FREE SHIPPING over $40
OVER 9000 FIVE-STAR REVIEWS
5% OFF ALL SUBSCRIPTIONS
100% HAPPINESS GUARANTEE
Analyze Diet
0
Home / Equine Research Bank / PLoS One / Repeatability, reproducibility and consistency of horse shap...
PloS one2018; 13(8); e0202931; doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0202931

Repeatability, reproducibility and consistency of horse shape data and its association with linearly described conformation traits in Franches-Montagnes stallions.

Abstract: Linear description (LD) of conformation traits was introduced in horse breeding to minimise subjectivity in scoring. However, recent studies have shown that LD traits show essentially the same problems as traditionally scored traits, such as data converging around the mean value with very small standard deviations. To improve the assessment of conformation traits of horses, we investigated the application of the recently described horse shape space model based upon 403 digitised photographs of 243 Franches-Montagnes (FM) stallions and extracted joint angles based on specific landmark triplets. Repeatability, reproducibility and consistency of the resulting shape data and joint angles were assessed with Procrustes ANOVA (Rep) and intra-class correlation coefficients (ICC). Furthermore, we developed a subjective score to classify the posture of the horses on each photograph. We derived relative warp scores (PCs) based upon the digitised photos conducting a principal component analysis (PCA). The PCs of the shapes and joint angles were compared to the posture scores and to the linear description data using linear mixed effect models including significant posture scores as random factors. The digitisation process was highly repeatable and reproducible for the shape (Rep = 0.72-0.99, ICC = 0.99). The consistency of the shape was limited by the age and posture (p < 0.05). The angle measurements were highly repeatable within one digitiser. Between digitisers, we found a higher variability of ICC values (ICC = 0.054-0.92), indicating digitising error in specific landmarks (e.g. shoulder point). The posture scores were highly repeatable (Fleiss' kappa = 0.713-0.857). We identified significant associations (p(X2) < 0.05) with traits describing the withers height, shoulder length and incline, overall leg conformation, walk and trot step length. The horse shape data and angles provide additional information to explore the morphology of horses and therefore can be applied to improve the knowledge of the genetic architecture of LD traits.
Get Full Text
Publication Date: 2018-08-27 PubMed ID: 30148872PubMed Central: PMC6110498DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0202931Google Scholar: Lookup
The Equine Research Bank provides access to a large database of publicly available scientific literature. Inclusion in the Research Bank does not imply endorsement of study methods or findings by Mad Barn.
LinkedInCopy
  • Journal Article
  • Research Support
  • Non-U.S. Gov't

Summary

This research summary has been generated with artificial intelligence and may contain errors and omissions. Refer to the original study to confirm details provided. Submit correction.

The article focuses on the effectiveness of the linear description method of scoring traits in horse breeding, offering alternatives based on a horse shape model using photographs, and comparing joint angles and posture scores. The results showed that this method, which was highly repeatable and reproducible, can provide additional information for understanding horse morphology, improving the understanding of the genetic architecture of these traits.

Research Method

  • The researchers applied a recently developed horse shape space model to 403 digitised images of 243 Franches-Montagnes (FM) stallions.
  • The joint angles based on specific landmark triplets were extracted from the images.
  • They used Procrustes ANOVA and intra-class correlation coefficients to measure the repeatability, reproducibility, and consistency of the shape data and joint angles obtained.
  • A subjective score of the horse’s posture in each photo was created, and a principal component analysis was conducted to derive relative warp scores.
  • The researchers employed linear mixed-effect models to compare principal components of the shapes and joint angles to posture scores and linear description data.

Results and Findings

  • The digitisation process was found to be highly repeatable and reproducible, with consistency limited by factors such as the age and posture of the horse.
  • The angle measurements showed high repeatability but showed increased variability between different digitisers, indicating potential error for certain landmarks.
  • The posture scores were also highly repeatable and demonstrated significant associations with traits such as the horse’s withers height, shoulder length, overall leg conformation, and the length of walk and trot steps.

