Analyze Diet

Topic:Digestibility

Digestibility in horses refers to the process by which horses break down and absorb nutrients from their feed. It involves the mechanical and chemical breakdown of feed components in the digestive tract, enabling nutrient absorption into the bloodstream. Digestibility is influenced by various factors, including feed type, processing methods, and individual horse health. Commonly examined components include fiber, protein, starch, and fat, each requiring specific digestive processes. Research in this area often focuses on optimizing feed formulations and understanding the digestive efficiency of different feedstuffs. This page compiles peer-reviewed research studies and scholarly articles that explore the mechanisms of digestion, factors affecting digestibility, and implications for equine nutrition and health.
The effects of diet on the physical characteristics of feces and fiber digestibility in healthy horses.
Journal of animal science    August 13, 2026   skag255 doi: 10.1093/jas/skag255
Starrett A, Sarturi JO, Leatherwood JL, Chaffin MK, Mukhopadhyay S, Pilla R, Arnold CE.Diet is a known risk factor for colic, but few studies have explored how diet affects fecal characteristics which are often altered in horses with colic. This prospective cross-over study evaluated the effects of two common equine diets on fecal characteristics and fiber digestibility in healthy adult horses. We hypothesized that horses offered a complete pelleted diet would exhibit increased fecal dry matter (DM) and decreased fecal particle size compared to those offered a forage-based diet. Twenty horses at Texas Tech University School of Veterinary Medicine served as subjects in the study....
Four Haylages, One Metabonome: Defining Diet Driven Metabolic Shifts in Ponies.
Journal of animal physiology and animal nutrition    August 6, 2026   doi: 10.1111/jpn.70099
Moore-Colyer M, Harris P, Daniels S.Haylage is widely fed to all categories of stabled horses across Europe and New Zealand. Haylage can vary from high energy nutrient dense forage to low energy highly fibrous fodder, yet little is known about the impact different haylages have on metabolism in horses. This study provides the first direct comparison of feeding four different haylages: early cut (Lolium multiflorum), later cut (Lolium perenne) rye grass (R1 and R2); early and late cut meadow grass (M1 and M2), on urinary and faecal metabonomics, in ponies at maintenance. Using replicated Latin Square design, eight individually ho...
Forage nutritive analysis in practical equine feeding: challenges and opportunities.
Journal of equine veterinary science    June 18, 2026   106067 doi: 10.1016/j.jevs.2026.106067
Nilsson ST, Müller CE, Lindqvist H.Previous research has shown that forage nutritive analyses are not used to any large extent in equine nutrition. As forages differ widely in nutritional quality, knowledge of the nutritive value is essential to avoid under- or overfeeding of horses. Objective: The aim of this study was to investigate how forage nutritive analyses were used among horse owners in Sweden, and to identify challenges horse owners encounter with such analyses. Methods: Data was collected through an online survey with questions about the respondent, access to forage analytical reports, if and how the respondent used ...
Mastication characterization of horses fed bermudagrass hay in a two-part field study.
Journal of equine veterinary science    June 17, 2026   106068 doi: 10.1016/j.jevs.2026.106068
Long JF, Hutton R, Abrams A, Duberstein JA, Duberstein KJ.Bermudagrass (Cynodon dactylon L.) is a common forage in the southeastern United States but remains controversial in equine diets due to reported associations with impaction colic. Reduced fiber digestibility has been proposed as a contributing factor, however differences in mastication of fine-stemmed bermudagrass hay have not been studied and may play a role in digestive disturbances. Objective: To compare chewing characteristics, including chews per unit weight and chews per minute, in horses consuming bermudagrass hay compared to other common hay types. Methods: Two studies were conducted....
Effects of Dietary Zinc Cysteamine Supplementation on Growth Performance, Physiological Responses, and Fecal Microbiota in Weaned Foals.
Animals : an open access journal from MDPI    May 21, 2026   Volume 16, Issue 10 1568 doi: 10.3390/ani16101568
Ren J, Ma C, Yang K, Li X, Yang F, Guo X, Yao X, Wang C.Zn-CS chelate has shown beneficial effects on gut health and growth in piglets, but its impact on weaned foals remains largely unknown. This study evaluated the effects of dietary Zn-CS supplementation on growth performance, nutrient digestibility, physiological status, and fecal microbiota in weaned Ili foals. Thirty-two six-month-old foals were randomly assigned to four treatment groups receiving 0, 2, 4, or 6 mg Zn-CS/kg body weight per day for 90 days. Growth performance, nutrient digestibility, plasma biochemical parameters, liver function enzymes, serum hormones, antioxidant indices, fec...
