash and Bronchoalveolar Lavage Cytology for the Assessment of Airway Inflammation in Racehorses Affected by Exercise-Induced Pulmonary Hemorrhage. Animals (Basel) 2025 Sep 5;15(17).
- Smith R, Pinchbeck G, McGowan C, Ireland J, Perkins E. Challenges for the veterinary profession: A grounded theory study of veterinarians' experiences of caring for older horses. Equine Vet J 2025 Jul;57(4):1053-1064.
- Leite RO, Albertino LG, Sperandio LMS, Campos F, Campos R, Borges AS, Oliveira-Filho JP. Evaluation of variants in the ENTPD1 and ENTPD2 genes in athletic horses with exercise-induced pulmonary haemorrhage. BMC Vet Res 2024 Aug 6;20(1):346.
- Smith R, Pinchbeck G, McGowan C, Ireland J, Perkins E. Becoming a matter of veterinary concern. Front Vet Sci 2024;11:1355996.
- van den Brom-Spierenburg AJ, Mureșan AN, Westermann CM. Antimicrobial Prescription Behavior in Equine Asthma Cases: An International Survey. Animals (Basel) 2024 Jan 30;14(3).
- Simões J, Tilley P. Decision Making in Severe Equine Asthma-Diagnosis and Monitoring. Animals (Basel) 2023 Dec 16;13(24).
Use Nutrition Calculator
Check if your horse's diet meets their nutrition requirements with our easy-to-use tool Check your horse's diet with our easy-to-use tool
Talk to a Nutritionist
Discuss your horse's feeding plan with our experts over a free phone consultation Discuss your horse's diet over a phone consultation
Submit Diet Evaluation
Get a customized feeding plan for your horse formulated by our equine nutritionists Get a custom feeding plan formulated by our nutritionists