FREE SHIPPING over $40
OVER 9000 FIVE-STAR REVIEWS
5% OFF ALL SUBSCRIPTIONS
100% HAPPINESS GUARANTEE
Analyze Diet
0
Home / Equine Research Bank / Equine Vet Educ / Is cloning horses ethical?
Equine veterinary education2016; 30(5); 268-273; doi: 10.1111/eve.12566

Is cloning horses ethical?

Abstract: This paper assesses whether cloning horses is ethical by reviewing ethical arguments against cloning of nonequine species and determining whether they apply to horses, analysing ethical arguments about horse cloning which do not apply to noncompetitive species and considering the ethical dilemmas faced by veterinarians involved in horse cloning. The author concludes that concerns about the health and welfare of cloned horses render the technique ethically problematic and that the onus is on those providing commercial equine cloning services to collate data and provide a stronger evidence base for ethical decision-making.
Get Full Text
Publication Date: 2016-03-07 PubMed ID: 29937631PubMed Central: PMC5993314DOI: 10.1111/eve.12566Google Scholar: Lookup
The Equine Research Bank provides access to a large database of publicly available scientific literature. Inclusion in the Research Bank does not imply endorsement of study methods or findings by Mad Barn.
LinkedInCopy
  • Journal Article
  • Review

Summary

This research summary has been generated with artificial intelligence and may contain errors and omissions. Refer to the original study to confirm details provided. Submit correction.

The research article examines the ethical implications of cloning horses, comparing these to ethical arguments related to the cloning of non-equine species and assessing the issues asserted by veterinarians in the field. Concerns are raised regarding the welfare of cloned horses, concluding that more evidence is required from commercial equine cloning services to solidify decision-making around the ethics of this practice.

Analysis of Ethical Arguments Against Cloning of Nonequine Species

  • The article begins by looking into the ethical issues surrounding cloning of non-equine species. This is carried out in order to draw parallels or contrasts to horse cloning.
  • An important focal point of this discussion is whether the ethical concerns associated with non-equine cloning, such as animal health and welfare, are equally relevant in the case of equine cloning.

Comparison with Ethical Arguments Against Horse Cloning

  • The article then shifts to detailing the ethical arguments specific to horse cloning, particularly those that don’t apply to noncompetive species.
  • Factors such as health considerations, psychological impact on the horse, and the commercialized nature of horse cloning form significant elements of this discussion.

Veterinary Dilemmas in Horse Cloning

  • This part of the study scrutinizes the dilemmas faced by veterinarians involved in the process of horse cloning.
  • The author assesses the ethical and practical challenges veterinarians have to deal with, including potential health risks to the cloned horses, and the responsibility of ensuring the welfare of these animals.

The Need for More Data

  • The paper maintains that the responsibility of ensuring ethical practice in horse cloning lies with those providing commercial equine cloning services.
  • This involves the requirement to collect and provide more data to support discussions on the ethical considerations and to guide and inform decision-making.

Conclusion

  • Ultimately, the author concludes that due to the health and welfare concerns for cloned horses, cloning is ethically problematic.
  • However, the onus is on the commercial equine cloning services to gather more data and provide a stronger basis for ethical decisions and future debates on the subject.

Cite This Article

APA
Campbell MLH. (2016). Is cloning horses ethical? Equine Vet Educ, 30(5), 268-273. https://doi.org/10.1111/eve.12566

Publication

Equine veterinary education
ISSN: 0957-7734
NlmUniqueID: 9885274
Country: England
Language: English
Volume: 30
Issue: 5
Pages: 268-273

Researcher Affiliations

Campbell, M L H
  • Department of Production and Population Health The Royal Veterinary College North Mymms Herts UK.