Effects of supplementing concentrates with different energy levels on growth performance, blood indicators, and fecal microbiota of Mongolian horses in late gestation.
BMC veterinary research    May 19, 2026   doi: 10.1186/s12917-026-05568-8
Liu Y, Wang X, Wang G, Wu Z, He Q, Zhao B, Du M, Zhao Y, Bou G, Bai D, Dugarjaviin M, Zhang X.Horse breeding and management have a globally extensive history, with horses serving vital roles in transportation, warfare, agriculture, and cultural activities. In China, particularly in Inner Mongolia, the horse industry faces challenges such as harsh winters and limited nutritional research for local breeds, especially during late gestation. This critical period is essential for fetal development and maternal health, and inadequate nutrition can lead to complications like nutritional abortions and poor foal growth. Similar issues exist worldwide in cold climates or regions with seasonal pa...
The Effects of L-Citrulline on the Apparent Digestion and Metabolism of Nutrients, Blood Hormone Levels, Amino Acid Metabolism and the Diversity of Faecal Microbiota in Mares in the Later Stage of Pregnancy.
Life (Basel, Switzerland)    April 30, 2026   Volume 16, Issue 5 744 doi: 10.3390/life16050744
Liu P, Yang F, Li J, Li C, Guo X, Li X.This study aimed to investigate the impact of dietary L-citrulline supplementation on the health of mares during late gestation. Thirty-two healthy mares in late pregnancy were randomly assigned to four groups: a control group (CON, 0 g/d) and three treatment groups receiving 15, 30, and 45 g/d/head of L-citrulline, respectively. The trial spanned 72 days, including a 12-day adaptation phase and a 60-day formal feeding period. A fixed daily feeding amount of 11.2 kg/head was provided, ensuring complete consumption and consistent dry matter intake across all groups. Results demonstrated that su...
Pasture Intake of Whole-Day Stocked Thoroughbred Foals With Growth.
Animal science journal = Nihon chikusan Gakkaiho    April 28, 2026   Volume 97, Issue 1 e70168 doi: 10.1111/asj.70168
Tanabe T, Matsui A, Tominari M, Ueda K, Mitani T, Kawai M.We investigated the changes in the forage and nutrient intake of thoroughbred foals on pastures with whole-day stocking with age. Twelve thoroughbred foals were used and were allowed to graze on a pasture for 21 h/day from June to September. All foals were weaned just before 5 months of age. The pasture intake of the foals was measured using the double-indicator method. During the suckling period, the total voluntary dry matter intake (VDMI) of the pasture for foals was higher at 4 months (2.1 kgDM/day) than at 2 months (1.3 kgDM/day). However, VDMI of pastures per body weight (%BW) for foal...
Physiological and nutritional adaptation of broodmares during the transition from late pregnancy to early lactation: Digestibility changes and the role of uNDF as an internal marker.
Veterinary research communications    April 9, 2026   Volume 50, Issue 4 258 doi: 10.1007/s11259-026-11194-4
Lamanna M, Mariella J, Freccero F, Lanci A, Colleluori R, Ghiaccio F, Buonaiuto G, Valle E, Raspa F, Castagnetti C, Cavallini D.Nutritional management of broodmares during late pregnancy and early lactation is essential for maternal health and foal well-being. This study evaluated a targeted dietary adaptation during the transition from late gestation to early lactation, monitored nutrient digestibility, and applied undigested neutral detergent fiber (uNDF) as an intrinsic digestibility marker. A prospective nutritional study was conducted on 11 clinically healthy Trotter broodmares (3 primiparous, 8 multiparous) monitored under standardized conditions. Mares received a forage-based diet with controlled starch intake a...
An investigation into the impact of the inclusion of a commercial fiber-based feed, designed for both hydration and nutrition, on the equine hindgut microbiomes.