Impact

  • The results suggest that the horse shape data and angle measurements can reveal more information about horse morphology, enhancing knowledge of the genetic architecture associated with linear description traits.
  • This could potentially lead to more accurate and objective assessments of conformation traits in horse breeding by reducing the problems currently associated with the linear description scoring system.

Cite This Article

APA
Gmel AI, Druml T, Portele K, von Niederhäusern R, Neuditschko M. (2018). Repeatability, reproducibility and consistency of horse shape data and its association with linearly described conformation traits in Franches-Montagnes stallions. PLoS One, 13(8), e0202931. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0202931

Publication

PloS one
ISSN: 1932-6203
NlmUniqueID: 101285081
Country: United States
Language: English
Volume: 13
Issue: 8
Pages: e0202931
PII: e0202931

Researcher Affiliations

Gmel, Annik Imogen
  • Agroscope-Swiss National Stud Farm, Avenches, Switzerland.
  • Institute of Genetics, Vetsuisse Faculty, University of Bern, Bern, Switzerland.
Druml, Thomas
  • Institute of Animal Breeding and Genetics, Veterinary University Vienna, Vienna, Austria.
Portele, Katrin
  • Agroscope-Swiss National Stud Farm, Avenches, Switzerland.
  • Equine Sciences Faculty, Veterinary University Vienna, Vienna, Austria.
von Niederhäusern, Rudolf
  • Agroscope-Swiss National Stud Farm, Avenches, Switzerland.
Neuditschko, Markus
  • Agroscope-Swiss National Stud Farm, Avenches, Switzerland.
  • Institute of Animal Breeding and Genetics, Veterinary University Vienna, Vienna, Austria.

MeSH Terms

  • Animals
  • Body Constitution
  • Breeding
  • Horses / anatomy & histology
  • Horses / physiology
  • Linear Models
  • Movement
  • Phenotype
  • Posture
  • Reproducibility of Results

Conflict of Interest Statement

The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.