References

This article includes 40 references
  1. Aizaki H, Sawada M, Sato K. Consumers' attitudes toward consumption of cloned beef. The impact of exposure to technological information about animal cloning.. Appetite 2011 Oct;57(2):459-66.
    pubmed: 21723894doi: 10.1016/j.appet.2011.06.011google scholar: lookup
  2. . Europeans’ Attitudes Towards Animal Cloning. .
  3. . Food safety, animal health and welfare and environmental impact of animals derived from cloning by somatic cell nucleus transfer (scnt) and their offspring and products obtained from those animals. EFSA J 767, 1‐49.
  4. . Further advice on the implications of animal cloning (SCNT). EFSA J RN 319, 1‐15.
  5. . “Human Cloning”: a Discussion Paper for the World Medical Association. .
  6. Skene L, Testa G, Hyun I, Jung KW, McNab A, Robertson J, Scott CT, Solbakk JH, Taylor P, Zoloth L. Ethics report on interspecies somatic cell nuclear transfer research.. Cell Stem Cell 2009 Jul 2;5(1):27-30.
    pubmed: 19570511doi: 10.1016/j.stem.2009.06.010google scholar: lookup
  7. . Update on the state of play of animal cloning. EFSA J 8, 1784.
  8. . Measures on Animal Cloning for Food Production in the EU. .
  9. . Welfare Implications of Cloning: Letter to Lord Taylor. .
  10. . European Parliament votes to extend cloning ban proposals.. Vet Rec 2015 Oct 10;177(14):355.
    pubmed: 26449901doi: 10.1136/vr.h5362google scholar: lookup
  11. Arnold DR, Fortier AL, Lefebvre R, Miglino MA, Pfarrer C, Smith LC. Placental insufficiencies in cloned animals - a workshop report.. Placenta 2008 Mar;29 Suppl A:S108-10.
    pubmed: 18281092doi: 10.1016/j.placenta.2007.11.010google scholar: lookup
  12. Campbell ML, Sandøe P. Welfare in horse breeding.. Vet Rec 2015 Apr 25;176(17):436-40.
    pmc: PMC4431322pubmed: 25908746doi: 10.1136/vr.102814google scholar: lookup
  13. Chavatte-Palmer P, Remy D, Cordonnier N, Richard C, Issenman H, Laigre P, Heyman Y, Mialot JP. Health status of cloned cattle at different ages.. Cloning Stem Cells 2004;6(2):94-100.
    pubmed: 15268782doi: 10.1089/1536230041372274google scholar: lookup
  14. Galli C, Lagutina I, Crotti G, Colleoni S, Turini P, Ponderato N, Duchi R, Lazzari G. Pregnancy: a cloned horse born to its dam twin.. Nature 2003 Aug 7;424(6949):635.
    pubmed: 12904778doi: 10.1038/424635agoogle scholar: lookup
  15. Gamborg C, Gunning J, Hartlev M. Farm Animal Cloning: The Current Legislative Framework. .
  16. Gjerris M, Lassen J, Meyer G, Tveit G. Ethical Aspects of Farm Animal Cloning. A Synthesis Report. .
  17. Harris J. "Goodbye Dolly?" The ethics of human cloning.. J Med Ethics 1997 Dec;23(6):353-60.
    pmc: PMC1377577pubmed: 9451604doi: 10.1136/jme.23.6.353google scholar: lookup
  18. Herrera C. Social acceptance of equine ARTs: situation in South America. Proceedings of the IETS Equine Reproduction Symposium Paris: pp 30‐31.
  19. Hill JR. Incidence of abnormal offspring from cloning and other assisted reproductive technologies.. Annu Rev Anim Biosci 2014 Feb;2:307-21.
    pubmed: 25384145doi: 10.1146/annurev-animal-022513-114109google scholar: lookup
  20. Hinrichs K. Update on equine ICSI and cloning.. Theriogenology 2005 Aug;64(3):535-41.
    pubmed: 15985289doi: 10.1016/j.theriogenology.2005.05.010google scholar: lookup
  21. Hinrichs K. Equine cloning.. Vet Clin North Am Equine Pract 2006 Dec;22(3):857-66.
    pubmed: 17129808doi: 10.1016/j.cveq.2006.07.004google scholar: lookup
  22. Hinrichs K. Assisted reproduction techniques in the horse.. Reprod Fertil Dev 2012;25(1):80-93.
    pubmed: 23244831doi: 10.1071/rd12263google scholar: lookup
  23. Hinrichs K, Choi HY. Health of Horses Produced by ARTs. Proceedings of the IETS Equine Reproduction Symposium Paris: pp 42‐43.
  24. Houdebine LM, Dinnyés A, Bánáti D, Kleiner J, Carlander D. Animal cloning for food: epigenetics, health, welfare and food safety aspects. Trends Food Sci. Technol. 19, Suppl 1, S88‐S95.