Journal of equine veterinary science    March 20, 2026   105862 doi: 10.1016/j.jevs.2026.105862
Hart KJ, Hegarty MJ, Hart EH.It is more evident that horse health is linked to the gastrointestinal tract and microbial community structure (MCS) as affected by diet. There are many marketed feeds available to enhance nutrition for horses, however the effects of these feeds on hindgut MCS are largely unknown. Objective: The aim was to test the effect of a complementary forage feed (FF) on the fermentation profile and MCS in contrasting basal diets. Methods: A 2×2 factorial design was used to assess the effect of basal diet, forage only (FOR) or forage/concentrate (MIX), and presence/absence of FF on fermentation paramete...
Finishing Performance, Meat Quality, and Economic Efficiency of Retired Thoroughbred Versus Belgian-Cross Geldings Under an Identical Total Mixed Ration: A Pilot Study.
Veterinary sciences    March 18, 2026   Volume 13, Issue 3 280 doi: 10.3390/vetsci13030280
Park C, Jeong C, Son M, Yi J.This study evaluated a 181-day finishing system for horses entering the Korean meat chain by comparing retired thoroughbred geldings and Belgian-crossbred geldings under identical management and an ad libitum forage-based total mixed ration. Ten geldings ( = 5 per group) were individually housed, with body weight and feed intake recorded monthly. After slaughter, carcass traits and meat quality grade were assessed, and longissimus thoracis et lumborum samples were analyzed for proximate composition. Belgian-crossbreds consumed more dry matter (18.68 vs. 13.60 kg DM/day), corresponding to 2.3% ...
Synergistic effects of Ferula asafoetida extract and condensed tannins from raisin pomace on in vitro cecal fermentation kinetics and nutrient digestibility in horses.
Veterinary world    March 13, 2026   Volume 19, Issue 3 905-919 doi: 10.14202/vetworld.2026.905-919
Dehghan H, Moghaddaszadeh-Ahrabi S, Hashemzadeh-Farhang H, Shahbazi P, Nobari B.The equine hindgut depends on microbial fermentation for efficient nutrient utilization but remains vulnerable to dysbiosis, hindgut acidosis, and suboptimal fiber digestion. Growing restrictions on antibiotic and synthetic feed additives have increased interest in natural phytogenic compounds. Medicinal plant extracts and condensed tannins are promising candidates to modulate microbial activity, improve fermentation efficiency, and enhance nutrient digestibility. This study aimed to investigate the individual and combined effects of hydroalcoholic extract of and condensed tannins extracted f...
Effects of Dietary Non-Fibrous Carbohydrate to Neutral Detergent Fiber Ratio on Apparent Digestibility, Fecal Microbiota, and Plasma Metabolomics in Yili Horses.
Animals : an open access journal from MDPI    March 7, 2026   Volume 16, Issue 5 844 doi: 10.3390/ani16050844
Li M, Xu Z, Sun L, Cheng Z, Yu Y, Chen Y, Li F, Zang C.This study aimed to investigate the effects of dietary NFC/NDF ratio on nutrient apparent digestibility, fecal fermentation parameters, microbial diversity, and plasma metabolomics in Yili horses. Twenty-four healthy Yili horses with similar body weights (406 ± 22.73 kg) were divided into four groups, each with six replicates: the Control Group (CG), Low-NFC Group (LG), Medium-NFC Group (MG), and High-NFC Group (HG). The experiment lasted 52 d, comprising a 7-day adaptation period and a 45-day experimental period. Total fecal collection was conducted from days 41 to 45 to calculate nutrient a...
Effect of feeder style on intake rate of equine concentrates.
Journal of equine veterinary science    February 19, 2026   Volume 159 105811 doi: 10.1016/j.jevs.2026.105811
O'Reilly K, Aldworth-Yang S, Catalano DN.There are many different concentrate feeders available to horse owners, but little data exists on feeder effect of equine intake rate. Rapid consumption ("bolting") is associated with issues such as esophageal obstruction. Objective: The objective of this study was to evaluate three common concentrate feeders on intake rate. We hypothesized horses would have the slowest intake rate when fed from the trough. Methods: Four geldings were fed 0.454 kg of concentrate from a pan on the ground (P), shallow trough (T), or hanging feeder (H). Horses were randomly assigned a first feeder and then rotate...
Feed intake, digestibility and passage kinetics in grazing horses.