References

This article includes 38 references
  1. Petersen JL, Mickelson JR, Rendahl AK, Valberg SJ, Andersson LS, Axelsson J, Bailey E, Bannasch D, Binns MM, Borges AS, Brama P, da Câmara Machado A, Capomaccio S, Cappelli K, Cothran EG, Distl O, Fox-Clipsham L, Graves KT, Guérin G, Haase B, Hasegawa T, Hemmann K, Hill EW, Leeb T, Lindgren G, Lohi H, Lopes MS, McGivney BA, Mikko S, Orr N, Penedo MC, Piercy RJ, Raekallio M, Rieder S, Røed KH, Swinburne J, Tozaki T, Vaudin M, Wade CM, McCue ME. Genome-wide analysis reveals selection for important traits in domestic horse breeds.. PLoS Genet 2013;9(1):e1003211.
    doi: 10.1371/journal.pgen.1003211pmc: PMC3547851pubmed: 23349635google scholar: lookup
  2. Duensing J, Stock KF, Krieter J. Implementation and Prospects of Linear Profiling in the Warmblood Horse. Journal of Equine Veterinary Science 2014;34(3):360–8.
  3. Viklund A, Thorén Hellsten E, Näsholm A, Strandberg E, Philipsson J. Genetic parameters for traits evaluated at field tests of 3- and 4-year-old Swedish Warmblood horses.. Animal 2008 Dec;2(12):1832-41.
    doi: 10.1017/S1751731108003030pubmed: 22444090google scholar: lookup
  4. Olsson EG, Árnason T, Näsholm A, Philipsson J. Genetic parameters for traits at performance test of stallions and correlations with traits at progeny tests in Swedish warmblood horses. Livestock Production Science 2000;65(1):81–9.
  5. Schroderus E, Ojala M. Estimates of genetic parameters for conformation measures and scores in Finnhorse and Standardbred foals.. J Anim Breed Genet 2010 Oct;127(5):395-403.
    doi: 10.1111/j.1439-0388.2010.00856.xpubmed: 20831564google scholar: lookup
  6. Thompson J, Freeman A, Wilson D, Chapin CA, Berger P, Kuck A. Evaluation of a Linear Type Program in Holsteins1. Journal of Dairy Science 1981;64(7):1610–7.
  7. Pfammatter M. Le système de description linéaire au sein de la race des Franches-Montagnes [Bachelor]. Zollikofen, Switzerland: Haute école des sciences agronomiques, forestières et alimentaires; 2017.
  8. Burren A, Bangerter E, Hagger C, Rieder S, Flury C. Züchterische Auswertung beim Freiberger Pferd. 2015.
  9. Koenen E, Van Veldhuizen A, Brascamp E. Genetic parameters of linear scored conformation traits and their relation to dressage and show-jumping performance in the Dutch Warmblood Riding Horse population. Livestock Production Science 1995;43(1):85–94.
  10. Viklund Å, Eriksson S. Genetic analyses of linear profiling data on 3-year-old Swedish Warmblood horses.. J Anim Breed Genet 2018 Feb;135(1):62-72.
    doi: 10.1111/jbg.12311pubmed: 29345075google scholar: lookup
  11. Samoré A, Pagnacco G, Miglior F. Genetic parameters and breeding values for linear type traits in the Haflinger horse. Livestock Production Science 1997;52(2):105–11.
  12. Druml T, Dobretsberger M, Brem G. The use of novel phenotyping methods for validation of equine conformation scoring results.. Animal 2015 Jun;9(6):928-37.
    doi: 10.1017/S1751731114002602pubmed: 25582051google scholar: lookup
  13. Mitteroecker P, Gunz P. Advances in geometric morphometrics. Evolutionary Biology 2009;36(2):235–47.
  14. Bignon O, Baylac M, Vigne J-D, Eisenmann V. Geometric morphometrics and the population diversity of Late Glacial horses in Western Europe (Equus caballus arcelini): phylogeographic and anthropological implications. Journal of archaeological science 2005;32(3):375–91.
  15. Seetah K, Cucchi T, Dobney K, Barker G. A geometric morphometric re-evaluation of the use of dental form to explore differences in horse (Equus caballus) populations and its potential zooarchaeological application. Journal of Archaeological Science 2014;41:904–10.
  16. Druml T, Dobretsberger M, Brem G. Ratings of equine conformation–new insights provided by shape analysis using the example of Lipizzan stallions. Archives Animal Breeding 2016;59(2):309–17.
  17. Weller R, Pfau T, Babbage D, Brittin E, May SA, Wilson AM. Reliability of conformational measurements in the horse using a three-dimensional motion analysis system.. Equine Vet J 2006 Nov;38(7):610-5.