  25. Jang G, Kim MK, Lee BC. Current status and applications of somatic cell nuclear transfer in dogs.. Theriogenology 2010 Nov;74(8):1311-20.
    pubmed: 20688377doi: 10.1016/j.theriogenology.2010.05.036google scholar: lookup
  26. Johnson AK, Clark-Price SC, Choi YH, Hartman DL, Hinrichs K. Physical and clinicopathologic findings in foals derived by use of somatic cell nuclear transfer: 14 cases (2004-2008).. J Am Vet Med Assoc 2010 May 1;236(9):983-90.
    pubmed: 20433399doi: 10.2460/javma.236.9.983google scholar: lookup
  27. Kim MJ, Oh HJ, Kim GA, Park JE, Park EJ, Jang G, Ra JC, Kang SK, Lee BC. Lessons learned from cloning dogs.. Reprod Domest Anim 2012 Aug;47 Suppl 4:115-9.
    pubmed: 22827359doi: 10.1111/j.1439-0531.2012.02064.xgoogle scholar: lookup
  28. Kim MJ, Oh HJ, Kim GA, Jo YK, Choi J, Kim HJ, Choi HY, Kim HW, Choi MC, Lee BC. Reduced birth weight, cleft palate and preputial abnormalities in a cloned dog.. Acta Vet Scand 2014 Mar 26;56(1):18.
    pmc: PMC3984017pubmed: 24669802doi: 10.1186/1751-0147-56-18google scholar: lookup
  29. Kühholzer-Cabot B, Brem G. Aging of animals produced by somatic cell nuclear transfer.. Exp Gerontol 2002 Dec;37(12):1317-23.
    pubmed: 12559401doi: 10.1016/s0531-5565(02)00176-6google scholar: lookup
  30. Lagutina I, Lazzari G, Duchi R, Colleoni S, Ponderato N, Turini P, Crotti G, Galli C. Somatic cell nuclear transfer in horses: effect of oocyte morphology, embryo reconstruction method and donor cell type.. Reproduction 2005 Oct;130(4):559-67.
    pubmed: 16183874doi: 10.1530/rep.1.00772google scholar: lookup
  31. Loi P, Clinton M, Vackova I, Fulka J Jr, Feil R, Palmieri C, Della Salda L, Ptak G. Placental abnormalities associated with post-natal mortality in sheep somatic cell clones.. Theriogenology 2006 Apr 1;65(6):1110-21.
    pubmed: 16154189doi: 10.1016/j.theriogenology.2005.07.016google scholar: lookup
  32. Nolen RS. The ethics debate over animal cloning.. J Am Vet Med Assoc 2007 Feb 15;230(4):467-8.
    pubmed: 17330348
  33. Petersen A. Replicating our bodies, losing our selves: news media portrayals of human cloning in the wake of Dolly. Body Soc 8, 71‐86.
  34. Reis AP. Acceptability of Biotechnologies in the Horse Industry in Europe. Proceedings of the IETS Equine Reproduction Symposium Paris: pp 34‐35.
  35. Renard JP, Zhou Q, LeBourhis D, Chavatte-Palmer P, Hue I, Heyman Y, Vignon X. Nuclear transfer technologies: between successes and doubts.. Theriogenology 2002 Jan 1;57(1):203-22.
    pubmed: 11775970doi: 10.1016/s0093-691x(01)00667-7google scholar: lookup
  36. Savulescu J. Equality, cloning and clonism: why we must clone. Bionews. The Progress Educational Trust 308.
  37. Shapiro HT. Cloning Human Beings: Report and Recommendations of the National Bioethics Advisory Commission. .
  38. Simpson JL. Could cloning become ethically permissible?. Reprod. Biomed. Online 14, Suppl. 1, 125‐129.
  39. van Wagtendonk-de Leeuw AM, Mullaart E, de Roos AP, Merton JS, den Daas JH, Kemp B, de Ruigh L. Effects of different reproduction techniques: AI MOET or IVP, on health and welfare of bovine offspring.. Theriogenology 2000 Jan 15;53(2):575-97.
    pubmed: 10735051doi: 10.1016/s0093-691x(99)00259-9google scholar: lookup
  40. Yang CY, Li RC, Pang CY, Yang BZ, Qin GS, Chen MT, Zhang XF, Huang FX, Zheng HY, Huang YJ, Liang XW. Study on the inter-subspecies nuclear transfer of river buffalo somatic cell nuclei into swamp buffalo oocyte cytoplasm.. Anim Reprod Sci 2010 Aug;121(1-2):78-83.
    pubmed: 20621244doi: 10.1016/j.anireprosci.2010.05.011google scholar: lookup

Citations

This article has been cited 1 times.
  1. Quain A, Ward MP, Mullan S. What Would You Do? Types of Ethical Challenging Situations Depicted in Vignettes Published in the Veterinary Literature from 1990 to 2020. Vet Sci 2021 Dec 22;9(1).
    doi: 10.3390/vetsci9010002pubmed: 35051086google scholar: lookup
Subscribe to our newsletter
Join 99,357 horse owners like you who receive our email updates on horse health and nutrition.