Scientific reports    January 22, 2026   Volume 16, Issue 1 3052 doi: 10.1038/s41598-026-35647-7
Bachmann M, Bochnia M, Wensch-Dorendorf M, Glatter M, Schäfer S, Simroth K, Greef JM, Zeyner A.Feed intake and digestibility are important indicators for sufficient nutrient supply, but they can be assessed only to a limited extent in horses on pasture. In horses, feed intake is embedded in a complex behavioural pattern of searching, selecting, chewing and almost constant movement called foraging. The objectives of this study were to estimate organic matter intake (OMI) and organic matter digestibility (OMD) in six horses, 24 h/day on pasture, based on plant alkanes and synthetic n-hexatriacontane (C) excretion. A multi-compartmental model was fitted to the marker excretion and the C m...
Effects of Feeding Strategies on Gut Microbial Communities in Donkeys: A Comprehensive Narrative Review.
Veterinary sciences    December 20, 2025   Volume 13, Issue 1 7 doi: 10.3390/vetsci13010007
Wei L, Wei J, Liu X, Chen W, Wang C, Khan MZ, Zhang Z.Donkeys () remain nutritionally understudied despite their critical roles in agriculture across developing regions, with current feeding practices inappropriately extrapolating horse standards without accounting for species-specific digestive physiology. No comprehensive synthesis has integrated how dietary modifications systematically alter gut microbial communities to drive measurable health outcomes in donkeys, preventing development of evidence-based feeding strategies. This review critically synthesizes current evidence on donkey nutritional requirements and gut microbiota dynamics to est...
Postbiotics: Multifunctional Microbial Products Transforming Animal Health and Performance.
Veterinary sciences    December 12, 2025   Volume 12, Issue 12 1191 doi: 10.3390/vetsci12121191
Prasad S, Patel B, Kumar P, Lall R.Postbiotics, which are preparations of inanimate microorganisms and their components, have emerged as a promising functional ingredient in animal health and nutrition. Postbiotics are primarily composed of microbial cell fractions, metabolites, enzymes, vitamins, polysaccharides, and short-chain fatty acids. Unlike probiotics, postbiotics do not contain live microorganisms, which strengthens their greater stability and safety in feed/food formulations. Postbiotics offer several beneficial effects, including antioxidant, anti-inflammatory, immune-modulatory, and antimicrobial actions. They enha...
Using culture ‘omics to explore the microbial structure and function in an equid in vitro digestion model.
Scientific reports    December 1, 2025   Volume 16, Issue 1 455 doi: 10.1038/s41598-025-29936-w
Daniels S, Martin S, Harris P, Moore-Colyer M.The in vitro gas production system (GPS), developed to estimate degradation of ruminant feedstuffs, has been adapted for equine use. This study aimed to characterise the bacterial community profile and metabolome of donor faeces and faecal inoculum within the GPS when fermenting the same diet as faecal donors. Six Welsh ponies on identical diets were faecal donors with samples collected for microbiome profiling and system inoculation. Gas production (manual pressure transducer technique) was performed for 156 h with 2 replicate bottles from each donor harvested at 8,20,28 and 36 h. Faecal an...
Preliminary Assessment of Leisure Horses’ Preferences for Different Forms of Carrot (Daucus carota subsp. sativus).
Animals : an open access journal from MDPI    November 24, 2025   Volume 15, Issue 23 3385 doi: 10.3390/ani15233385
Mańkowska A, Dobraczyńska BM, Szewczak J, Chodup Z, Radzanowski B, Matychyn I, Witkowska D.Cultivated carrot ( subsp. ) is a valuable component of equine diets due to its high β-carotene content (a precursor of vitamin A) and desirable sensory properties. However, its use may be limited by short shelf life, susceptibility to spoilage, and firm texture, which can be challenging for horses with dental problems. This study aimed to evaluate horses' preferences for different physical forms of carrots. Twenty-one leisure horses aged 3-22 years were individually evaluated in a free-choice test. Each horse was simultaneously offered equal portions (150 g) of five carrot forms: raw, grated...
A comparison of fecal output determined by total fecal collection or titanium dioxide in horses.