    pubmed: 17228574doi: 10.2746/042516406x150367google scholar: lookup
  18. Weller R, Pfau T, May SA, Wilson AM. Variation in conformation in a cohort of National Hunt racehorses.. Equine Vet J 2006 Nov;38(7):616-21.
    pubmed: 17228575doi: 10.2746/042516406x150394google scholar: lookup
  19. Anderson TM, McIlwraith CW. Longitudinal development of equine conformation from weanling to age 3 years in the Thoroughbred.. Equine Vet J 2004 Nov;36(7):563-70.
    pubmed: 15581319doi: 10.2746/0425164044864507google scholar: lookup
  20. Rohlf FJ. tps Utility Program, file utility program. version 1.68. Departement of Ecology & Evolution, State University of New York SUNY at Stony Brook, New York, USA. 2016.
  21. Rohlf FJ. tpsDig2, digitize landmarks and outlines. version 2.26. Departement of Ecology & Evolution, State University of New York SUNY at Stony Brook, New York, USA. 2016.
  22. R Core Team. R: A Language and Environment for Statistical Computing. version 3.4.1. R Foundation for Statistical Computing. 2017.
  23. Adams D, Collyer M, Otarola-Castillo E, Sherratt E. geomorph R package, Software for geometric morphometric analyses. version 3.0.5. R Foundation for Statistical Computing. 2014.
  24. Wolak ME. ICC R package, Facilitating Estimation of the Intraclass Correlation. version 2.3.0. R Foundation for Statistical Computing. 2015.
  25. Cicchetti DV. Guidelines, criteria, and rules of thumb for evaluating normed and standardized assessment instruments in psychology. Psychological assessment 1994;6(4):284.
  26. Zelditch ML, Swiderski DL, Sheets HD. Geometric morphometrics for biologists: a primer. Academic Press; 2012.
  27. Gamer M, Lemon J, Singh P. irr R package, Various Coefficients of Interrater Reliability and Agreement. version 0.84. R Foundation for Statistical Computing. 2012.
  28. Kuznetsova A, Bruun Brockhoff P, Haubo Bojesen Christensen R. lmerTest R package, Tests in Linear Mixed Effects Models. version 2.0–33. R Foundation for Statistical Computing. 2016.
  29. Lefcheck JS. piecewiseSEM R package, Piecewise Structural Equation Modeling. version 1.2.1. R Foundation for Statistical Computing. 2016.
  30. Nakagawa S, Schielzeth H. A general and simple method for obtaining R2 from generalized linear mixed‐effects models. Methods in Ecology and Evolution 2013;4(2):133–42.
  31. Fruciano C. Measurement error in geometric morphometrics.. Dev Genes Evol 2016 Jun;226(3):139-58.
    doi: 10.1007/s00427-016-0537-4pubmed: 27038025google scholar: lookup
  32. Plyusnin I, Evans AR, Karme A, Gionis A, Jernvall J. Automated 3D phenotype analysis using data mining.. PLoS One 2008 Mar 5;3(3):e1742.
    doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0001742pmc: PMC2254194pubmed: 18320060google scholar: lookup
  33. Bromiley PA, Schunke AC, Ragheb H, Thacker NA, Tautz D. Semi-automatic landmark point annotation for geometric morphometrics. Frontiers in Zoology 2014;11(1):61.
  34. Sánchez MJ, Azor PJ, Molina A, Parkin T, Rivero JL, Valera M. Prevalence, risk factors and genetic parameters of cresty neck in Pura Raza Español horses.. Equine Vet J 2017 Mar;49(2):196-200.
    doi: 10.1111/evj.12569pubmed: 26877245google scholar: lookup
  35. Smythe RH. What Makes a Good Horse: Its Structure and Performance. Country Life; 1957.
  36. Kropatsch WG. Von digitalen RGBD-Bildern zum Modell—3D-Bildanalyse zur Phänotypisierung. In: Brem G, editor. Phänotypisierung—Vom Schein zum Sein; Vienna: Nova Acta Leopoldina; 2015. p. 93–103.
  37. Institut français du cheval et de l'équitation IFCE. Mesures scientifiques. In: Institut français du cheval et de l'équitation IFCE, Les Haras du Pin, editors. Appréciation du modèle et des allures—chevaux de selle, chevaux de trait, ânes et poneys. 9th ed. Exmes, France2018.
  38. Kristjansson T, Bjornsdottir S, Sigurdsson A, Crevier-Denoix N, Pourcelot P, Arnason T. Objective quantification of conformation of the Icelandic horse based on 3-D video morphometric measurements. Livestock Science 2013;158(1–3):12–23.