Journal of animal science    October 28, 2025   Volume 103 skaf375 doi: 10.1093/jas/skaf375
Fowler AL, Pyles MB, Hayes SH, Crum AD, Lawrence LM.Total fecal collection studies to determine digestibility of nutrients are costly and laborious. The use of externally dosed indigestible markers, such as titanium dioxide (TiO2), to estimate digestibility using spot samples could be advantageous, but studies validating their use in horses are inadequate. Two experiments were conducted to determine if TiO2 in fecal spot samples effectively estimated fecal output in horses. In Exp. 1, four mature horses were fed a forage-based diet (85:15 forage: concentrate) split into two equal meals with 1.75 ± 0.03 g TiO2/kg DM (10 g TiO2) per day ...
The horse gut bacteriome and anaerobic mycobiome are influenced by seasonal forages and small intestinal starch digestibility.
Journal of applied microbiology    August 13, 2025   lxaf203 doi: 10.1093/jambio/lxaf203
Wunderlich G, Bull M, McGilchrist N, Zhao C, Ross T, Rose M, Chapman B.The equine gut microbiome is a complex and dynamic ecosystem, housing a diverse consortium of bacteria and anaerobic fungi (AF) capable of breaking down complex plant matter and converting it into vital energy sources for their host. The aim of this study was to broaden our current understanding of bacterial and AF diversity in the equine hindgut and how it differs between cohorts and responds to dietary shifts. Results: Faecal samples were collected from 48 horses and the bacteriome and anaerobic mycobiome analysed using long-read amplicon sequencing. Samples were collected from racehorses (R...
Total mixed ration enhances nutrient digestibility, blood biochemical parameters and faecal microbial diversity in horses.
BMC veterinary research    July 23, 2025   Volume 21, Issue 1 483 doi: 10.1186/s12917-025-04937-z
Jing H, Liu P, Zheng S, Cao K, Li X.Total Mixed Ration (TMR) is recognized for its balanced nutritional composition, improved feed efficiency, enhanced animal production, and stabilization of the gastrointestinal microbiome. It has been extensively implemented in intensive ruminant farming, particularly for cattle and sheep, with demonstrated positive outcomes. However, its effects on the nutritional health of non-ruminant herbivores, such as horses, remain insufficiently investigated. This study aims to evaluate the comparative effects of TMR feeding versus conventional feeding practices in Akhal-Teke horses while maintaining i...
Prediction of the digestibility and digestible energy content of hay for horses using an enzymatic degradability method.
Animal : an international journal of animal bioscience    July 9, 2025   Volume 19, Issue 8 101597 doi: 10.1016/j.animal.2025.101597
Andueza D, Martin-Rosset W.The nutritive value of forage for horses is closely dependent on the digestibility of organic matter (OMD), which is typically measured in vivo. Researchers have developed a variety of prediction methods to estimate the digestibility value of hay. In ruminants, pepsin-cellulase degradability, expressed as dry matter enzymatic degradability (dCS) and organic matter enzymatic degradability (dCO), is a commonly employed method for predicting OMD in forage types. The objective of this study was to evaluate the feasibility of predicting the dry matter digestibility (DMD), OMD, energy digestibility ...
Meat Production Potential of Local Horse Breeds: Sustainable Conservation Through Valorization.
Animals : an open access journal from MDPI    June 28, 2025   Volume 15, Issue 13 1911 doi: 10.3390/ani15131911
Ivanković A, Pećina M, Bittante G, Amalfitano N, Konjačić M, Kelava Ugarković N.Local horse breeds, particularly cold-blood types, are often marginalized in economic and social contexts, primarily due to the neglect of their economic, genetic, and cultural potential, as well as their role in preserving the identity of rural areas, local communities, and ecosystems. The valorization of these breeds is a crucial prerequisite for their economic repositioning. The Croatian Posavina horse is a local breed, well adapted to harsh, extensive production systems. Its sustainability is achieved through pasture-based meat production, primarily targeting foreign European markets. Ensu...
Corrigendum to “Carbohydrate digestion in the stomach of horses grazed on pasture, fed hay or hay and oats” [Journal of Equine Veterinary Science Volume 141 (2024) 105152].
Journal of equine veterinary science    June 27, 2025   Volume 151 105635 doi: 10.1016/j.jevs.2025.105635
Bachmann M, Schusser GF, Wensch-Dorendorf M, Pisch C, Bochnia M, Santo MM, Netzker H, Woitow G, Thielebein J, Kesting S, Riehl G, Greef JM....No abstract available
Dietary nonstructural carbohydrates influence synthesis of mare milk carbohydrates and yield.
Journal of animal science    June 26, 2025   Volume 103 skaf213 doi: 10.1093/jas/skaf213
Pyles MB, Fowler AL, Crum AD, Hayes SH, Schendel RR, Lawrence LM.Mare milk is the primary source of nutrients for neonatal foals and contains various carbohydrates. Milk oligosaccharides are complex carbohydrates that are resistant to enzymatic digestion and provide support for the immune system and developing microbiome in the neonate. However, factors influencing the synthesis of milk carbohydrates in the mare are not well understood. This study aimed to determine the effects of dietary nonstructural carbohydrate (NSC) on mare milk composition and yield. Thoroughbred mares were paired by age and last breeding date then randomly assigned to one of two diet...
Comparative digestibility and gas production kinetics of Tifton 85 hay in donkeys and horses.
Journal of equine veterinary science    April 26, 2025   Volume 149 105575 doi: 10.1016/j.jevs.2025.105575
de Morais CBR, Santiago JM, da Silva AH, Nascimento DBD, de Farias IM, da Silva Dias W, Taran FMP, Lucena JEC.This study aimed to verify whether donkeys of the Nordestino ecotype are more efficient than horses concerning apparent digestibility and gas production of Tifton 85 hay at different maturity stages, using the total feces collection method and the in vitro gas production technique. Four donkeys and four horses were used in a 2 × 2 factorial completely randomized design with two Equidae species and hay at two maturity stages (higher quality "Hay 1″ and lower quality "Hay 2″). No difference (P < 0,05) was found between the Equidae species for apparent nutrient digestibility of the Hay 1....
Effects of different grain types on nutrient apparent digestibility, glycemic responses, and fecal VFA content in weaned foals.
BMC veterinary research    April 14, 2025   Volume 21, Issue 1 273 doi: 10.1186/s12917-025-04716-w
Huang X, Li Q, Li X, Li C, Li J, He L, Jing H, Yang F, Li X.China's equine industry has shifted from traditional rough grazing to modern intensive farming, expanding the roles of horses into eventing, leisure, tourism, and meat and dairy production. Concurrently, equine nutrition has evolved from a forage-based diet to a more diverse regimen incorporating grain supplements to meet the heightened energy demands of intensive farming. However, nutrient digestibility and glycemic response vary considerably based on grain type, starch content, composition, and structural properties. Optimal grain selection is therefore essential for energy supplementation a...
Thermal and non-thermal effects of microwave pretreatment on horse dung microbial communities used as inoculum for acidogenic fermentation.
Bioresource technology    March 17, 2025   Volume 427 132407 doi: 10.1016/j.biortech.2025.132407
Pipereau K, Trably E, Santa-Catalina G, García-Bernet D, Carrere H.This study focuses on thermal and non-thermal effects of microwave pretreatment on horse dung as indigenous inoculum before xylose and wheat straw fermentation, emphasizing metabolite production and microbial community changes. Two horse dung microwave pretreatments (MW40°C and MW95°C) were compared with a conventional thermal pretreatment (Th95°C) and an unpretreated condition (Ctrl). Microwave heating pretreatment (MW95°C) leads to similar production as a conventional thermal pretreatment (Th95°C) for xylose and wheat straw fermentation while MW40°C treatment was similar to the control...
Novel anti-oxidative peptides from equine hemoplasma protein hydrolysates: Purification, identification and protective effects on Caco-2 cells.
Food research international (Ottawa, Ont.)    February 5, 2025   Volume 204 115943 doi: 10.1016/j.foodres.2025.115943
Ma Z, Li Y, Zhao Z, Song Q, Wang Q, Lu S, Wang J.In this study, we purified and identified antioxidant peptides from equine plasma protein hydrolysates and assessed their protective effects against HO-induced oxidative stress in Caco-2 cells. Four antioxidant peptides were identified by liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS) in equine plasma protein hydrolysate, namely: GTMVGC (567.69 Da), FGMTST (662.88 Da), VGYHSHF (847.01 Da) and ALSPFFKE (939.18 Da). Among them, ALSPFFKE showed the strongest antidigestive properties after modelled digestion studies. Moreover, ALSPFFKE enhanced intracellular superoxide dismutase (SO...
1 2 3 11