Citations

This article has been cited 13 times.
  1. Gmel AI, Brem G, Neuditschko M. New genomic insights into the conformation of Lipizzan horses. Sci Rep 2023 Jun 2;13(1):8990.
    doi: 10.1038/s41598-023-36272-4pubmed: 37268682google scholar: lookup
  2. McVey C, Egger D, Pinedo P. Improving the Reliability of Scale-Free Image Morphometrics in Applications with Minimally Restrained Livestock Using Projective Geometry and Unsupervised Machine Learning. Sensors (Basel) 2022 Oct 31;22(21).
    doi: 10.3390/s22218347pubmed: 36366045google scholar: lookup
  3. Gmel AI, Burren A, Neuditschko M. Estimates of Genetic Parameters for Shape Space Data in Franches-Montagnes Horses. Animals (Basel) 2022 Aug 25;12(17).
    doi: 10.3390/ani12172186pubmed: 36077906google scholar: lookup
  4. Roth IT, Schielke B, Rensing M, Bernau M. Comparison of American Quarter Horses Competing in Western Pleasure, Hunter under Saddle, and Reining Using Linear Traits. Animals (Basel) 2021 Sep 30;11(10).
    doi: 10.3390/ani11102861pubmed: 34679888google scholar: lookup
  5. Raspa F, Roggero A, Palestrini C, Marten Canavesio M, Bergero D, Valle E. Studying the Shape Variations of the Back, the Neck, and the Mandibular Angle of Horses Depending on Specific Feeding Postures Using Geometric Morphometrics. Animals (Basel) 2021 Mar 10;11(3).
    doi: 10.3390/ani11030763pubmed: 33801885google scholar: lookup
  6. Folla F, Sartori C, Mancin E, Pigozzi G, Mantovani R. Genetic Parameters of Linear Type Traits Scored at 30 Months in Italian Heavy Draught Horse. Animals (Basel) 2020 Jun 25;10(6).
    doi: 10.3390/ani10061099pubmed: 32630510google scholar: lookup
  7. Gmel AI, Druml T, von Niederhäusern R, Leeb T, Neuditschko M. Genome-Wide Association Studies Based on Equine Joint Angle Measurements Reveal New QTL Affecting the Conformation of Horses. Genes (Basel) 2019 May 14;10(5).
    doi: 10.3390/genes10050370pubmed: 31091839google scholar: lookup
  8. Ahmad I, Ijaz S, Usman MM, Safdar A, Khan IU, Zeeshan M, Bukhari SSUH. Evaluating Forelimb and Hindlimb Joint Conformation of Morna Racehorses (Equus caballus). Vet Sci 2025 Jan 5;12(1).
    doi: 10.3390/vetsci12010020pubmed: 39852895google scholar: lookup
  9. Guyo M, Tareke M, Tonamo A, Bediye D, Defar G. Multivariate analysis of morphometric traits of the horse ecotypes reared in highlands of Bale Zone, Ethiopia. Vet Anim Sci 2024 Sep;25:100391.
    doi: 10.1016/j.vas.2024.100391pubmed: 39280772google scholar: lookup
  10. Reich P, Möller S, Stock KF, Nolte W, von Depka Prondzinski M, Reents R, Kalm E, Kühn C, Thaller G, Falker-Gieske C, Tetens J. Genomic analyses of withers height and linear conformation traits in German Warmblood horses using imputed sequence-level genotypes. Genet Sel Evol 2024 Jun 13;56(1):45.
    doi: 10.1186/s12711-024-00914-6pubmed: 38872118google scholar: lookup
  11. Maśko M, Sikorska U, Borowska M, Zdrojkowski Ł, Jasiński T, Domino M. The Postural and Body Surface Temperature Response of Leisure Horses to Lunging with Selected Lunging Aids. Animals (Basel) 2023 Dec 20;14(1).
    doi: 10.3390/ani14010022pubmed: 38200753google scholar: lookup
  12. Borowska A, Lewczuk D. Comparison of Conformation and Movement Characteristics in Dressage and Jumping Sport Warmblood Mares Based on Point Evaluation and Linear Scoring System. Animals (Basel) 2023 Oct 4;13(19).
    doi: 10.3390/ani13193101pubmed: 37835707google scholar: lookup
  13. Ricard A, Crevier-Denoix N, Pourcelot P, Crichan H, Sabbagh M, Dumont-Saint-Priest B, Danvy S. Genetic analysis of geometric morphometric 3D visuals of French jumping horses. Genet Sel Evol 2023 Sep 18;55(1):63.
    doi: 10.1186/s12711-023-00837-8pubmed: 37723416google scholar: lookup
Subscribe to our newsletter
Join 99,357 horse owners like you who receive our email updates on horse health and nutrition.